NFL Sportsbook Consensus Grading Recap — Sunday, October 18, 2026

Iain MacMillan of SI had the biggest Sunday of anyone we logged: 18-9 for +7.46u across all 12 games, taking his season record with us to 72-66-2. Bleacher Report’s Moton went 9-3 (+5.19u, now 31-30-2 on the season), and SI’s Manzano went 9-3 (+4.38u) to move to 36-20-1, the best-weighted record in the consensus.

Sportsbook Review’s Liam Fox went 12-5 (+3.76u, 17-12 with us), and three experts ran the table on three picks apiece: Will Brinson (CBS Sports), Nikos Lagouretos (Sports Chat Place) and Garrett Kerman (ClutchPoints), each 3-0 for +2.73u. We graded 551 picks from 86 experts at the posted line.

The consensus card went 4-5 for -1.38u. STRONG 4-4 (-0.38u), LEAN 0-1 (-1.00u). The STRONG totals went 3-1 (+1.69u) and the STRONG sides 1-3 (-2.07u). Every play is graded at the line we posted.

What actually happened

The totals carried the card. Chargers-Chiefs finished 22-6, a combined 28 that never threatened the 41.5: Justin Herbert threw a second-quarter interception that handed Kansas City the ball at the Los Angeles 17, and the Chargers stalled in the red zone all day, settling for a field goal after a 57-yard play to the 1 and turning it over on downs inside the 10 in the final minute. That same game delivered the STRONG Chiefs -7.5, a 16-point win. Bills-Raiders sailed past 53.5 at 63 points, and Cardinals-Rams stayed well under 51.5 at 34.

The sides went the other way. The Rams, laid at -12.5, lost outright 18-16: with left tackle Alaric Jackson out on suspension, Matthew Stafford was sacked three times and the offense had nine points for most of the afternoon, then an 86-yard drive took a 16-15 lead with 47 seconds left before an unnecessary roughness call on Josh Wallace set up Chad Ryland’s 43-yard field goal at the gun. The Saints forced four turnovers, two of them Martin Emerson Jr. interceptions, and led 34-10 before the Giants scored late to finish 34-27, well short of +1.5. In London, the Texans beat the Jaguars 34-31 on Ka’imi Fairbairn’s 49-yard field goal on the final play after Jacksonville had tied it with 1:55 left.

Sunday night’s Over 53.5 never got close. Dak Prescott threw two first-half interceptions that both turned into Green Bay points, the Packers led 17-0 at halftime and won 23-13, a combined 36. The LEAN on the Patriots -7.5 fell a half-point short: Drake Maye threw three touchdown passes and New England led 17-3 at the half, but Andy Borregales missed an extra point and the Jets’ late score made it 26-19, a seven-point win. None of the card’s premises were voided by a pregame scratch or an early injury; the losing plays were beaten on the field.

The card, by tier

Tier Record Hit rate Units
STRONG 4-4-0 50% -0.38u
LEAN 0-1-0 0% -1.00u
Card (STRONG + LEAN) 4-5-0 44% -1.38u

Every play is graded at the line we posted.

Every play

Result Tier Play Line Final Grading
❌ LOSS STRONG Cardinals @ Rams — Rams -12.5 -112 DraftKings Cardinals 18-16 Rams Rams 16-18 margin -2 -12.5 -> -14.5 · -1.00u
✅ WIN STRONG Chargers @ Chiefs — Chiefs -7.5 -108 DraftKings Chargers 6-22 Chiefs Chiefs 22-6 margin +16 -7.5 -> +8.5 · +0.93u
❌ LOSS STRONG Saints @ Giants — Giants +1.5 -122 DraftKings Saints 34-27 Giants Giants 27-34 margin -7 +1.5 -> -5.5 · -1.00u
❌ LOSS STRONG Texans @ Jaguars — Jaguars -2.5 -120 DraftKings Texans 34-31 Jaguars Jaguars 31-34 margin -3 -2.5 -> -5.5 · -1.00u
✅ WIN STRONG Chargers @ Chiefs — Under 41.5 -118 DraftKings Chargers 6-22 Chiefs 6+22=28 vs Under 41.5 · +0.85u
❌ LOSS STRONG Cowboys @ Packers — Over 53.5 -105 DraftKings Cowboys 13-23 Packers 13+23=36 vs Over 53.5 · -1.00u
✅ WIN STRONG Bills @ Raiders — Over 53.5 -110 DraftKings Bills 33-30 Raiders 33+30=63 vs Over 53.5 · +0.91u
✅ WIN STRONG Cardinals @ Rams — Under 51.5 -108 DraftKings Cardinals 18-16 Rams 18+16=34 vs Under 51.5 · +0.93u
❌ LOSS LEAN Jets @ Patriots — Patriots -7.5 -108 DraftKings Jets 19-26 Patriots Patriots 26-19 margin +7 -7.5 -> -0.5 · -1.00u

Best call: Chiefs -7.5 (STRONG): Kansas City won 22-6 and covered by 8.5. Herbert’s second-quarter interception gave the Chiefs a short field, and the Chargers came away empty or with field goals on every red-zone trip, including a turnover on downs inside the 10 in the final minute.

