MLB Sportsbook Consensus — Weekly Report Card (Jun 29 – Jul 5, 2026)

Our Week-in-Review report card grades every model, expert, and free site that posted MLB picks from Monday, June 29 through Sunday, July 5, 2026, across both the moneyline and totals (Over/Under) markets — each on a binary RIGHT/WRONG basis (totals can also push). The house Daily Overlay lines are our top-consensus plays (sources agreeing ≥75%).

A strong bounce-back week: the Daily Overlay Moneyline (≥75%) went 25–10 (71.4%), +7.03u (ROI +20.1%), and the Daily Overlay Totals (≥75%) went 13–9–3 (59.1%), +2.83u (ROI +12.9%). The week’s best source in both markets was MyGameSim: +8.98u (46–32) on the moneyline and +3.77u (47–39–5) on totals. Season to date the Daily Overlay Moneyline sits at 49–37 (-0.77u) and the Daily Overlay Totals at 30–24 (+3.30u).

Notes: moneyline units are priced at each source’s posted odds (missing prices defaulted to −110); totals are graded at −110. The moneyline feed logged no picks for Sunday, July 5, so moneyline records cover Mon–Sat; totals cover all seven days. Three run-line picks in the feed were excluded from moneyline grading. Best day: Tuesday, June 30 (+3.06u combined); worst day: Friday, July 3 (−0.39u combined).

Moneyline — Per-Source Leaderboard

SourcePicksRecordHit %Net UnitsROI
MyGameSim7846–3259.0%+8.98u+11.5%
AN: Sandy Plashkes1815–383.3%+8.58u+47.7%
Pickswise1814–477.8%+8.41u+46.7%
OddsShark7846–3259.0%+4.77u+6.1%
SCP: Randy Chambers1712–570.6%+4.37u+25.7%
AN: The Degenerates86–275.0%+2.53u+31.6%
Dimers7745–3258.4%+2.40u+3.1%
SCP: Sports Chat Place33–0100.0%+2.36u+78.6%
AN: OldSchool090953–260.0%+1.90u+38.0%
AN: Sean Zerillo1911–857.9%+1.62u+8.5%
AN: Kyle Murray11–0100.0%+1.38u+138.0%
DRatings7745–3258.4%+1.07u+1.4%
SCP: Chris Ruffolo127–558.3%+1.05u+8.7%
AN: Nick Martin11–0100.0%+1.02u+102.0%
AN: Ryan Minion11–0100.0%+0.83u+83.3%
AN: The Pick Don11–0100.0%+0.74u+74.1%
AN: Picks Office32–166.7%+0.65u+21.8%
AN: Adam Kaufman3821–1755.3%+0.63u+1.7%
AN: Anthony Dabbundo11–0100.0%+0.51u+51.3%
Covers95–455.6%+0.46u+5.1%
Covers: JD Yonke11–0100.0%+0.43u+42.9%
AN: Sean Paul21–150.0%+0.10u+5.0%
AN: Doug Ziefel21–150.0%-0.17u-8.3%
Covers: Todd Cordell21–150.0%-0.41u-20.6%
AN: Jake74–357.1%-0.59u-8.4%
AN: Frank Ammirante31–233.3%-0.80u-26.7%
AN: Brian Bitler156–940.0%-0.88u-5.9%
AN: Anders10–10.0%-1.00u-100.0%
AN: tonysartori9910–10.0%-1.00u-100.0%
Covers: Chris Hatfield10–10.0%-1.00u-100.0%
Covers: Chris Faria10–10.0%-1.00u-100.0%
Covers: Shawn Krest10–10.0%-1.00u-100.0%
SCP: Nikos Lagouretos147–750.0%-1.64u-11.7%
SCP: David Racey157–846.7%-1.66u-11.0%
AN: Matt Trollo166–1037.5%-3.05u-19.1%
OddsTrader7936–4345.6%-10.12u-12.8%

