NFL Sportsbook Consensus Grading Recap — Sunday, September 27, 2026

Jamey Eisenberg had the best Sunday of anyone we graded. The CBS Sports writer went 10-3-1 for +6.09 units across 14 Week 3 games, and he was one of only twelve people in our whole log who took Washington +7 in the game that decided the day. Covers’ Trevor Knapp was right behind him at 10-4, +5.09u. Bleacher Report’s Brad Gagnon and Pickswise’s Caleb Wilfinger both went a perfect 4-0 (+3.64u each), Lineups’ Richard Janvrin went 5-1 (+3.55u), and Kyle Kargel of Picks and Parlays and VSiN’s Steve Makinen tied at 6-2 (+3.45u). Eisenberg is now 25-14-1 on everything we have graded him on this season and Knapp is 27-16 — the two highest-rated humans in our NFL ledger.

We logged 787 picks from 125 experts and models on this slate. The consensus card went 3-7 for -4.39 units: STRONG plays 3-5 (-2.39u), the two LEANs 0-2 (-2.00u). The one FADE-WATCH we flagged also lost, at zero units, and stays out of the card record. The field as a whole hit 47.7%, so this was a hard Sunday for everybody, not only for the side the consensus landed on.

What actually happened

One game beat two card plays. The consensus had Cincinnati -3.5 and the Under 42.5 in Pittsburgh, and both rested on the same premise: the Steelers had the worst offensive DVOA in the league and Aaron Rodgers was averaging 5.2 yards an attempt with nothing past 20 yards. He then went 19 of 34 for 292 yards and three touchdowns. Jaylen Warren ran for 127 on 17 carries and had an 87-yard run wiped out by a holding call. Burrow matched Rodgers throw for throw — 28 of 37, 282 yards, three scores — but with Pittsburgh up 30-27 and Cincinnati driving with 53 seconds left, Burrow was sacked and fumbled and the Steelers recovered. Fifty-seven points in a game priced for 42.5. That is not a voided premise, it is the read being beaten on the merits: the offense everyone had graded as the worst in football scored 30.

The Under in Denver was on schedule at halftime and then the roof came off. Denver trailed 16-0 at the break — 16 points through two quarters of a 44.5 total. Then Talanoa Hufanga took a Matthew Stafford interception 66 yards for a pick-six to put the Broncos up 23-19, Denver converted two-point tries on both of its second-half touchdown drives, and Bo Nix dove in from a yard out with under a minute left for 30-26. Hufanga’s second interception, on a Stafford throw to Davante Adams, ended the game. Forty second-half points between two defenses that both ranked top five.

In Indianapolis, the card’s own caution arrived exactly as written. The Over 42.5 writeup named one risk — Nico Collins out for Houston — and that is precisely what capped the game. C.J. Stroud threw for 167 yards, Xavier Hutchinson led the Texans’ receivers with 51 yards on three catches, David Montgomery gained 33 on 11 carries and Woody Marks 15 on five against a run defense that had been the softest in the league. Indianapolis won 19-17 and 36 points went on the board.

Elsewhere: Harold Fannin’s late touchdown pushed Cleveland past Carolina 21-18, so the road favourite of under three points lost outright — the exact shape the ten Cleveland takers had pointed at. San Francisco won but only by six, 36-30, which is the open back door the fourteen Arizona takers named in advance. Detroit won by exactly seven, so the consensus side covered -6.5 by half a point while one expert holding Detroit -7 pushed. And in Rio, Tyler Loop’s 56-yard field goal at the gun made it Ravens 34, Cowboys 31.

Tier record — Sunday, September 27

Tier Record Hit rate Units
STRONG 3-5-0 37.5% -2.39u
LEAN 0-2-0 0.0% -2.00u
Card total 3-7-0 30.0% -4.39u
FADE-WATCH (watch only) 0-1-0 0.0% 0.00u

Every play is graded at the line and price we posted. FADE-WATCH plays are watches, not staked plays, and are kept out of the card record.

Every play, graded

Game Consensus play Tier Final Units
✅ Baltimore @ Dallas (Rio) Over 52.5 (-118) STRONG Ravens 34-31 Cowboys — 65 pts +0.85
✅ Kansas City @ Miami Kansas City -10.5 (-112) STRONG Chiefs 24-10 Dolphins — by 14 +0.89
✅ NY Jets @ Detroit Detroit -6.5 (-115) STRONG Lions 31-24 Jets — by 7 +0.87
❌ Houston @ Indianapolis Over 42.5 (-114) STRONG Colts 19-17 Texans — 36 pts -1.00
❌ Cincinnati @ Pittsburgh Under 42.5 (-105) STRONG Steelers 30-27 Bengals — 57 pts -1.00
❌ LA Rams @ Denver Under 44.5 (-115) STRONG Broncos 30-26 Rams — 56 pts -1.00
❌ Carolina @ Cleveland Carolina -2.5 (-110) STRONG Browns 21-18 Panthers — lost by 3 -1.00
❌ Seattle @ Washington Seattle -7.5 (-105) STRONG Commanders 33-31 Seahawks — lost by 2 -1.00
❌ Cincinnati @ Pittsburgh Cincinnati -3.5 (-104) LEAN Steelers 30-27 Bengals — lost by 3 -1.00
❌ Arizona @ San Francisco San Francisco -8.5 (-110) LEAN 49ers 36-30 Cardinals — by 6 -1.00
➖ Minnesota @ Tampa Bay Tampa Bay +1.5 (-110) FADE-WATCH Vikings 23-16 Buccaneers — lost by 7 0.00

