NHL Sportsbook Consensus Grading Recap — Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Jay Cooper (Ultimate Capper) had the best night of the 27 experts we graded, going 2-1 for +1.34u. He took both underdogs that won, Montreal at +142 and Utah at -109, and is now 70-75 with us for +5.23u. Mike Fink (Winners and Whiners) went 1-0 for +1.00u with Boston at even money, which makes him 2-0 with us. Robert Carter (Sportsgambler) cashed Boston too, at -102 for +0.98u, and he is now 21-12, +6.53u, one of the best records we track in hockey.
Thom Cunningham (Lineups.com) went 2-1 for +0.89u with Boston and the Boston–Detroit Under 6. Ben Burns (WagerTalk) went against nine experts and took Utah, a winner that moves him to 11-6, +3.48u. Mark Lammey (Pickswise) cashed Under 6.5 in Colorado–Utah and is now 18-10, +4.80u. Tyler Williams (ScoresAndStats) hit Montreal at +130.
The consensus card went 2-4 for -1.95u. STRONG went 1-3 (-2.09u) and LEAN went 1-1 (+0.14u). Every play is graded at the line we posted.
What actually happened
In Newark, the STRONG play was the Devils on the moneyline, and 9 of 11 experts were on it. New Jersey led twice in the first period, on goals by Evangelista and Meier. Montreal tied it 2-2 on Nick Suzuki’s power-play goal 42 seconds before the second intermission, and Jake Evans won it 3-2 at 6:17 of the third. Rookie Jacob Fowler, the unsettled crease the card flagged, made 28 saves on 30 shots for Montreal. With no empty-net goal and only five goals in total, the STRONG Over 6.5 and the LEAN Devils -1.5 both lost. The consensus was beaten on the merits by Fowler’s goaltending, not by a voided premise.
In Detroit, the STRONG play on Boston landed. Lucas Raymond put the Red Wings up 1-0 in the first, but Boston scored twice in the second, including a Pavel Zacha power-play goal after a Moritz Seider tripping penalty. David Pastrnak scored and added an assist, and Boston outshot Detroit 31-21. Casey Mittelstadt’s late empty-net goal stretched it to 4-1, which still left the total at five, so the LEAN Under 5.5 cashed.
In Utah, the STRONG play was Colorado, and it lost 4-1. Mammoth goalie Sebastian Cossa stopped 30 of 31, and Colorado went 0-for-4 on the power play against a penalty kill that had been among the league’s worst. Utah scored at even strength, on the power play and shorthanded, and added an empty-netter late. The win ended Utah’s six-game losing streak. Colorado was still without Nathan MacKinnon and Cale Makar, as the card noted, and Mackenzie Blackwood made 25 saves. No goalie change or in-game injury voided the read; Utah won on the merits.
The card, by tier
| Tier | Record | Hit rate | Units |
|---|---|---|---|
| STRONG | 1-3-0 | 25% | -2.09u |
| LEAN | 1-1-0 | 50% | +0.14u |
| Card (STRONG + LEAN) | 2-4-0 | 33% | -1.95u |
Every play is graded at the line we posted.
Every play
| Result | Tier | Play | Line | Final | Grading |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ❌ LOSS | STRONG | Canadiens @ Devils — Devils ML | -170 DraftKings | Canadiens 3-2 Devils | Devils lose 2-3 in regulation → LOSS · -1.00u |
| ✅ WIN | STRONG | Bruins @ Red Wings — Bruins ML | -110 DraftKings | Bruins 4-1 Red Wings | Bruins win 4-1 → WIN · +0.91u |
| ❌ LOSS | STRONG | Avalanche @ Mammoth — Avalanche ML | -105 DraftKings | Mammoth 4-1 Avalanche | Avalanche lose 1-4 → LOSS · -1.00u |
| ❌ LOSS | STRONG | Canadiens @ Devils — Over 6.5 | +114 DraftKings | Canadiens 3-2 Devils | 3 + 2 = 5, Over 6.5 misses ❌ · -1.00u |
| ✅ WIN | LEAN | Bruins @ Red Wings — Under 5.5 | +114 DraftKings | Bruins 4-1 Red Wings | 4 + 1 = 5, Under 5.5 cashes ✅ · +1.14u |
| ❌ LOSS | LEAN | Canadiens @ Devils — Devils -1.5 | +150 DraftKings | Canadiens 3-2 Devils | Devils 2 − 1.5 = 0.5 vs Canadiens 3 → fails -1.5 ❌ · -1.00u |
Best call: The LEAN Under 5.5 in Bruins–Red Wings at +114 (+1.14u). Boston and Detroit combined for four goals through regulation play plus an empty-netter, and the five-goal finish stayed under the number.
