CFB Consensus Weekly Recap — Who’s Hot / Who’s Not — Week of Oct 19–24, 2026

Anthony Rome of TheSpread was the best source on the board for the week of Oct 19–24, going 11-3 (78.6%, +9.40 units) across three graded slates; he is 33-26-3 and +7.54 units with us on the season. Pete Fiutak of College Football News handled the most volume of anyone in the top tier at 15-6 (71.4%, +7.65 units), lifting him to 65-55 and +4.15 units for the year. Colby Marchio of Covers posted the cleanest hit rate of the three at 10-2 (83.3%, +7.10 units), and his season now reads 20-12, +7.51 units. A total of 161 sources were graded on the week.

The card this week

The consensus STRONG plays finished 7-7, -0.51 units. The LEAN tier finished 3-4, -1.24 units. Together the card came in at 10-11, -1.75 units over the three graded days. FADE-WATCH, which is tracked at zero units and does not count toward the card, went 1-0.

Full tier-by-tier history is on the consensus record page.

Market check

Totals were the one place the card made money. The LEAN total plays were the week’s single best line item at 2-0, +1.85 units, and the lone STRONG moneyline added 1-0, +1.05 units. Everything else leaked: STRONG spreads were 3-3, -0.31 units, STRONG totals 3-4, -1.25 units, and LEAN spreads were the clear drag at 1-4, -3.09 units — that one bucket accounted for more red than the rest of the card combined.

Worth noting on the breadth side: the full field of 161 graded sources hit 50.6% on the week (596-581-14), while the card itself hit 47.6%. When the field as a whole is barely above a coin flip, agreement is thin, and the tiers that lean hardest on agreement — the spread LEANs — are the ones that paid for it.

Hot this week

Expert Outlet W-L-P Hit rate Units
Anthony Rome TheSpread 11-3-0 78.6% +9.40
Pete Fiutak College Football News 15-6-0 71.4% +7.65
Colby Marchio Covers 10-2-0 83.3% +7.10
Randy Chambers Sports Chat Place 7-2-0 77.8% +6.09
E College Football News 12-5-0 70.6% +5.92
Andrew Sports Chat Place 8-2-0 80.0% +5.28
Philip Wood Sportsbook Review 9-3-0 75.0% +5.21
The Gold Sheet WagerTalk 11-5-0 68.8% +4.93
Iain MacMillan SI 5-1-0 83.3% +4.84
Tom Fornelli CBS Sports 11-6-1 64.7% +4.01

Minimum three graded picks on the week.

Season leaders

Expert Season record Units Consensus weight
DRatings Model 30-12-0 +15.30 1.27
VSiN – Matt Youmans 18-6-2 +10.38 1.22
CBS Sports – John Talty 43-29-1 +10.13 1.14
College Football News – Doug Millen 51-37-0 +9.49 1.12
Lineups – Thom Cunningham 14-5-0 +7.85 1.17
College Football News – Andre Cherry 50-38-0 +7.58 1.10
TheSpread – Anthony Rome 33-26-3 +7.54 1.06
SportsLine Model 29-19-1 +7.52 1.13
Covers – Colby Marchio 20-12-0 +7.51 1.12
CBS Sports – Tom Fornelli 55-43-4 +7.02 1.08

Minimum ten decided picks and positive units on the season; 53 sources currently clear that bar. The full graded record for every source we track — good weeks and bad — is public on the grading pages.

What we’re watching

The LEAN spread bucket is now a season-long problem, not a one-week dip: 1-4 and -3.09 units this week on top of 15-23 and -9.19 units for the year, which is the single worst line item in the ledger. STRONG plays, by contrast, are close to break-even at 38-37 and -2.86 units. Going into next week we are watching whether the agreement threshold that promotes a spread into a LEAN is simply set too low — the same agreement level that produces a profitable STRONG spread does not appear to survive the step down. Totals in both tiers continue to hold up better than spreads, and that gap is what we will be measuring.

Please bet responsibly. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER.

DailyOverlay Premium

Get the full graded consensus — every slate.

Free for 5 days, then $19.99/mo. Cancel anytime.

Start your free trial →

Season to date — the card

Live from the grading ledger, so it includes every game graded since this recap went up.

College football consensus card

Graded Sep 11 – Nov 14 · 29 graded days
Card (STRONG + LEAN)
91-97-1
-14.90u · 48.4%
STRONG
57-55
-3.76u · 50.9%
LEAN
34-42-1
-11.14u · 44.7%
Last 7 graded days
11-7
+2.57u · 61.1%
TierSpreadMoneylineTotal
STRONG24-33 -11.43u3-3 -0.64u30-19 +8.31u
LEAN21-29-1 -9.83u4-4 -0.41u9-9 -0.90u

FADE-WATCH (tracked, not staked, kept out of the card record): 5-4.

Every graded play, day by day →

Every sport’s consensus record →

Flat 1-unit stakes at the line and price we posted before the game. STRONG and LEAN are tiered before the game starts and graded against the confirmed final the next morning. Updated automatically from the grading ledger.