CFB Consensus Weekly Recap — Who’s Hot / Who’s Not — Week of Nov 12–14, 2026

Three sources separated themselves on the Nov 12–14 college football slate. Covers Computer Model (Covers) graded out at 67-47-0 for +13.97 units, the best unit total of any source we track this week, and sits 121-110-0 on the season with us. Richard Johnson (CBS Sports) was next at 13-6-0, 68.4%, for +5.83 units, and is 65-63-4 on the season. Kyle Kargel (WagerTalk) ran the table at 6-0-0 for +5.37 units and is 12-6-0 on the season.

The card this week

The consensus STRONG plays finished 8-1-0 for +5.94 units across the three graded days. The LEAN tier finished 3-6-0 for -3.37 units. Together the graded card was 11-7-0 for +2.57 units. FADE-WATCH games are tracked at zero units and came back 0-0-0 this week.

Every graded day behind those numbers is posted on the consensus record page.

Market check

Totals inside the STRONG tier carried the week outright: 6-0-0 for +5.44 units, every graded STRONG total cashing. The STRONG moneyline play went 1-0-0 for +0.57 units and STRONG spreads were a wash at 1-1-0, -0.07 units.

The LEAN tier is where the week leaked. LEAN spreads came in 3-4-0 for -1.37 units and LEAN totals 0-2-0 for -2.00 units — the same market that won at the STRONG threshold lost at the LEAN one. That is the cleanest read of the week: tier conviction mattered more than market.

For scale, the full field of 140 graded sources hit 52% this week (623-576-4, -12.76 units). The graded card hit 61.1%.

Hot this week

Expert Outlet W-L-P Hit rate Units
Covers Computer Model Covers 67-47-0 58.8% +13.97
Richard Johnson CBS Sports 13-6-0 68.4% +5.83
Kyle Kargel WagerTalk 6-0-0 100% +5.37
Nikos Lagouretos Pick Dawgz 11-6-0 64.7% +4.01
Andrew Margolick College Football News 12-7-0 63.2% +3.92
Adam Burke VSiN 5-1-0 83.3% +3.55
Joe Williams Pickswise 6-2-0 75% +3.46
Randy Chambers Pick Dawgz 10-6-1 62.5% +3.14
SportsBettingDime AI Model SportsBettingDime 12-8-0 60% +2.92
Andrew Wilsher Pickswise 3-0-0 100% +2.73

Season leaders

Expert Outlet Record Units Consensus weight
DRatings Model DRatings 30-12-0 +15.30 1.27
Chris Amberley SportsBettingDime 32-15-2 +13.99 1.24
Colby Marchio Covers 33-20-0 +11.46 1.16
Doug Millen College Football News 67-50-0 +11.05 1.12
Napier Montgomery Pickswise 32-22-0 +10.85 1.11
SportsLine Model SportsLine 36-23-1 +9.89 1.15
Thom Cunningham Lineups 19-8-0 +9.39 1.19
Matt Youmans VSiN 23-12-2 +8.85 1.17
Ben Dezell Pickswise 27-18-0 +8.39 1.11
Andre Cherry College Football News 66-52-0 +8.14 1.09
Ryan Bunnell Pickswise 23-14-0 +7.90 1.13
Steve Makinen VSiN 80-65-4 +7.80 1.07

Consensus weight is how much a source’s pick moves the card. The full graded record for every source we track — good weeks and bad — is public on the grading pages.

What we’re watching

The split we saw this week is not a one-week artifact. On the season the STRONG tier is 30-19 on totals for +8.31 units but 24-33 on spreads for -11.43 units. Totals are doing the work; sides are the drag.

So two things change going into next week. First, we are raising the bar a side has to clear to reach STRONG, because the current threshold is letting through spread plays that grade out like LEANs. Second, the LEAN tier itself is under review — it is 34-42-1 for -11.14 units on the season, and a tier that cannot clear zero needs a narrower definition, not more picks. We will report both against next week’s card.

Please bet responsibly. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER.

DailyOverlay Premium

Get the full graded consensus — every slate.

Free for 5 days, then $19.99/mo. Cancel anytime.

Start your free trial →

Season to date — the card

Live from the grading ledger, so it includes every game graded since this recap went up.

College football consensus card

Graded Sep 11 – Nov 14 · 29 graded days
Card (STRONG + LEAN)
91-97-1
-14.90u · 48.4%
STRONG
57-55
-3.76u · 50.9%
LEAN
34-42-1
-11.14u · 44.7%
Last 7 graded days
11-7
+2.57u · 61.1%
TierSpreadMoneylineTotal
STRONG24-33 -11.43u3-3 -0.64u30-19 +8.31u
LEAN21-29-1 -9.83u4-4 -0.41u9-9 -0.90u

FADE-WATCH (tracked, not staked, kept out of the card record): 5-4.

Every graded play, day by day →

Every sport’s consensus record →

Flat 1-unit stakes at the line and price we posted before the game. STRONG and LEAN are tiered before the game starts and graded against the confirmed final the next morning. Updated automatically from the grading ledger.