NHL Sportsbook Consensus Grading Recap — Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Doc’s Sports – Josh Schonwald went a perfect 4-0 for +4.34u on Tuesday, hitting the Oilers (+105), Blackhawks (+130), Senators (-117) and Stars (+114). He is now 26-14 (+12.73u) on the season with us, the best hit rate of any rated NHL expert at 65%.
The iHeart Model led the day in units at 20-11, +6.16u across 31 graded picks, and stays on top of our NHL season table at 156-106-2 (+18.44u). Picks and Parlays – Kim Smith went 7-3 (+3.37u), cashing the Islanders, Stars and Senators, to move to 78-60 with us. Pickswise – Connor Grootenhuis (2-0, +1.62u) and The Hockeynomist (2-0, +1.53u) were both perfect, and CBS Sports – Allie O’Neill went 2-0 (+1.49u) on two Overs in her first graded day with us.
The consensus card went 4-4 for -0.16u. STRONG 3-3 (-0.21u), LEAN 1-1 (+0.05u). Every play is graded at the line we posted.
What actually happened
Dallas cashed the biggest price on the STRONG list the hard way. Vegas led 3-1 late on two William Karlsson goals and one from Brett Howden, before the Stars pulled Jake Oettinger and scored twice six-on-five — Wyatt Johnston at 18:42 and Mikko Rantanen with five seconds left. Miro Heiskanen, back after missing five games, won it 3:36 into overtime. In Tampa, the Lightning scored three times on their first four shots, Jake Guentzel added two, and Anthony Cirelli’s empty-netter with 2:41 left put the total at seven to clear 6.5. Ilya Sorokin made 28 saves and rookie defenseman Matthew Schaefer scored a hat trick as the Islanders beat Columbus 5-1, and Edmonton led Florida 4-0 after two power-play goals before winning 5-2.
The Boston play went in with a premise that did not hold. The card’s case leaned on a projected Jeremy Swayman vs. Anton Forsberg matchup; instead Michael DiPietro started for Boston and Darcy Kuemper for Los Angeles. Kuemper made 29 saves for his 40th career shutout, stopping a Morgan Geekie penalty shot, and the Kings won 3-0. That is a changed goaltending premise, not the same read played out.
The other three losses were decided on the ice. St. Louis scored three times in 2:58 early in the third to pull away from Anaheim; Ville Husso was pulled after allowing seven, and despite a Cutter Gauthier hat trick the Blues won 8-6 with a Pavel Buchnevich empty-netter. In San Jose, the Sharks scored first, then Calgary answered with three straight goals, Dustin Wolf made 21 saves and the Flames won 5-2. In Chicago, Frank Nazar scored twice and Connor Bedard once (Bedard left early in the third with an apparent upper-body injury) as the Blackhawks scored six on Sergei Bobrovsky; Toronto has now lost seven straight. The consensus was beaten on the merits in all three.
The card, by tier
| Tier | Record | Hit rate | Units |
|---|---|---|---|
| STRONG | 3-3-0 | 50% | -0.21u |
| LEAN | 1-1-0 | 50% | +0.05u |
| Card (STRONG + LEAN) | 4-4-0 | 50% | -0.16u |
Every play is graded at the line we posted.
Every play
| Result | Tier | Play | Line | Final | Grading |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ❌ LOSS | STRONG | Kings @ Bruins — Bruins ML | -155 DraftKings | Kings 3-0 Bruins | Bruins 0, Kings 3 → Bruins lose; moneyline loses ❌ · -1.00u |
| ✅ WIN | STRONG | Blue Jackets @ Islanders — Islanders ML | -142 DraftKings | Islanders 5-1 Blue Jackets | Islanders 5, Blue Jackets 1 → Islanders win; moneyline cashes ✅ · +0.70u |
| ❌ LOSS | STRONG | Ducks @ Blues — Ducks ML | +120 DraftKings | Blues 8-6 Ducks | Ducks 6, Blues 8 → Ducks lose; moneyline loses ❌ · -1.00u |
| ❌ LOSS | STRONG | Flames @ Sharks — Sharks ML | -130 DraftKings | Flames 5-2 Sharks | Sharks 2, Flames 5 → Sharks lose; moneyline loses ❌ · -1.00u |
| ✅ WIN | STRONG | Stars @ Golden Knights — Stars ML | +114 DraftKings | Stars 4-3 Golden Knights (OT) | 3-3 after regulation; Heiskanen scores at 3:36 of OT → Stars win 4-3; overtime counts; moneyline cashes ✅ · +1.14u |
| ✅ WIN | STRONG | Capitals @ Lightning — Over 6.5 | -105 DraftKings | Lightning 5-2 Capitals | 5 + 2 = 7 goals → above 6.5; Over cashes ✅ · +0.95u |
| ❌ LOSS | LEAN | Maple Leafs @ Blackhawks — Maple Leafs ML | -148 DraftKings | Blackhawks 6-3 Maple Leafs | Maple Leafs 3, Blackhawks 6 → Maple Leafs lose; moneyline loses ❌ · -1.00u |
| ✅ WIN | LEAN | Oilers @ Panthers — Oilers ML | +105 DraftKings | Oilers 5-2 Panthers | Oilers 5, Panthers 2 → Oilers win; moneyline cashes ✅ · +1.05u |
Best call: Stars ML +114 (STRONG). Down 3-1 in the final minutes, Dallas scored twice with Oettinger pulled — Rantanen’s equalizer came with five seconds left — and Heiskanen won it in overtime. The longest price on the STRONG list cashed, and overtime counts.
