MLB Sportsbook Consensus Grading Recap — Saturday, October 03, 2026
Four Division Series openers, 45 experts and models logged, 106 picks graded against the confirmed finals. The consensus card went 4-2-0 for +1.57 units, and the day belonged to Anthony Rome of TheSpread, who went a perfect 5-0 for +4.71 units — the best single-day return we have graded from any MLB capper this postseason.
Anthony Rome went a perfect 5-0 on Division Series Saturday
Rome’s card at TheSpread hit on every number: the White Sox moneyline at +127, the Dodgers run line at -105, the Yankees-Rays Under 7 at -110, and two first-five-innings plays. Casey Whitmore of TheRX logged the heaviest volume of anyone in the green, going 6-2 for +3.35 units across all four games. Mike Spector of Sportsbook Review went 3-0 for +2.79 units, and Shawn Krest of Covers matched him at 3-0 for +2.73 units.
We grade every play at the exact price the expert published, at flat one-unit stakes. Where no price was published, the row is graded at -110 per our standing rule.
The consensus card: 4-2-0, +1.57 units
Six plays made the card. The lone STRONG play cashed, and the LEAN tier went 3-2.
| Tier | Record | Units |
|---|---|---|
| STRONG | 1-0-0 | +0.95u |
| LEAN | 3-2-0 | +0.62u |
| Card total | 4-2-0 (66.7%) | +1.57u |
By market: run line 1-0-0 (+0.95u), moneyline 0-1-0 (-1.00u), totals 3-1-0 (+1.62u). The totals carried the day — three of the four Unders on the card cashed, and the one Over lost.
What actually happened
Dodgers 5, Braves 3. Los Angeles won by two, which clears the -1.5 run line, and the eight combined runs landed under 8.5 by exactly half a run. Both numbers on this game cashed. Worth noting: a separate Under 8 at -115 published by Kim Smith of Picks and Parlays pushed at exactly eight runs — both numbers graded correctly at their own totals.
Rays 1, Yankees 0. The lowest-scoring game of the day, and the one that split the field. The Under 7 cashed by six runs, but the Yankees moneyline at +113 — the play the consensus leaned toward at 57% — lost outright. Tampa Bay won a one-run game on a single run.
Brewers 3, Padres 2. Five combined runs, so the Under 7 cashed comfortably. Milwaukee won but failed to cover -1.5, which rewarded everyone holding the Padres +1.5.
White Sox 3, Guardians 0. The upset of the day and the one that cost the card. The consensus took Over 7 at +102 in a game that produced three runs. Chicago’s shutout also beat the Guardians moneyline, which much of the field had backed.
Every play, graded
| Matchup | Bet | Consensus pick | Tier | Result | Units |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Braves @ Dodgers | Run line | Dodgers -1.5 (-105) DraftKings | STRONG | WIN | +0.95 |
| Yankees @ Rays | Moneyline | Yankees ML +113 DraftKings | LEAN | LOSS | -1.00 |
| Padres @ Brewers | Total | Under 7 (-110) DraftKings | LEAN | WIN | +0.91 |
| Yankees @ Rays | Total | Under 7 (-113) DraftKings | LEAN | WIN | +0.88 |
| White Sox @ Guardians | Total | Over 7 (+102) DraftKings | LEAN | LOSS | -1.00 |
| Braves @ Dodgers | Total | Under 8.5 (-120) FanDuel | LEAN | WIN | +0.83 |
Best call and worst beat
Best call: the Braves-Dodgers Under 8.5, the only play on the card with unanimous agreement — 4 of 4 experts who published a total on that game took the Under, nobody took the Over. It cashed by half a run. Unanimity on this card is rare and it was right.
Worst beat: the White Sox-Guardians Over 7. Two-thirds of the experts publishing a total there wanted the Over, and the game delivered a three-run shutout in the other direction. The reasoning on that side pointed at Chicago starting an unconventional arm with almost no major-league track record; the game went the opposite way, and the field’s moneyline exposure to Cleveland compounded it.
