CFB Sportsbook Consensus Grading Recap — Thursday, October 22, 2026

Pete Fiutak and Connor O’Gara of College Football News both went 2-0 (+1.82u) on Thursday night, taking the points with Appalachian State +10.5 and East Carolina +10.5 — and both dogs covered. Fiutak is now 52-49 across 101 graded picks with us; O’Gara moves to 37-36.

Dimers Model went 4-2 (+1.64u) on six plays: App State +11.5, App State on the moneyline, Memphis on the moneyline and Over 53.5 in Memphis-ECU all cashed. That lifts the model to 34-34-1 on the season with us. Napier Montgomery (Pickswise) had App State +11.5 at -104 (1-0, +0.96u) and is now 13-8, +5.73u — one of the better rated records in our CFB ledger. Also perfect on the night: Ryan Gilbert (SI) on App State +10.5, Chinmay Vaidya (CBS Sports) and Tony Sink (Doc’s Sports) on East Carolina, and Chris Ruffolo (Pick Dawgz) on Over 56.5 in JMU-App State.

The consensus card went 0-4 for -4.00u. STRONG 0-2 (-2.00u), LEAN 0-2 (-2.00u). Every play is graded at the line we posted.

What actually happened

Appalachian State 34, James Madison 31 (OT). The Dukes led 14-10 at the half and 21-13 after three quarters, but App State tied it at 21 with a touchdown and two-point conversion. After a Morgan Suarez field goal put JMU up 24-21, Colton Phares intercepted Camden Coleman with 6:03 left and returned it to the JMU 14, and Henry Hasselbeck hit Luke Douglas from 4 yards out for a 31-24 lead. Coleman tied it on a 6-yard quarterback draw with 3 seconds left. In overtime Suarez’s 47-yard try hit the left upright and James London won it with a 40-yarder. No quarterback injury or benching decided this one — App State won it on the merits, with the Phares interception the swing play.

For the card, that meant the LEAN on James Madison -11.5 lost outright. The STRONG Under 56.5 was the cruelest result of the night: the score sat at 31-24 — 55 points, under the number — until Coleman’s tying touchdown with 3 seconds left in regulation pushed it to 62. The fourth quarter alone produced 28 points.

Memphis 41, East Carolina 34 (OT). East Carolina led 10-0 after one and 16-3 at the half, even after starting quarterback Emory Williams (5 of 13, 61 yards) gave way to Mitch Griffis early in the second quarter; the published recaps do not say whether Williams was hurt or benched. Memphis quarterback Marcus Stokes then took over — 320 passing yards, three touchdown passes and two rushing scores, all after halftime — and Memphis scored 17 in the third. Stokes’ 2-yard run made it 34-27 with 3:31 left, but Griffis found Landon Sides for a 20-yard touchdown on 4th-and-9 to force overtime. Stokes ran in from 5 yards in OT and Ellis Ellis Jr. intercepted Griffis in the end zone to end it.

The LEAN on Memphis -10.5 lost — the Tigers won by seven, and their regulation lead topped out at 34-27. The STRONG Under 54.5 lost too: a game that was 19 points at the half finished regulation at 68 and 75 with overtime. The consensus case for the Under rested on a slow, run-first East Carolina offense; instead Memphis scored 31 points after halftime in regulation and the game opened up. That was the consensus being beaten on the merits, not a voided premise.

The card, by tier

Tier Record Hit rate Units
STRONG 0-2-0 0% -2.00u
LEAN 0-2-0 0% -2.00u
Card (STRONG + LEAN) 0-4-0 0% -4.00u

Every play is graded at the line we posted.

Every play

Result Tier Play Line Final Grading
❌ LOSS STRONG East Carolina @ Memphis — Under 54.5 -112 DraftKings Memphis 41-34 East Carolina (OT) 34 + 41 = 75 vs Under 54.5 (68 in regulation) — loses · -1.00u
❌ LOSS STRONG James Madison @ Appalachian State — Under 56.5 -110 DraftKings Appalachian State 34-31 James Madison (OT) 31 + 34 = 65 vs Under 56.5 (62 in regulation) — loses · -1.00u
❌ LOSS LEAN James Madison @ Appalachian State — James Madison -11.5 -105 DraftKings Appalachian State 34-31 James Madison (OT) James Madison lost by 3 — fails to cover -11.5 · -1.00u
❌ LOSS LEAN East Carolina @ Memphis — Memphis -10.5 -108 DraftKings Memphis 41-34 East Carolina (OT) Memphis by 7 — fails to cover -10.5 · -1.00u

Best call: Napier Montgomery (Pickswise) on Appalachian State +11.5 at -104: his read was that the number was inflated and a fair line sat nearer a touchdown. App State not only covered but won outright, 34-31 in overtime, on Colton Phares’ late interception and James London’s 40-yard field goal.