Best call and worst beat

Best call — Over 52.5 in Rio. Ten of thirteen experts were on it, and the reasoning held up completely: two banged-up secondaries, Dallas 28th in yards per rush allowed, Baltimore starting a second-year left tackle, and natural grass at the Maracana that was still being trimmed on Saturday with the NFLPA flagging slipping. The game produced 65 points and needed Tyler Loop’s 56-yarder as time expired to settle at 34-31.

Worst beat — Under 44.5 on Sunday Night Football. Sixteen points through two quarters, then a 66-yard pick-six, two successful two-point conversions, and Bo Nix diving in from the one with under a minute left. The number was 44.5 and the second half alone produced 40.

Expert scoreboard — Sunday, September 27

125 experts and models graded, 787 picks, 766 decided. The field hit 47.7%; the consensus card hit 30.0% on ten decided plays.

Best of the day Record Units Season with us Weight
CBS Sports – Jamey Eisenberg 10-3-1 +6.09u 25-14-1 1.16
Covers – Trevor Knapp 10-4-0 +5.09u 27-16 1.15
Bleacher Report – Brad Gagnon 4-0-0 +3.64u building sample 1.00
Pickswise – Caleb Wilfinger 4-0-0 +3.64u building sample 1.00
Lineups – Richard Janvrin 5-1-0 +3.55u building sample 1.00
Picks and Parlays – Kyle Kargel 6-2-0 +3.45u building sample 1.00
VSiN – Steve Makinen 6-2-0 +3.45u 15-9 1.10
Toughest day Record Units
Odds Shark Computer 19-23-0 -9.01u
SI – Peter Dewey 4-12-0 -8.36u
Athlon Sports – Ellenport 3-10-1 -7.27u
Sportsbook Review – Gary Pearson 7-13-1 -6.45u
SI – Iain MacMillan 12-14-1 -5.52u
Season leaders in our NFL ledger Graded record Hit rate Weight
SI – Albert Breer 19-8 70.4% 1.19
CBS Sports – Jamey Eisenberg 25-14-1 64.1% 1.16
Covers – Trevor Knapp 27-16 62.8% 1.15
SI – Verderame 18-10 64.3% 1.13
SI – Kadlick 18-10 64.3% 1.13
Covers – Chris Vasile 26-17 60.5% 1.12
VSiN – Steve Makinen 15-9 62.5% 1.10

How this changes the card

Our consensus weights every expert by their graded record with us, and Sunday moved the board. Jamey Eisenberg is 25-14-1 on everything we have graded him on this season and now carries a 1.16 weight, up from 1.05 before kickoff — he is the highest-rated active NFL capper in our ledger behind only Albert Breer, who has 27 decided picks at 19-8. Trevor Knapp climbed from 1.07 to 1.15 at 27-16, and Steve Makinen went from 1.03 to 1.10 at 15-9. Our rated pool grew from 39 experts to 55, because Sunday pushed sixteen more cappers past the 15-decided-pick bar.

Weight moved the other way too, and it matters most where the concentration is: Sportsbook Review’s Gary Pearson is now 16-26-1 and sits at 0.79, the lowest rating on the board, after a 7-13-1 Sunday. Athlon’s Easterling is 16-25-1 at 0.81 and the Covers Model is 23-31 at 0.84. Brad Gagnon, Caleb Wilfinger and Richard Janvrin all had excellent days but still sit at 1.00 — an expert stays neutral until 15 decided picks, and none of the three is there yet. Wilfinger is the closest of them to qualifying.

Season to date

Tier Spread Total Moneyline All Units
STRONG 3-5 9-9-1 0-1 12-15-1 -4.15u
LEAN 1-4 2-1 1-0 4-5-0 -1.85u
Card total 4-9 11-10-1 1-1 16-20-1 -6.00u
FADE-WATCH (watch only) 2-2 — — 2-2-0 0.00u

Six graded NFL dates so far this season.

Grading notes

Every pick was graded against the confirmed Week 3 final, overtime included, at the exact line and price we posted. Flat one-unit stakes throughout; expert rows without a published price are graded at -110. Twenty-one expert picks pushed: every Baltimore -3 and Dallas +3 ticket landed exactly on the number in the 34-31 final, and one Detroit -7 ticket pushed on the Lions’ seven-point win. No card play pushed. Detroit -6.5 is the one place the half point earned its money.

DailyOverlay does not make picks. We log what other experts and models publish, tier it, grade every play against the confirmed final, and rate each capper on the record. Betting involves risk — only stake what you can afford to lose. If gambling stops being fun, call 1-800-GAMBLER.

DailyOverlay Premium

Get the full graded consensus — every slate.

Free for 5 days, then $19.99/mo. Cancel anytime.

Start your free trial →