CFB Sportsbook Consensus Grading Recap — Friday, October 23, 2026

Anthony Rome (TheSpread) went 10-2 for +9.49u on Friday night’s five-game CFB slate. Rome had Duke and the Under in Charlottesville, Army in Tulsa, Wyoming against Air Force on the spread, the moneyline and the Under, and both Stanford +7 and Stanford +215 on the moneyline. His season record with us is now 33-26-3, +7.54u.

Kim Smith (Picks and Parlays) went 7-3 for +3.34u across all five games and is now 57-47, +5.07u with us. Zachary Cohen (VSiN) went 2-0 for +2.84u by taking Stanford twice, at +7.5 and at +210 on the moneyline, and is now 10-11, -1.44u. Colby Marchio (Covers) went 3-0 for +2.73u with Duke +1.5, the Duke-Virginia Under and Stanford on the moneyline, and is now 13-12, +1.14u.

We logged 107 picks from 47 experts and graded every one at its posted line. The field went 59-48.

The consensus card went 5-2 for +2.68u. STRONG went 2-2 (-0.08u) and LEAN went 3-0 (+2.76u). Every play is graded at the line we posted.

The two STRONG losses were UMass +14.5 (UConn won by 19) and the Army-Tulsa Under 54.5 (73 points). Each lost 1.00u.

What actually happened

Duke 19, Virginia 16. Seven of eight experts were on the Duke moneyline at +105, and six of eight were on Duke +2.5. Both plays landed on a trick play. Walker Eget lateraled to Nate Sheppard, who threw a 28-yard touchdown to Brody Keefe with 1:14 left to finish a 75-yard drive. Virginia hurt itself throughout. Beau Pribula lost a fumble at the Duke 30 early in the third quarter, Will Bettridge missed a 47-yard field goal, an intentional grounding call at the Duke 11 left the Cavaliers settling for a field goal, and Pribula threw an interception with 36 seconds left. The game finished with 35 points, so the LEAN Under 47.5 was never close.

Army 38, Tulsa 35. Nine of 13 experts were on Army +1.5, and Army won outright. Tulsa scored 21 straight points to lead 35-28. Cale Hellums tied it with a 1-yard run at 1:50, and Tim Kloska then blocked a Tulsa punt and recovered it at the 13. Dawson Jones hit a 50-yard field goal as time expired. The same game sank the STRONG Under 54.5. The case for the Under rested on Army’s slow tempo, but the two teams combined for 73 points, so the consensus was beaten on the merits.

UConn 35, UMass 16. UConn outrushed UMass 265 yards to 53. Shamar Porter’s blocked punt, recovered in the end zone, made it 28-3 in the third quarter. UMass quarterback Pop Watson III, back after missing two games, went 22 of 38. UMass scored a late touchdown with 1:09 left, but the 19-point margin stayed well outside +14.5. Nothing unusual decided this one: the consensus was beaten on the merits.

Wyoming 28, Air Force 14. Air Force lost a fumble on its first drive, ending a streak of 554 straight plays without one, and Wyoming later scored off another lost fumble. A hook-and-ladder touchdown made it 21-6 just before halftime. Air Force quarterback Evan Medders, who ran for 115 yards, left injured at the end of the third quarter. Markell Holman’s touchdown with 3:04 left brought the total to 42, still under the LEAN 44.5.

Stanford 31, NC State 28. The card had no play on this game. Davis Warren threw four touchdown passes for Stanford, and the experts who took Stanford with the points or on the moneyline cashed. A late NC State touchdown with 1:23 left made the final margin 3.

The card, by tier

Tier Record Hit rate Units
STRONG 2-2-0 50% -0.08u
LEAN 3-0-0 100% +2.76u
Card (STRONG + LEAN) 5-2-0 71% +2.68u

Every play is graded at the line we posted.

Every play

Result Tier Play Line Final Grading
✅ WIN STRONG Duke @ Virginia — Duke ML +105 +105 DraftKings Duke 19-16 Virginia Duke wins 19-16; Duke ML wins · +1.05u
✅ WIN STRONG Duke @ Virginia — Duke +2.5 (-115) -115 DraftKings Duke 19-16 Virginia Duke 19-16 Virginia → Duke +3 with +2.5 = +5.5 → WIN · +0.87u
❌ LOSS STRONG UMass @ UConn — UMass +14.5 (-110) -110 DraftKings UMass 16-35 UConn UMass 16-35 UConn → UMass -19 with +14.5 = -4.5 → LOSS · -1.00u
❌ LOSS STRONG Army @ Tulsa — Under 54.5 (-112) -112 DraftKings Army 38-35 Tulsa Army 38-35 Tulsa → total 73 vs Under 54.5 → LOSS · -1.00u
✅ WIN LEAN Army @ Tulsa — Army +1.5 (-110) -110 DraftKings Army 38-35 Tulsa Army 38-35 Tulsa → Army +3 with +1.5 = +4.5 → WIN · +0.91u
✅ WIN LEAN Duke @ Virginia — Under 47.5 (-115) -115 DraftKings Duke 19-16 Virginia Duke 19-16 Virginia → total 35 vs Under 47.5 → WIN · +0.87u
✅ WIN LEAN Air Force @ Wyoming — Under 44.5 (-102) -102 DraftKings Air Force 14-28 Wyoming Air Force 14-28 Wyoming → total 42 vs Under 44.5 → WIN · +0.98u