Worst beat: The STRONG Under 56.5 in James Madison-App State. It stood at 31-24 — 55 total points, under the number — until Camden Coleman’s 6-yard quarterback draw with 3 seconds left tied the game and pushed regulation to 62. Overtime added three more.

Expert scoreboard — Thursday, Oct 22

We graded 78 picks from 39 experts and models. The field went 28-50 (35.9%) against the consensus card’s 0-4 (0%).

Top of the day Pick Record Units
College Football News – Pete Fiutak App State +10.5; East Carolina +10.5 2-0-0 +1.82u
College Football News – Connor O'Gara App State +10.5; East Carolina +10.5 2-0-0 +1.82u
Dimers Model App State +11.5; App State ML; Memphis ML; Over 53.5 (ECU-Memphis) 4-2-0 +1.64u
Pickswise – Napier Montgomery App State +11.5 (-104) 1-0-0 +0.96u
SI – Ryan Gilbert App State +10.5 (-110) 1-0-0 +0.91u

Also on the right side: Chinmay Vaidya (CBS Sports) and Tony Sink (Doc’s Sports) with East Carolina +10 and +10.5; Chris Ruffolo (Pick Dawgz) with Over 56.5 in JMU-App State; Steve Makinen (VSiN) with Over 54.5 in ECU-Memphis; and David Anicetti (StatSalt), who split 2-2 with both Overs. The College Football News grid’s split on the two dogs left most of its panel 1-1. The field went 28-50 overall — the favorites and the Unders were where the losses piled up. At the bottom of the night: Kim Smith (Picks and Parlays) 0-4 (-4.00u) and Kyle Kargel (WagerTalk) 1-4 (-3.15u), whose only win was East Carolina +10.5 at -118.

Season leaders (CFB, graded with us) Record Units Consensus weight
DRatings Model 30-12 +15.30u 1.27
CBS Sports – John Talty 37-19 +14.67u 1.23
College Football News – Andre Cherry 45-28 +13.03u 1.18
CBS Sports – Chris Hummer 46-31-3 +10.86u 1.15
College Football News – Doug Millen 43-30 +9.21u 1.13
SportsLine Model 24-13-1 +8.86u 1.16
Lineups – Thom Cunningham 13-4 +8.00u 1.18

How this changes the card

89 CFB experts are now rated (15+ decided picks). Napier Montgomery (Pickswise) gains weight to 1.08 at 13-8, and Pete Fiutak (College Football News) ticks up to 0.98 at 52-49. Kim Smith (Picks and Parlays) drops from 1.07 to 1.02 after an 0-4 night (now 50-44), Andre Cherry (College Football News) eases from 1.21 to 1.18 at 45-28, and SportsLine Model slips from 1.19 to 1.16 at 24-13-1. Peter Taylor (SportsGambler) reached 16 decided picks and is now rated at 0.98 (8-8). DRatings Model (30-12, 1.27) still carries the most weight.

Season to date

Tier All Spread Moneyline Total Units
STRONG 31-32 15-16 1-3 15-13 -4.35u
LEAN 22-30 14-21 4-3 4-6 -9.95u
FADE-WATCH (not staked) 3-4 3-2 — 0-2 —
Card (STRONG + LEAN) 53-62 -14.30u

Every card, every sport: the full consensus record.

Both games went to overtime; no card play or expert pick was decided by the overtime period — every total was already over in regulation and both spread results held at the end of regulation.

Rows with no sportsbook price (Dimers Model’s spreads, moneylines and Over; several College Football News grid picks and other unpriced rows) are graded at the standard -110, per our rule. Dimers Model’s App State moneyline win is therefore counted at +0.91u even though the underdog’s actual price was longer.

Please bet responsibly. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER.

DailyOverlay Premium

Get the full graded consensus — every slate.

Free for 5 days, then $19.99/mo. Cancel anytime.

Start your free trial →