Worst beat: Patriots -7.5 (LEAN): New England won 26-19 and missed the cover by a half-point. Andy Borregales missed an extra point that would have made it an eight-point game, and the Jets’ late touchdown left the margin at exactly seven.

Expert scoreboard — Sunday, Oct 18

We graded 551 picks from 86 experts and models. The field went 270-276 (49.5%) against the consensus card’s 4-5 (44%).

Top of the day Pick Record Units
SI – Iain MacMillan 27 picks across all 12 games 18-9-0 +7.46u
Bleacher Report – Moton 12 picks against the spread, including Panthers +1.5 9-3-0 +5.19u
SI – Manzano 12 moneyline picks, including Titans ML +260 9-3-0 +4.38u
Sportsbook Review – Liam Fox 17 picks, including Under 51.5 Cardinals-Rams 12-5-0 +3.76u
CBS Sports – Will Brinson Chiefs -7.5; Texans +2.5; Over 46.5 3-0-0 +2.73u

Also perfect on the day: Nikos Lagouretos (Sports Chat Place) 3-0, including Browns +4.5 and Bears ML, and Garrett Kerman (ClutchPoints) 3-0 with Panthers +1.5, Texans +2.5 and Jets +7.5. SI’s Kadlick went 8-4 (+2.68u) and VSiN’s Wes Reynolds and Sportsbook Review’s Mike Spector each went 4-1 (+2.64u). At the bottom of the day, Athlon Sports’ Ellenport went 2-10 (-8.18u), and Bleacher Report’s Knox, Gagnon and O’Donnell each went 3-9 (-6.27u). The field as a whole went 270-276-5.

Season leaders (NFL, graded with us) Record Units Consensus weight
VSiN – Zachary Cohen 13-5 +8.20u 1.15
CBS Sports – Jordan Dajani 20-11 +7.20u 1.14
SportsLine Model 17-9-3 +6.66u 1.13
VSiN – Steve Makinen 26-18-2 +5.71u 1.10
Pickdawgz – David Racey 10-4 +5.27u 1.00 (14 of 15 decided)
Pickswise – Andrew Wilsher 8-3 +5.17u 1.00 (11 of 15 decided)
WagerTalk – The Gold Sheet 6-1 +4.87u 1.00 (7 of 15 decided)

How this changes the card

SI’s Manzano now carries the heaviest weight in the consensus, up from 1.13 to 1.20 on a 36-20-1 record, with SI’s Breer next at 1.19 (34-19-1). SI’s Kadlick (32-23-1) and VSiN’s Wes Reynolds (21-14) each moved from 1.05 to 1.10, while the SportsBettingDime AI Model slipped from 1.16 to 1.06 after a 3-8-1 day. Four more experts crossed the 15-decided-pick threshold, bringing the rated pool to 79; the lowest weights belong to Athlon Sports’ Easterling (0.73, 32-49-3) and Bleacher Report’s Knox (0.76, 32-47-1).

Season to date

Tier All Spread Moneyline Total Units
STRONG 19-30-1 5-11 1-4 13-15-1 -12.49u
LEAN 10-18 4-16 1-1 5-1 -9.33u
FADE-WATCH (not staked) 4-2 3-2 — 1-0 —
Card (STRONG + LEAN) 29-48-1 -21.82u

Every card, every sport: the full consensus record.

29 expert rows carried no sportsbook price and are graded at -110, as is VSiN’s Saints PK (graded as a zero-point spread). Steelers-Buccaneers went to overtime (26-19 Steelers) and overtime counts; no card play was on that game. For Texans-Jaguars, Bears-Falcons, Ravens-Browns and Titans-Colts, game details come from published box scores and play-by-play.

Please bet responsibly. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER.

DailyOverlay Premium

Get the full graded consensus — every slate.

Free for 5 days, then $19.99/mo. Cancel anytime.

Start your free trial →