MLB Sportsbook Consensus Grading Recap — Tuesday, September 29, 2026

What the grading found: the sides cashed and the totals did not. Across the four Wild Card Game 1s on Tuesday September 29 the consensus went 2-0 on run lines and 2-0 on moneylines — four for four on picking teams — while the three total plays came back 1-2. The single best read on the board was the one the consensus had the most agreement on: all four run-line picks in Philadelphia–Atlanta were on Braves -1.5 and Atlanta won by exactly two.

The full card graded 5-2 (+1.87 units) at the lines we posted, a 71.4% hit rate on seven plays. STRONG plays went 1-1 for -0.09 units — the Braves run line won, the Boston–New York Under 6.5 lost — while the LEANs went 4-1 for +1.96 units. We logged 111 picks from 52 distinct experts and models on this slate, tiered it into 1 STRONG and 4 LEANs plus the two locked Philadelphia–Atlanta plays, and graded every one against the confirmed final.

What actually happened

Houston’s opener never got out of the first inning and that one fact decided both plays in that game. A.J. Blubaugh walked three and gave up a run on 27 pitches and was pulled with the first inning still in progress; Miguel Ullola covered three innings behind him. Chicago scored in the first, added two in the second and got a Colson Montgomery home run in the fourth. Hagen Smith worked three scoreless as the White Sox opener with Grant Taylor following. With Houston’s bullpen covering nine innings from the first batter on, Chicago won 6-3 — the White Sox +1.5 cashed without needing the insurance run, and 9 total runs carried the Over. One early hook, both plays.

Boston–New York was alive for six innings. Cam Schlittler did exactly what the consensus said he would, shutting Boston out on three hits, and through six the game sat 2-0 with two total runs against a 6.5. The Under did not lose on the starting-pitching read. It lost because the Yankees put up two in the seventh and five in the eighth off the Boston bullpen, turning a 2-0 game into 9-0. The same seven runs made the Yankees moneyline a winner.

Atlanta won on one swing. Chris Sale struck out nine over 6.1 innings and gave up three runs, two on a J.T. Realmuto triple in the seventh that put Philadelphia ahead. Austin Riley then homered three runs off Jhoan Duran in the eighth — on a 99.9 mph fastball, the hardest pitch he has ever homered against — for a 5-3 final, Raisel Iglesias saving it. That homer is why Braves -1.5 cashed by the exact margin and why the Under 6.5 in the same game lost: it pushed the total to eight.

San Diego was never in doubt. Fernando Tatis Jr. homered on the first pitch of the game, the Padres hung four on Matthew Boyd early, and Michael King carried a no-hitter into the seventh before finishing seven shutout innings on one hit, three walks and eight strikeouts. Padres 8-0.

Tier record

  • STRONG 1-1-0, 50.0%, -0.09 units
  • LEAN 4-1-0, 80.0%, +1.96 units
  • Card total 5-2-0, 71.4%, +1.87 units

Every play graded at the line we posted. No FADE-WATCH and no first-five-innings plays ran.

Every play graded

  • WIN · STRONG · Phillies @ Braves · RUN LINE Braves -1.5 (-110) · 4 of 4 · Braves 5-3 Phillies · +0.91
  • WIN · LEAN · Cubs @ Padres · MONEYLINE Padres (-127) · 14 of 22 (64%) · Padres 8-0 Cubs · +0.79
  • WIN · LEAN · White Sox @ Astros · TOTAL Over 8.5 (-110) · 5 of 8 (63%) · White Sox 6-3 Astros · +0.91
  • WIN · LEAN · Red Sox @ Yankees · MONEYLINE Yankees (-137) · 6 of 9 (67%) · Yankees 9-0 Red Sox · +0.73
  • WIN · LEAN · White Sox @ Astros · RUN LINE White Sox +1.5 (-190) · 4 of 5 (80%) · White Sox 6-3 Astros · +0.53
  • LOSS · STRONG · Red Sox @ Yankees · TOTAL Under 6.5 (-120) · 10 of 14 (71%) · Yankees 9-0 Red Sox · -1.00
  • LOSS · LEAN · Phillies @ Braves · TOTAL Under 6.5 (-110) · 4 of 6 (67%) · Braves 5-3 Phillies · -1.00