Worst beat: The STRONG Devils moneyline at -170. New Jersey led 1-0 and 2-1, but Suzuki’s power-play goal with 42 seconds left in the second and Evans’ winner early in the third, behind 28 saves from rookie Jacob Fowler, turned it.
Expert scoreboard — Wednesday, Nov 18
We graded 47 picks from 27 experts and models. The field went 18-29 (38.3%) against the consensus card’s 2-4 (33%).
| Top of the day | Pick | Record | Units |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ultimate Capper – Jay Cooper | Canadiens ML +142; Mammoth ML -109 | 2-1-0 | +1.34u |
| Winners and Whiners – Mike Fink | Bruins ML +100 | 1-0-0 | +1.00u |
| Sportsgambler – Robert Carter | Bruins ML -102 | 1-0-0 | +0.98u |
| Bettors Insider – Nicholas Berault | Bruins ML -105 | 1-0-0 | +0.95u |
| Pick Dawgz – David Racey | Bruins ML -105 | 1-0-0 | +0.95u |
Also on the right side: Randy Chambers (Sports Chat Place) with Boston, +0.95u; Ben Burns (WagerTalk) with Utah, +0.93u; Mark Lammey (Pickswise) with Under 6.5 in Colorado–Utah, +0.91u; Thom Cunningham (Lineups.com), 2-1, +0.89u; and Tyler Williams (ScoresAndStats), 1-1 with Montreal +130, +0.30u. At the bottom of the day, the iHeart Model went 0-5 (-5.00u), Paul Elliot (TheSpread) went 1-3 (-2.09u), and Lori Bennett (Last Word on Sports) went 0-2 (-2.00u).
| Season leaders (NHL, graded with us) | Record | Units | Consensus weight |
|---|---|---|---|
| iHeart Model | 156-111-2 | +13.44u | 1.19 |
| Doc's Sports – Josh Schonwald | 26-14 | +12.73u | 1.18 |
| Sportsgambler – Robert Carter | 21-12 | +6.53u | 1.14 |
| RotoWire – Daniel Dobish | 11-3 | +6.00u | 1.00 (14 of 15 decided) |
| Ultimate Capper – Jay Cooper | 70-75 | +5.23u | 0.89 |
| CBS Sports | 100-72-2 | +5.06u | 1.16 |
| Action Network – Nick Martin | 9-3 | +4.93u | 1.00 (12 of 15 decided) |
How this changes the card
44 NHL experts now carry a weight. Robert Carter (Sportsgambler) rose to 1.14 at 21-12, Mark Lammey (Pickswise) to 1.13 at 18-10 and Ben Burns (WagerTalk) to 1.09 at 11-6. The iHeart Model slipped from 1.22 to 1.19 after its 0-5 night but still carries the most weight, at 156-111-2. Paul Elliot (TheSpread) fell from 1.04 to 0.99 at 14-13, and Lori Bennett (Last Word on Sports) fell from 0.90 to 0.85 at 7-13. Tyler Mortimer (Pickswise, 7-8) and Neil Parker (Covers, 7-9) reached 15 decided picks and are rated for the first time, at 0.96 and 0.94.
Season to date
| Tier | All | Puck line | Moneyline | Total | Units |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| STRONG | 77-61 | 10-5 | 44-33 | 23-23 | +0.78u |
| LEAN | 27-37 | 5-6 | 10-17 | 12-14 | -12.36u |
| FADE-WATCH (not staked) | 1-5 | 0-3 | 1-2 | — | — |
| Card (STRONG + LEAN) | 104-98 | -11.58u |
Every card, every sport: the full consensus record.
All three games ended in regulation; there was no overtime or shootout. The Dimers Model’s Avalanche pick had no sportsbook price, so it is graded at -110. Two goal-scorer credits in Colorado–Utah differ between the NHL.com recap and the box-score feed; the final score does not.
Please bet responsibly. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER.
Get the full graded consensus — every slate.
Free for 5 days, then $19.99/mo. Cancel anytime.
