MLB Expert Grading

MLB Industry Expert Grading

The Daily Overlay team keeps track of top MLB expert predictions. We then test this information each week and share it with our visitors and top performing experts. Our goal is to see who is great, who is really good, and who is not so hot, so you will know who to trust. If you think your predictions could make it to the top of the list let us know in the comments below and we may add you to the grading. Also, check out our Grading Process.

Note: We weight A+ selections very high because the payout is much higher. Our grading consists of the selections each site has up. If the site is late getting picks available they may not be included. We grade each MLB player against overall scoring, rank of scoring, scoring value(score/salary). They then receive the best grade from those 3 scales (because our grading system is damn hard!)

[AFgradingScale]


*** See which analysts performed well in previous seasons in our MLB Expert Rankings History ***

Updated weekly. Last updated September 6, 2026

Hitters

MLB DFS Expert Hitters Rankings 2026

DFS ExpertTotal PicksA+ABCDFDK Pts/$1000DO Score
Rotoballer43691352566471722.1223.07
RotoGrinders - 6-pack25550181633331052.1092.89
Industry Consensus - Core 539277262749411721.9072.86
RotoGrinders - Consensus133724783811851555861.8482.73
DFSArmy - CheatSheet569103393273692531.8112.70
Sportsline52492343673642251.9552.69
FantasyLabs7131224746104723221.9162.63
FantasyGuru237040015214131328210821.7812.57
DK Playbook - Targets35965141943471712.0132.53
Rotowire - Optimizer7701284547108883542.0512.53
DFSArmy - Domination Station7451244144111863391.9802.53
Rotowire702118493786683441.8362.53
RunPureSports270043818515836931212381.8772.53
Industry Consensus279346117815439032012901.8502.53
DailyFantasyNerd28846201342291381.9752.47
FantasyPros115717277651481385571.8792.36
DailyFantasyFuel7761144845108953661.9682.35
RotoGrinders - Lineup Builder7731115537109943671.9822.34
OddsShopper60592382871683082.0002.32
DK Playbook - Values1101655711662.0942.05

Pitchers

MLB DFS Expert Pitcher Rankings 2026

ExpertTotal PicksA+ABCDFDK Pts/$1000DO Score
RotoGrinders - 6-pack53255463102.3065.70
Industry Consensus - Core 599391481110172.1255.21
Rotoballer742711689132.1424.97
DailyFantasyFuel1976929142624352.0964.84
Rotowire - Optimizer1946624223025272.1404.80
RotoGrinders - Lineup Builder1966731132623362.1234.79
DailyFantasyNerd7124741115102.0174.56
RotoGrinders - Consensus38711657375145811.9794.40
DFSArmy - CheatSheet2317327212143461.9044.39
FantasyPros2868440293937572.0424.34
Sportsline34210246353147811.9964.28
DFSArmy - Domination Station1975234172225472.0914.11
FantasyLabs3519741394547821.9914.07
DK Playbook - Targets1854923232331362.0454.06
OddsShopper441122504757641011.9314.06
Industry Consensus557145675876821291.9303.94
RunPureSports585148676083861411.9503.84
FantasyGuru468119544559691221.8323.81
Rotowire2355630243133611.9703.73
DK Playbook - Values571054913162.1292.95

MLB Grading Key