The expert scoreboard
Best of the day. Records include first-five-innings plays where an expert published them; we grade F5 separately from full-game markets.
| Expert | Outlet | Record | Units |
|---|---|---|---|
| Anthony Rome | TheSpread | 5-0-0 | +4.71u |
| Casey Whitmore | TheRX | 6-2-0 | +3.35u |
| Mike Spector | Sportsbook Review | 3-0-0 | +2.79u |
| Shawn Krest | Covers | 3-0-0 | +2.73u |
| Kim Smith | Picks and Parlays | 5-2-1 | +2.15u |
| Joe Jensen | Predictem | 3-1-0 | +2.14u |
| Ethan Diamandas | Covers | 2-0-0 | +1.82u |
| Alexander Ansted | RG.org | 2-0-0 | +1.74u |
| Parlay’s Pundit | Doc’s Sports | 2-0-0 | +1.37u |
| Billy Coleman | Winners and Whiners | 1-0-0 | +1.32u |
Toughest day. Reported in full, because a ledger that only shows winners is not a ledger.
| Expert | Outlet | Record | Units |
|---|---|---|---|
| SportsGrid Model | SportsGrid | 2-10-0 | -8.18u |
| Thom Cunningham | Lineups.com | 0-4-0 | -4.00u |
| Ricky Dimon | Pickswise | 0-3-0 | -3.00u |
| Ryan Gilbert | Sports Illustrated | 1-3-0 | -2.05u |
| Todd Cordell | Covers | 0-2-0 | -2.00u |
| Michael Harrison | SportsBettingDime | 0-2-0 | -2.00u |
The SportsGrid Model published the widest slate of anyone — 12 graded picks — and went 2-10 on them, largely by backing Cleveland and Atlanta across multiple markets in both games that broke the other way. Volume cuts both directions, and on this day it cut hard.
The field as a whole went 58-47-1 for +5.81 units across 45 distinct experts and models on 106 logged picks. That is a 55.2% hit rate on the 105 decided picks — the field beat the number, and the consensus card beat the field on hit rate while logging far fewer plays.
How this changes the weighting
It does not change it yet. No MLB expert is weighted on our board at this point: our rated count is zero, because weighting requires a minimum of 15 graded picks and nobody has reached it. The closest are the SportsGrid Model at 12 graded picks, Casey Whitmore and Kim Smith at 8 each, and Anthony Rome at 5. Until those thresholds are met, MLB tiering runs on raw agreement rather than on the record each source has built with us.
That is a deliberate choice. A 5-0 day is a terrific day and it is also five picks — not enough for us to start weighting someone’s opinion more heavily than the field’s.
Season to date
| Tier | Record | Units |
|---|---|---|
| STRONG | 2-1-0 | +0.86u |
| LEAN | 7-3-0 | +2.58u |
| All plays | 9-4-0 | +3.44u |
That covers the two graded MLB dates of the postseason so far.
Grading notes
- Finals confirmed against ESPN, MLB.com and plaintextsports line scores before any play was graded.
- Units are flat one-unit stakes at the exact price in the published line. Where an expert published no price, the row is graded at -110.
- One row was published without a sign, as “115”, and is graded as +115 exactly as published rather than reinterpreted.
- Four first-five-innings plays are graded here in full but are excluded from the site ledger’s tier totals, because the ledger has no F5 market key. F5 grades use the score after five complete innings only: White Sox 2-0 Guardians, Dodgers 2-0 Braves, Rays 1-0 Yankees, Brewers 2-2 Padres.
- Three rows were priced only on prediction markets in cents. The side is graded; the cents were not converted into American odds, so those rows are graded at -110.
- Several experts publish at two outlets under different bylines. Where the picks differ by outlet, each is logged separately against the outlet that published it.
Betting involves risk and no record guarantees a future result. Bet only what you can afford to lose. If gambling stops being entertainment, call 1-800-GAMBLER.
Get the full graded consensus — every slate.
Free for 5 days, then $19.99/mo. Cancel anytime.