Totals — Per-Source Leaderboard

SourcePicksRecordHit %Net UnitsROI
MyGameSim9147–39–554.7%+3.77u+4.4%
AN: Picks Office65–1–083.3%+3.55u+59.2%
SCP: Nikos Lagouretos54–1–080.0%+2.64u+52.8%
AN: Wags Wins43–1–075.0%+1.73u+43.2%
AN: Jake43–1–075.0%+1.73u+43.2%
Covers106–4–060.0%+1.46u+14.6%
AN: Anders11–0–0100.0%+0.91u+91.0%
Covers: Chris Hatfield11–0–0100.0%+0.91u+91.0%
Covers: JD Yonke11–0–0100.0%+0.91u+91.0%
AN: Doug Ziefel32–1–066.7%+0.82u+27.3%
OddsShark9145–41–552.3%-0.05u-0.1%
SCP: Chris Ruffolo42–2–050.0%-0.18u-4.5%
SCP: Randy Chambers62–2–250.0%-0.18u-4.5%
AN: Matt Trollo105–5–050.0%-0.45u-4.5%
AN: Brandon Kravitz2010–10–050.0%-0.90u-4.5%
AN: Nick Martin10–1–00.0%-1.00u-100.0%
Covers: Chris Faria10–1–00.0%-1.00u-100.0%
Covers: Ed Scimia10–1–00.0%-1.00u-100.0%
AN: Collin Whitchurch10–1–00.0%-1.00u-100.0%
AN: Sandy Plashkes10–1–00.0%-1.00u-100.0%
AN: Allan Lem31–2–033.3%-1.09u-36.3%
Covers: Shawn Krest31–2–033.3%-1.09u-36.3%
Covers: Todd Cordell31–2–033.3%-1.09u-36.3%
AN: Alex Hinton20–2–00.0%-2.00u-100.0%
AN: Austin Pendergrass20–2–00.0%-2.00u-100.0%
AN: The Degenerates20–2–00.0%-2.00u-100.0%
AN: John Feltman20–2–00.0%-2.00u-100.0%
Pickswise187–10–141.2%-3.63u-21.4%
DRatings9243–43–650.0%-3.87u-4.5%
AN: Frank Ammirante82–6–025.0%-4.18u-52.2%
OddsTrader9343–44–649.4%-4.87u-5.6%
SCP: David Racey81–7–012.5%-6.09u-76.1%
AN: Sean Zerillo3310–21–232.3%-11.90u-38.4%

Daily Overlay (≥75% consensus)

SegmentRecordHit %Net UnitsROI
Daily Overlay — Moneyline25–1071.4%+7.03u+20.1%
Daily Overlay — Totals13–9–359.1%+2.83u+12.9%
Daily Overlay — Moneyline (season to date)49–3757.0%-0.77u-0.9%
Daily Overlay — Totals (season to date)30–2455.6%+3.30u+6.1%

Day by Day

DateMoneyline (≥75%)ML UnitsTotals (≥75%)Totals Units
Mon, Jun 294–2+0.58u1–1–1-0.09u
Tue, Jun 306–0+4.24u2–3–2-1.18u
Wed, Jul 12–3-1.49u3–0–0+2.73u
Thu, Jul 23–1+0.98u——
Fri, Jul 34–1+1.70u1–3–0-2.09u
Sat, Jul 46–3+1.02u2–1–0+0.82u
Sun, Jul 5——4–1–0+2.64u
DailyOverlay Premium

Get the full graded consensus — every slate.

Free for 5 days, then $19.99/mo. Cancel anytime.

Start your free trial →

Season to date — the card

Live from the grading ledger, so it includes every game graded since this recap went up.

MLB consensus card

Graded Sep 29 – Oct 28 · 21 graded days
Card (STRONG + LEAN)
38-26-1
+6.55u · 59.4%
STRONG
11-14-1
-4.23u · 44%
LEAN
27-12
+10.78u · 69.2%
Last 7 graded days
0-0
0.00u · —
TierRun lineMoneylineTotal
STRONG2-1 +0.86u4-5 -1.55u5-8-1 -3.54u
LEAN5-1 +2.88u10-6 +2.21u12-5 +5.69u

FADE-WATCH (tracked, not staked, kept out of the card record): 0-1.

Every graded play, day by day →

Every sport’s consensus record →

Flat 1-unit stakes at the line and price we posted before the game. STRONG and LEAN are tiered before the game starts and graded against the confirmed final the next morning. Updated automatically from the grading ledger.