MLB Sportsbook Consensus Picks — Wild Card Tuesday, September 29, 2026
Updated Tuesday afternoon. The Wild Card round opens Tuesday with all four Game 1s on one day: Philadelphia at Atlanta at 1:00 PM CT, Chicago at Houston at 4:00 PM CT, Boston at New York at 7:00 PM CT and Chicago at San Diego at 9:00 PM CT. We first published this card Monday night and have now rebuilt it on Tuesday’s cards: the file stands at 111 picks from 52 distinct experts and models, up from 68 and 27 overnight, and the extra depth changed the board enough that two of last night’s calls no longer survive. Tiered as it stands: 1 STRONG play and 4 LEANs, with one play pulled and two markets held off the card. Philadelphia–Atlanta is already underway and is frozen exactly as published. Every Game 1 pitching plan is public, and two of the four are bullpen games rather than conventional starts. One correction is documented below rather than quietly absorbed — we would rather you see how the file is maintained than trust it blindly.
Get the full graded consensus — every slate.
Free for 5 days, then $19.99/mo. Cancel anytime.
