Premium Content – Signup – Consensus DFS Picks and Daily Fantasy Sports Grading

Independent expert grading since 2015

We grade every expert.
Including ourselves.

DailyOverlay reads what the DFS sites, handicappers and betting models publish, grades every pick against what actually happened, and turns the experts who are hitting into two things members use every day: DFS consensus sheets and sportsbook consensus cards. Our own consensus is graded the same way, in public, wins and misses alike.


See the grading system

Free for 5 days, then $19.99/month. Secure checkout.

PGA Expert Grading — 2026 Season

2026 SEASON

Source Picks Grades DO Score
Golf Digest 110 A 25C 17F 25 2.82
RotoGrinders 125 A 29C 23F 33 2.90
FantasyLabs 203 A 51C 31F 54 3.14
DO Consensus — GPP 201 A 62C 28F 40 3.46
DO Consensus — Cash 238 A 76C 42F 52 3.53
Rotowire 245 A 76C 41F 48 3.59
Every pick graded A+ through F against actual results. Our consensus rows are highlighted — we never hide our own scorecard.
10+years grading in public
6DFS sports: NFL · NBA · MLB · NHL · PGA · CFB, plus select coverage of NASCAR, F1 and more
1000sof picks graded every week
0hidden results — misses published too
How it works

Built from the experts who are actually hitting.

Stop paying for three subscriptions and guessing which one to trust. We track them all, grade them all, and weight the consensus toward verified performance.

STEP 01

We track the industry’s picks

Every slate, we log the published plays from the top DFS sites, handicappers and betting models — the same picks they’re charging their subscribers for.

STEP 02

We grade against real results

DFS picks are graded A+ through F on what players actually scored and roll into a season-long DO Score for every site. Betting plays are graded at the line we posted, with every handicapper’s running record. Recaps are public every morning.

STEP 03

You get the graded consensus

Before each slate locks, members get the DFS sheet and the betting card — weighted toward the sources that have earned it, and graded the next morning like everything else.

What members get

Two products, one membership.

DFS

DFS consensus sheets

Before the slate locks: every player the graded DFS sites are recommending, ranked by weighted agreement, so a site that is grading well counts for more. Cash and GPP lists by position, with salary and estimated ownership built from how many experts are on each player. Six sports, each in its season — NFL, NBA, MLB, NHL, PGA and college football — plus select coverage of NASCAR, Formula 1 and other sports.

BETTING

Sportsbook consensus cards

What the handicappers and models are on, tiered STRONG and LEAN, each with the line we captured, how many experts agree, and why. In season now: MLB every game day, NFL on Thursday, Sunday and Monday, and college football Thursday through Saturday.

GRADES

The receipts behind both

Every DFS site’s DO Score, every handicapper’s record, and our own consensus graded on the same scale. If a source stops hitting, it loses weight on the sheet and the card — and you can see it happen.

“

I built DailyOverlay because I needed this exact information to be a winning player. I use it every day, and I’ve been profitable for five straight years — I get W-9s from DraftKings and FanDuel every year, mostly playing $1–$20 MME contests. If our consensus stops earning its grade, you’ll see that on the site before you see it anywhere else.
— Greg Peters, Founder · @dailyoverlay

Pricing

Try everything free for 5 days.

Full premium access — every DFS sheet, every betting card, every grade.

5-day free trial

DailyOverlay Premium

For in-season grinders who want every edge.

$19.99 / month
Free for 5 days · then $19.99/month
  • DFS consensus sheets for 6 sports in season, plus select coverage of NASCAR, Formula 1 and more
  • Every sportsbook card, STRONG and LEAN
  • Full expert grading & DO Scores
  • Ranking history & archives

Free for 5 days, then $19.99/month. Secure checkout.

Best value · save $91

$149 / year
Free for 5 days · then $149/year (works out to $12.42/month)

Same full access, one payment a year. Free for 5 days, then $149/year until you cancel.

Questions

Fair questions, straight answers.

How is this different from RotoGrinders, DFS Army, or RunPureSports?

Those sites sell you their picks. We track and grade all of them against actual results (and many more sites), then build a consensus weighted toward the sources that are verifiably hitting. We’re the only site in the industry that publishes a season-long, pick-by-pick scorecard for every major expert — including our own consensus.

What if your consensus has a bad week?

You’ll see it. Our consensus is graded with the identical system we apply to everyone else, and the results are published weekly whether they’re good or bad. That accountability is the entire point of the site.

Which sports are covered?

DFS consensus sheets for the NFL, NBA, MLB, NHL, PGA and college football, each in its season, plus select coverage of NASCAR, Formula 1 and other sports. Betting cards for MLB, the NFL and college football. The home page lists every sheet and card for the day each morning, and the grading archives go back years in every sport.

Does the DFS sheet include ownership?

Yes — estimated Cash and GPP ownership for every player on the sheet, built from how many of the graded experts are on him. When most of the industry is on a player, the field tends to follow; when only a few experts are, that’s where the low-owned leverage is.

How does the free trial work?

You get full premium access free for 5 days. You enter your card at signup and you’re not charged during the trial. Billing starts on day 5 only if you stay — $19.99/month, or $149/year on the annual plan.

How do I cancel?

From the Manage Subscription page in your account, any time. Your access always runs to the end of the period you’re in — including all five days of a free trial — so there’s no need to cancel early to avoid a charge.

The only subscription that shows you its own report card.

Five days free. Every DFS sheet, every betting card, every grade.