
PGA – DFS Expert Rankings History
NumberFire was the best-grading PGA DFS source of the 2025 season, finishing with a 3.43 DO Score across the 18 sites and expert products we graded. Rotoballer was second at 3.29 and Rotowire – Optimizer third at 3.17; our own Cash Consensus entry finished fourth at 3.13. No 2026 board has been published yet, so 2025 is the most recent PGA season we have graded end to end.
Who are the best PGA DFS sites?
For 2025 the answer is NumberFire, Rotoballer and Rotowire – Optimizer — the golf DFS sources whose published picks graded highest against actual results. Rotoballer has finished first or second on the PGA board in each of the last four graded seasons. DailyOverlay does not make picks. We read what the experts, sites and models publish for each slate, tier it, publish it, and then grade every pick against what actually happened. The season-by-season boards we have published run back to 2016-17.
How the DO Score works. The DO Score is the average grade earned by every pick a site published. After each slate we pull the actual DraftKings points that were scored, grade each recommended player on value, positional ranking and gross score, and weight the resulting letter grades from A+ down to F. A site’s DO Score is the average of those grades across the season, so a higher number means more of what it published actually worked. Every pick is graded against what really happened on the slate, never against a projection. Scores are measured relative to each slate, so compare sites within a season rather than across sports or seasons. The full method is in our Grading Process.
Below are the Top 5 experts in the PGA DFS Rankings over the history of DailyOverlay grading the experts.
2026 Season
| Rank |
Expert |
DO score |
| 1 |
Rotoballer – Lineup Picks – Zach Thompson |
4.03 |
| 2 |
OddsShopper – Cheatsheet – Sam Smith |
3.75 |
| 3 |
Rotowire – Optimizer |
3.68 |
| 4 |
Rotowire |
3.58 |
| 5 |
DailyOverlay – Cash Consensus |
3.53 |
Full 2026 Standings
2025 Season
| Rank |
Expert |
DO score |
| 1 |
NumberFire |
3.43 |
| 2 |
Rotoballer |
3.29 |
| 3 |
Rotowire – Optimizer |
3.17 |
| 4 |
DailyOverlay – Cash Consensus |
3.13 |
| 5 |
RotoGrinders – Core Plays |
3.06 |
Full 2025 Standings
2024 Season
| Rank |
Expert |
DO score |
| 1 |
Rotoballer |
3.72 |
| 2 |
Sportsline |
3.68 |
| 3 |
RotoGrinders – GPP Breakdown |
3.56 |
| 4 |
Pro Golf Now |
3.54 |
| 5 |
RotoGrinders – Lineup Builder |
3.47 |
Full 2024 Standings
2022-2023 Season
| Rank |
Expert |
DO score |
| 1 |
Rotoballer |
3.57 |
| 2 |
Rotowire – Optimizer |
3.45 |
| 3 |
DailyFantasySportsRankings |
3.35 |
| 4 |
Pro Golf Now |
3.33 |
| 5 |
RunPureSports |
3.32 |
Full 2022-2023 Standings
2021-2022 Season
| Rank |
Expert |
DO score |
| 1 |
Rotoballer (Joe Nicely) |
3.50 |
| 2 |
NBC Sports Edge (Brad Thomas) |
3.34 |
| 3 |
DailyOverlay (Cash Consensus) |
3.22 |
| 4 |
Sportsline (Mike McClure) |
3.20 |
| 5 |
RunPureSports |
3.10 |
Full 2021-2022 Standings
2020-2021 Season
| Rank |
Expert |
DO score |
| 1 |
DailyOverlay (Cash Consensus) |
3.28 |
| 2 |
RotoGrinders Core Plays (Derek Farnsworth) |
3.24 |
| 3 |
DFSArmy (DFSUpNorth) |
3.12 |
| 4 (tie) |
Rotoballer (Joe Nicely) |
3.11 |
| 4 (tie) |
Rotowire (Optimizer) & RotoGrinders (Lineup Builder) |
3.11 |
Full 2020-2021 Standings
2019-2020 Season
| Rank |
Expert |
DO score |
| 1 |
DailyRoto – Optimizer |
3.41 |
| 2 |
FantasyLabs (Justin Bailey) |
3.13 |
| 3 |
DailyFantasySportsRankings (Chris Durell) |
3.10 |
| 4 |
RotoGrinders GPP Breakdown (StlCards84) |
3.05 |
| 5 (tie) |
DFSArmy (DFSUpNorth) & Rotoworld (Josh Culp) |
3.03 |
Full 2019-2020 Standings
2018-2019 Season
| Rank |
Expert |
DO score |
| 1 |
DailyFantasyInsider |
3.30 |
| 2 |
FullTimeFantasy (Alex White) |
3.14 |
| 3 |
FantasyLabs (Justin Bailey) |
3.06 |
| 4 |
DFSArmy (Brody Schnarr) |
3.06 |
| 5 |
Fansided (Christopher Aliperto) |
2.65 |
Full 2018-2019 Standings
2017-2018 Season
| Rank |
Expert |
DO score |
| 1 |
DailyOverlay & ScoutFantasy (Ryan Baroff) |
2.753 |
| 2 |
FantasyGolfMetrics |
2.752 |
| 3 |
DailyFantasySportsRankings (Chris Durrell) |
2.70 |
| 4 |
TheFantasyGolf |
2.67 |
| 5 |
DailyOverlay – Consensus |
2.65 |
Full 2017-2018 Standings
2016-2017 Season
| Rank |
Expert |
DO score |
| 1 |
DraftKings Playbook (Brad Messersmith) |
4.18 |
| 2 |
RotoGrinders (stlcards84) |
3.13 |
| 3 |
DailyFantasyInsider |
2.95 |
| 4 |
FanSided (Brandon Raper) |
2.88 |
| 5 |
DFSOnDemand (epatterson) |
2.73 |
Full 2016-2017 Standings