NFL Handicapper Rankings — 2026 Season and Archive

NFL Handicapper Rankings — 2026 Season and Archive

Updated for the 2026 season. Every NFL handicapper below is graded by DailyOverlay against the confirmed final of each game, at the line that was posted when the pick was published. We log the picks, we grade them, and we publish the results whether they flatter anyone or not. The picks themselves belong to the handicappers who made them.

Who are the best NFL handicappers right now?

These are the 39 handicappers who have reached our minimum sample for the 2026 season — 15 decided picks — out of 164 we are currently tracking. Between them they account for 994 graded picks, with records current through Thursday, September 24, 2026.

How to read the rating. A rating of 1.00 means an expert has had no measurable effect either way. Above 1.00 means they are beating the number over a real sample of picks we have graded; below 1.00 means they are not. Nobody moves off 1.00 until they have 15 decided picks with us, and past that the rating only moves as far as the sample size honestly supports. Three weeks into a season these samples are still small, and a hot 15-pick start is not the same thing as a proven edge — read the decided-pick count alongside the rating, not the rating on its own.

# Handicapper Record Hit rate Decided picks Rating
1 SI – Breer
@AlbertBreer
19-8 70.4% 27 1.19
2 SI – Verderame
@MattVerderame
18-10 64.3% 28 1.13
3 SI – Kadlick
@mikekadlick
18-10 64.3% 28 1.13
4 SI – Peter Dewey
@peterdewey2
20-12 62.5% 32 1.12
5 SI – Geitheim
@EGeitheim
17-10 63.0% 27 1.11
6 Bleacher Report – Moton
@MoeMoton
10-5 66.7% 15 1.10
7 Bleacher Report – Davenport
@IDPSharks
10-5 66.7% 15 1.10
8 CBS Sports – Dave Richard
@daverichard
16-10 61.5% 26 1.09
9 SI – Manzano
@gmanzano24
17-11 60.7% 28 1.09
10 Covers – Jason Logan
@CoversJLo
11-7 61.1% 18 1.07
11 SI – Orr
@ConorOrr
16-11 59.3% 27 1.07
12 Covers – Chris Vasile
@mc_silly3
17-12 58.6% 29 1.07
13 Covers – Trevor Knapp
@KnappBets
17-12 58.6% 29 1.07
14 CBS Sports – Jamey Eisenberg
@JameyEisenberg
15-11 57.7% 26 1.05
15 Athlon Sports – Ellenport
@ellenport
9-7 56.3% 16 1.03
16 VSiN – Steve Makinen
@SteveMakinen
9-7 56.3% 16 1.03
17 CBS Sports – Ryan Wilson
@ryanwilsonCBS
15-12 55.6% 27 1.03
18 SI – Goldich
@mitchgoldich
15-13 53.6% 28 1.01
19 Bleacher Report – Sobleski
@brentsobleski
8-7 53.3% 15 1.01
20 SI – Pluym
@vjohn427
14-13 51.9% 27 0.99
21 CBS Sports – Tyler Sullivan
@TylerSully
15-15 50.0% 30 0.97
22 Bleacher Report – Hanford
@Ian_Hanford
7-8 46.7% 15 0.96
23 Winners and Whiners – Al MacMillan
@WinnersWhiners
21-22 48.8% 43 0.95
24 CBS Sports – John Breech
@johnbreech
13-14 48.1% 27 0.95
25 Sports Gambling Podcast – Sean Green
@SeanTGreen
7-9 43.8% 16 0.94
26 Dimers Model
@DimersCom
7-9 43.8% 16 0.94
27 Yahoo Sports – Frank Schwab
@YahooSchwab
13-16 44.8% 29 0.92
28 CBS Sports – Pete Prisco
@PriscoCBS
13-16 44.8% 29 0.92
29 SportsBettingDime – Sascha Paruk
@SBD_Sascha
20-23 46.5% 43 0.91
30 SI – Iain MacMillan
@IainMacBets
23-27 46.0% 50 0.90
31 Sportsbook Review – Gary Pearson
@newagejourno
9-13 40.9% 22 0.90
32 Bleacher Report – O'Donnell
@wesodonnell
6-10 37.5% 16 0.90
33 Bleacher Report – Knox
@Kris_Knox
12-17 41.4% 29 0.88
34 CBS Sports – Jared Dubin
@jadubin5
11-16 40.7% 27 0.88
35 Bleacher Report – Gagnon
@Brad_Gagnon
8-13 38.1% 21 0.87
36 Athlon Sports – Easterling
@LukeEasterling
11-17 39.3% 28 0.86
37 Sports Gambling Podcast – Ryan Kramer
@KramerCentric
5-11 31.3% 16 0.85
38 SportsBettingDime – Zach Reger
@zachreger18
9-16 36.0% 25 0.84
39 Covers Model
@Covers
8-20 28.6% 28 0.74

Ratings update as picks are graded. A handicapper who falls below 15 decided picks for a season does not carry a rating at all.

A gap in the record: 2021 to 2025

This page does not cover the 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024 or 2025 NFL seasons. DailyOverlay did not run handicapper grading across those years, and rather than quietly skip from 2020 to 2026 we would rather say so plainly. Grading resumed for the 2026 season and now runs daily.

The three seasons below are the last that were graded before that pause. They are kept because the records in them are real and were published at the time — not because they describe anyone’s current form. A handicapper’s 2020 result says nothing about how they are picking today, and should not be read as if it does.

Archive: 2018–2020 seasons

Note: Picks are recorded as of the Saturday prior to the NFL games for the week so that we can provide our Consensus Picks. The handicapper records shown may not reflect all of the recommended wagers by that handicapper and does not take into account any variation of units recommended by the handicapper.

NFL Handicapper Results — 2020

NFL Handicapper Results 2020

NFL Handicapper Results — 2019

NFL Handicapper Results 2019

NFL Handicapper Results — 2018

NFL Handicapper Results 2018