Best call: Duke ML +105 (STRONG). Virginia led 16-13 with three minutes left before Nate Sheppard’s trick-play touchdown pass to Brody Keefe with 1:14 left won it outright. Virginia’s two turnovers and missed field goal kept Duke within reach all night.

Worst beat: Army-Tulsa Under 54.5 (STRONG). The case was a clock-control game, but the teams combined for 73 points. Tulsa scored 21 straight in the second half, and a blocked punt set up Army’s 50-yard walk-off field goal.

Expert scoreboard — Friday, Oct 23

We graded 107 picks from 47 experts and models. The field went 59-48 (55.1%) against the consensus card’s 5-2 (71%).

Top of the day Pick Record Units
TheSpread – Anthony Rome Wyoming ML +185; Stanford ML +215; Duke ML +115 (+9 more) 10-2-0 +9.49u
Picks and Parlays – Kim Smith Duke +2.5; Wyoming +7; Army-Tulsa Over 52.5 (+7 more) 7-3-0 +3.34u
VSiN – Zachary Cohen Stanford +7.5 (-135); Stanford ML +210 2-0-0 +2.84u
Covers – Colby Marchio Duke +1.5; Duke-Virginia Under 47.5; Stanford ML 3-0-0 +2.73u
Cappers Picks – Marty Walker Duke-Virginia Under 47.5; Air Force-Wyoming Under 44.5 2-0-0 +1.82u
VSiN – Steve Makinen Army +1.5; Wyoming +5.5 2-0-0 +1.82u
Sportsbook Review – Philip Wood Duke +1.5 (-105); Duke-Virginia Under 47.5 2-0-0 +1.82u

Others on the right side included Eddie Kline (StatSalt), 4-2 for +1.64u, Sergey Demidov (RG.org) on Duke at +120, and Jeff Michaels (WagerTalk) and Steve Merril (Winners and Whiners) on Army +1.5. At the bottom of the day, the SportsGrid Model went 0-4 (-4.00u) and Mike Spector (Sportsbook Review) went 0-3 (-3.00u). The SportsLine Model and Cameron Ross (StatSalt) each went 1-3.

Season leaders (CFB, graded with us) Record Units Consensus weight
DRatings Model 30-12 +15.30u 1.27
CBS Sports – John Talty 37-19 +14.67u 1.23
College Football News – Andre Cherry 45-28 +13.03u 1.18
CBS Sports – Chris Hummer 46-31-3 +10.86u 1.15
College Football News – Doug Millen 43-30 +9.21u 1.13
Lineups – Thom Cunningham 14-5 +7.85u 1.17
TheSpread – Anthony Rome 33-26-3 +7.54u 1.06

How this changes the card

Anthony Rome’s 10-2 day moved his consensus weight from 0.95 to 1.06 (now 33-26-3). Kim Smith (Picks and Parlays) rose from 1.02 to 1.06 (57-47). Colby Marchio (Covers) and Eddie Kline (StatSalt) both climbed back to neutral at 1.00, at 13-12 and 12-11. Going the other way, the SportsGrid Model dropped from 0.95 to 0.90 (41-45), Mike Spector (Sportsbook Review) from 1.01 to 0.97 (49-47) and the SportsLine Model from 1.16 to 1.12 (25-16-1). These weights apply to future cards. They did not change any of Friday’s plays.

Season to date

Tier All Spread Moneyline Total Units
STRONG 33-34 16-17 2-3 15-14 -4.43u
LEAN 25-30 15-21 4-3 6-6 -7.19u
FADE-WATCH (not staked) 3-4 3-2 — 0-2 —
Card (STRONG + LEAN) 58-64 -11.62u

Every card, every sport: the full consensus record.

All five games went final in regulation. Expert picks that were logged without American odds (a line only, or ‘line at capture’) are graded at -110.

Please bet responsibly. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER.

DailyOverlay Premium

Get the full graded consensus — every slate.

Free for 5 days, then $19.99/mo. Cancel anytime.

Start your free trial →