Worst beat: Bruins ML -155 (STRONG). The heaviest favorite on the card lost 3-0. The goalie matchup it was built on never happened: DiPietro started for Boston, and Kuemper shut the Bruins out, including a stop on a penalty shot.
Expert scoreboard — Tuesday, Nov 17
We graded 152 picks from 38 experts and models. The field went 79-73 (52%) against the consensus card’s 4-4 (50%).
| Top of the day | Pick | Record | Units |
|---|---|---|---|
| Doc's Sports – Josh Schonwald | Oilers ML +105; Blackhawks ML +130; Senators ML -117; Stars ML +114 | 4-0-0 | +4.34u |
| iHeart Model | 31 picks across 11 games; Lightning -1.5; Wild -1.5; Islanders -1.5 among the wins | 20-11-0 | +6.16u |
| Picks and Parlays – Kim Smith | Islanders ML; Stars ML; Senators ML; Senators-Jets Under 6.5 | 7-3-0 | +3.37u |
| Pickswise – Connor Grootenhuis | Islanders ML -150; Ducks-Blues Over 6.5 (-105) | 2-0-0 | +1.62u |
| The Hockeynomist | Lightning ML -162; Capitals-Lightning Over 6.5 | 2-0-0 | +1.53u |
| CBS Sports – Allie O'Neill | Sabres-Flyers Over 5.5 (-135); Oilers-Panthers Over 5.5 (-134) | 2-0-0 | +1.49u |
Also on the right side: WagerTalk – Bryan Leonard (Kings +130, 1-0, +1.30u), Covers – Robert Criscola (4-3, +1.13u), Bettors Insider – Earnest Horn (Oilers +102, 1-0, +1.02u) and Covers – Kyle LaRusic (Capitals-Lightning Over 6.5, 1-0, +1.00u). At the bottom of the day: Pickswise – Nate Duffett and Pickswise – Jon Yaremko both went 0-4 (-4.00u), Pick Dawgz – Nikos Lagouretos and Doc’s Sports – Tony Sink went 0-3, and the Dimers Model went 2-5 (-3.18u). The field as a whole went 79-73 (-0.02u).
| Season leaders (NHL, graded with us) | Record | Units | Consensus weight |
|---|---|---|---|
| iHeart Model | 156-106-2 | +18.44u | 1.22 |
| Doc's Sports – Josh Schonwald | 26-14 | +12.73u | 1.18 |
| RotoWire – Daniel Dobish | 11-3 | +6.00u | 1.00 (14 of 15 decided) |
| Sportsgambler – Robert Carter | 20-12 | +5.55u | 1.12 |
| CBS Sports | 100-72-2 | +5.06u | 1.16 |
| Action Network – Nick Martin | 9-3 | +4.93u | 1.00 (12 of 15 decided) |
| Doc's Sports – Parlays Pundit | 15-11 | +4.42u | 1.05 |
How this changes the card
Josh Schonwald’s 4-0 day lifts his weight in the consensus from 1.11 to 1.18, second only to the iHeart Model (1.20 to 1.22). Kim Smith rises from 1.08 to 1.11 and Connor Grootenhuis from 1.03 to 1.07. Going the other way, Nate Duffett drops from 1.00 to 0.92 (now 10-13), Jon Yaremko from 1.04 to 0.96 (12-13), Nikos Lagouretos at Pick Dawgz from 1.06 to 1.00 and Tony Sink from 1.03 to 0.97. Covers – Robert Criscola reached 16 decided picks and is now rated at 0.98 (8-8). 42 NHL experts are rated.
Season to date
| Tier | All | Puck line | Moneyline | Total | Units |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| STRONG | 76-58 | 10-5 | 43-31 | 23-22 | +2.87u |
| LEAN | 26-36 | 5-5 | 10-17 | 11-14 | -12.50u |
| FADE-WATCH (not staked) | 1-5 | 0-3 | 1-2 | — | — |
| Card (STRONG + LEAN) | 102-94 | -9.63u |
Every card, every sport: the full consensus record.
Expert rows recorded without a sportsbook price (or at the line captured at DraftKings 10:40 AM CT) are graded at -110. Overtime and the shootout count for every market.
Please bet responsibly. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER.
Get the full graded consensus — every slate.
Free for 5 days, then $19.99/mo. Cancel anytime.
