CFB – DFS Expert Rankings History

College Football – DFS Expert Rankings History

FantasyGuru – Breakdown was the best-grading college football DFS source of the 2024 season, finishing with a 3.88 DO Score across the 13 sites and expert products we graded. RunPureSports was second at 3.81, RotoGrinders – Lineup HQ Top 3 third at 3.79 and RotoGrinders – Consensus fourth at 3.77. RotoGrinders – Lineup HQ Top3 topped the 2025 board at 4.49, ahead of FantasyLabs at 4.18 and RotoGrinders – Lineup Builder at 4.04. That board covers the slates graded from 28 August to 29 November 2025 and is the most recent CFB season we have graded; the 2026 season is underway now.

Who are the best college football DFS sites?

On the 2025 board the answer is RotoGrinders – Lineup HQ Top3, FantasyLabs and RotoGrinders – Lineup Builder — the CFB DFS sources whose published picks graded highest against actual results. DailyOverlay does not make picks. We read what the experts, sites and models publish for each slate, tier it, publish it, and then grade every pick against what actually happened. The season-by-season boards we have published run back to 2018.

How the DO Score works. The DO Score is the average grade earned by every pick a site published. After each slate we pull the actual DraftKings points that were scored, grade each recommended player on value, positional ranking and gross score, and weight the resulting letter grades from A+ down to F. A site’s DO Score is the average of those grades across the season, so a higher number means more of what it published actually worked. Every pick is graded against what really happened on the slate, never against a projection. Scores are measured relative to each slate, so compare sites within a season rather than across sports or seasons. The full method is in our Grading Process.

Below are the Top 5 experts in the CFB DFS Rankings over the history of DailyOverlay grading the experts.

2025 Season

Rank Expert DO Score
1 RotoGrinders – Lineup HQ Top3 4.49
2 FantasyLabs 4.18
3 RotoGrinders – Lineup Builder 4.04
4 DFSArmy – Domination Station 3.99
5 RotoGrinders – Consensus 3.89

Full 2025 Standings

2024 Season

Rank Expert DO Score
1 FantasyGuru – Breakdown 3.88
2 RunPureSports 3.81
3 RotoGrinders – Lineup HQ Top 3 3.79
4 RotoGrinders – Consensus 3.77
5 RotoGrinders – Lineup Builder 3.68


Full 2024 Standings

2023 Season

Rank Expert DO Score
1 FantasyLabs 4.30
2 RotoGrinders – Lineup HQ Top 3 4.17
3 RotoGrinders – Consensus 4.07
4 Rotoballer 3.79
5 DFSArmy – Domination Station 3.69


Full 2023 Standings

2022 Season

Rank Expert DO Score
1 DailyFantasyInsider 5.70
2 DFSKarma – Top Plays 4.71
3 RotoGrinders – Consensus 4.41
4 RotoGrinders – Lineup HQ Top 3 4.31
5 FantasyLabs 4.30


Full 2022 Standings

2021 Season

Rank Expert DO Score
1 DailyFantasyInsider 4.58
2 RotoGrinders – Lineup HQ Top 3 4.19
3 DFSKarma – Final Thoughts 4.00
4 RotoGrinders – Consensus 3.85
5 DFSKarma – Game Theory 3.83


Full 2021 Standings

2020 Season

Rank Expert DO Score
1 DailyFantasyInsider 4.56
2 RotoGrinders – Consensus 3.90
3 RotoGrinders – Lineup HQ Top 3 3.86
4 DFSAmry – Domination Station 3.80
5 DFSKarma 3.76


Full 2020 Standings

2019 Season

Rank Expert DO Score
1 DailyOverlay – Single Pick 5.71
2 DailyFantasyInsider 5.05
3 Sportsline 4.96
4 RotoGrinders – Consensus 4.62
5 SportingNews 4.00


Full 2019 Standings

2018 Season

Rank Expert DO Score
1 DailyOverlay – Single Pick 4.20
2 DFS Karma 4.08
3 RotoGrinders – CFB Marketplace Projections 3.91
4 RotoGrinders – Consensus 3.69
5 SportingNews 3.59


Full 2018 Standings