Arithmetic: Braves by 2 covers -1.5. White Sox won by 3 covering +1.5 outright. 6 + 3 = 9 runs so Over 8.5 cashes. 9 + 0 = 9 runs against 6.5 so that Under loses. 5 + 3 = 8 runs against 6.5 so that Under loses too. The Houston total was posted across two numbers (four Overs at 8.5 and one at 8) and is graded at the plurality 8.5; at 9 runs the Over wins at both so the split changes nothing.

Best call

Braves -1.5 at 4 of 4 agreement. A unanimous run-line file is rare and this one needed the exact right margin: Riley’s three-run homer off a 99.9 mph Duran fastball made it 5-3, the smallest winning margin that covers -1.5. The run line was the better side of its own game; the Atlanta moneyline ran eight of nine the same way and the consensus found the version with the price attached.

Worst beat

Boston–New York Under 6.5, the deepest agreement on the board at 10 of 14. A beat rather than a bad read: Schlittler shut Boston out on three hits, exactly the case the Under was built on, and through six the game had produced two runs. The Yankees then scored seven across the seventh and eighth. The consensus was right about the arm it handicapped and lost anyway, because the Under also needed Boston’s relievers to hold a game their team was never in.

Expert scoreboard

There is none for this date and the reason is ours to report. This card published with expert names deliberately held until grading, the correct order, but no expert-picks ledger was ever written for September 29, so the 111 individual picks from 52 sources cannot now be attributed to the people who made them. We are not going to guess at names to fill a table. No expert rows are graded for this date and nobody is named; the consensus counts above are what survives and they are accurate.

How this changes the card

Nothing yet and we will not pretend otherwise. An expert stays at a neutral 1.00 weight until we have graded 15 decided picks from them, and the MLB ledger currently has zero experts with a rated sample; this is the first MLB date we have graded this postseason. No play on this card was weighted by anyone’s record because there were no MLB records to weight it by. The Division Series card carries a full expert ledger, so from Game 1 onward every MLB pick gets logged to a name, graded and counted toward that person’s weight.

Graded record for this date

Run line 2-0-0, +1.44 · Moneyline 2-0-0, +1.52 · Totals 1-2-0, -1.09 · First five innings none ran, 0.00 · Card (STRONG + LEAN) 5-2-0, +1.87

By tier and market: STRONG run line 1-0-0 (+0.91), STRONG totals 0-1-0 (-1.00); LEAN run line 1-0-0 (+0.53), LEAN moneyline 2-0-0 (+1.52), LEAN totals 1-1-0 (-0.09). September 29 is the first graded MLB date of this postseason so these are also the season-to-date numbers for the round.

Grading notes

  • All four finals confirmed from Baseball Reference box scores. All four games went nine innings; none shortened, suspended or postponed.
  • This is a backfill: games finished September 29 and were graded October 3, because no MLB postseason grading task existed until now.
  • No Drive source sheet was created for this card so it was reconstructed from the published article, every pick line and consensus count taken verbatim from what we posted before first pitch.
  • Prices: four plays were quoted as ranges and are graded at the mid of the posted range (Under 6.5 at -120, White Sox +1.5 at -190, Padres at -127, Yankees at -137). The two locked Philadelphia–Atlanta plays carried no posted price and are graded at -110.
  • The two Philadelphia–Atlanta plays were frozen as published Monday night with no Tuesday refresh because that game had already started when the morning cards landed.

Please bet responsibly. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER.

DailyOverlay Premium

Get the full graded consensus — every slate.

Free for 5 days, then $19.99/mo. Cancel anytime.

Start your free trial →