MLB Sportsbook Consensus — 2026 Season Recap

Mike Spector of Sportsbook Review finished the 2026 MLB postseason as the best-graded expert in our log: 12-4 for +6.99 units, a 75% hit rate. Anthony Rome of TheSpread was right behind him at 19-12-2 for +6.96u on nearly twice the volume, and Mike Goodpaster of The Grueling Truth (15-8-1, +5.14u) and Joe Jensen of Predictem (16-11, +4.78u) rounded out the top four. Those four also carried the four highest weights in the consensus by the end of October.

From the first Wild Card game on September 29 to the Brewers’ Game 5 clincher on October 28, we logged 139 experts and models across 21 graded days of postseason baseball and graded 779 of their picks at the lines they published. The field as a whole went 392-366-21, a 51.7% hit rate. The consensus card was graded the same way, every play at the line we posted.

The consensus card

The card finished 38-26-1 for +6.55 units, a 59.4% hit rate. LEAN plays carried it at 27-12 for +10.78u (69.2%), and LEAN was profitable in every market. STRONG plays went 11-14-1 for -4.23u. The one FADE-WATCH tag lost and, as always, is logged at 0 units.

Tier All Run line Moneyline Total Units
LEAN 27-12 5-1 (+2.88u) 10-6 (+2.21u) 12-5 (+5.69u) +10.78u
STRONG 11-14-1 2-1 (+0.86u) 4-5 (-1.55u) 5-8-1 (-3.54u) -4.23u
Card (STRONG + LEAN) 38-26-1 7-2 14-11 17-13-1 +6.55u
FADE-WATCH (not staked) 0-1 — 0-1 — —

Round by round

Round Graded days Card Units
Wild Card 1 5-2 +1.87u
Division Series 7 16-10-1 +3.69u
League Championship Series 8 11-9 +1.57u
World Series 5 6-5 -0.58u
Postseason 21 38-26-1 +6.55u

The run line was the cleanest market of October at 7-2 across both tiers. The World Series card finished one play under even: Game 1 went 3-0 and Game 5 went 2-0, while Game 2 and Game 3 went a combined 0-4, and Game 4 split.

Where it went right, and where it didn’t

The losing totals followed a pattern consistent enough to name. They were mostly Unders built on a starting pitcher going deep, and the runs came after he left: Boston’s bullpen turned a 2-0 Wild Card game into 9-0, the Rays’ relievers gave up five runs over the last two innings of ALCS Game 1, and neither starter got through four innings in World Series Game 2. When the starter did go deep, as Jacob Misiorowski did in World Series Game 1, the Under held. STRONG totals finished 5-8-1, and how the consensus handles a total that depends on one starter’s length is the first thing we’ll review before Opening Day.

The LEAN tier was the opposite story: 12-5 on totals, 5-1 on run lines and positive on moneylines, often at plus money. That included the Brewers moneyline at +146 against the Dodgers in the NLCS and the Rays -1.5 at +161 in ALCS Game 6.

2026 postseason expert standings

Experts with at least 15 decided picks, ranked by units at flat one-unit stakes. These are the experts whose records move their weight in the consensus.

Rank Expert Record Hit rate Units
1 Sportsbook Review – Mike Spector 12-4 75.0% +6.99u
2 TheSpread – Anthony Rome 19-12-2 61.3% +6.96u
3 The Grueling Truth – Mike Goodpaster 15-8-1 65.2% +5.14u
4 Predictem – Joe Jensen 16-11 59.3% +4.78u
5 TheRX – Casey Whitmore 14-11-1 56.0% +2.84u
6 Sports Illustrated – Ryan Gilbert 11-8-1 57.9% +1.84u
7 Lineups – Thom Cunningham 16-14-2 53.3% +1.78u
8 RG.org – Sergey Demidov 9-8 52.9% +0.13u
9 Bettors Insider – Earnest Horn 11-9 55.0% +0.09u
10 WagerTalk – Kyle Kargel 12-13-1 48.0% -2.68u
11 Picks and Parlays – Kim Smith 28-27-5 50.9% -2.77u
12 Dimers Model 10-13-1 43.5% -3.09u
13 Bleacher Nation Model 6-9-1 40.0% -3.93u
14 SportsGrid Model 6-18 25.0% -12.97u

Short of the 15-pick line but worth noting: Covers’ Shawn Krest went 6-0 (+5.79u), The Lines’ Jason Green 8-3 (+3.69u), Sportytrader’s Lou Aguila 3-1 (+3.60u), Action Network’s Sean Zerillo 4-0 (+3.50u) and Pick Dawgz’s David Racey 4-1 (+3.03u). Picks and Parlays’ Kim Smith was the most active expert we graded, 28-27-5 across 60 picks.

The DFS side

MLB DFS grading closed out in September. RotoBaller won the hitters board at a 3.07 DailyOverlay Score, its first MLB board win in eleven years of our grading, and RotoGrinders 6-pack took the pitchers board at 5.70. Our weighted Core 5 consensus finished third on hitters and second on pitchers. The full boards are in the 2026 MLB DFS final standings.

What’s next

MLB consensus cards return on Opening Day 2027. Until then, the same logging, tiering and public grading runs every day for the NBA, NHL, NFL and college football, and NBA, NFL and PGA DFS. Every pick, theirs and the consensus, is graded in public the next morning.

Please bet responsibly. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER.

DailyOverlay Premium

Get the full graded consensus — every slate.

Free for 5 days, then $19.99/mo. Cancel anytime.

Start your free trial →