CFB Sportsbook Consensus Grading Recap — Saturday, November 21, 2026
Iain MacMillan of SI had the biggest Saturday of anyone we graded: 18-7 for +11.44 units, cashing Nebraska on the moneyline at +150, Tennessee outright, Washington +7.5 and the Under in UCLA-Michigan. That moves him to 86-69-3 (+8.32u) on the season with us across 158 logged picks. Chris Ruffolo of Sports Chat Place went 9-2 (+6.19u), with Iowa -8.5, West Virginia +8.5 and Rutgers +26.5 among the winners, and Athlon Sports’ AI News Desk went 10-3 (+6.10u), now 15-9 (+4.65u) on the year. Close behind: the Sportsbook Review Model at 14-8 (+4.74u), Sportsbook Review’s Mike Spector at 16-9 (+4.17u), and two perfect 4-0 days from CBS Sports’ David Cobb and Picks and Parlays’ Kim Smith (+3.64u each).
We logged 723 picks from 97 experts across 47 Saturday games, and the field finished 378-340-5 (+6.54u), a 52.6% hit rate.
The consensus card went 5-4-1 for +0.56u. STRONG 3-4-1 (-1.28u), LEAN 2-0 (+1.84u). The two FADE-WATCH spots went 1-1 and carry no units. Every play is graded at the line we posted.
What actually happened
The STRONG wins came in the SEC. Georgia’s defense held South Carolina to 118 yards after the first quarter in a 34-6 win that clinched an SEC title game berth; Gunnar Stockton was 19-of-23 for 281 yards and a recovered onside kick and a long punt return added points. Tennessee, getting 1.5, beat LSU 27-13 after a 13-13 tie going into the fourth, when Faizon Brandon ran for touchdowns of 18 and 55 yards; the Vols’ defense recorded eight sacks. The Under 36.5 in UCLA-Michigan stood at 20 points through regulation and still came in at 34 after three overtimes.
The same UCLA-Michigan game went the other way on the spread. UCLA starting quarterback Ty Dieffenbach turned it over three times and was carted off in overtime, and Michigan won 18-16 on Bryce Underwood’s two-point conversion to Jalen Hoffman in the third extra period. Arizona -7.5 landed exactly on 7: the Wildcats needed 11 fourth-quarter points to force overtime in heavy rain at Kansas State and won 35-28. Memphis led Navy 34-24 with 12:38 left and lost 38-34 on a touchdown with 19 seconds to go, after Navy’s J. Gutierrez ran for 241 yards. Virginia Tech-Miami finished 28-20, well short of 60.5; Miami’s offense managed 14 points through three quarters and Darian Mensah threw two interceptions. Wake Forest beat Georgia Tech 50-29, a push at exactly 21, with Georgia Tech’s 22 second-half points coming after Wake led 36-7 at halftime.
Both LEAN plays cashed comfortably. Utah broke a fourth-quarter tie with TCU by scoring three touchdowns in the final 5:46 to win 38-17, and Iowa shut Illinois out after halftime, including a 40-yard interception return, to win 34-17. Illinois quarterback Katin Houser played through a broken hand and threw two interceptions. On the FADE-WATCH side, West Virginia +7 covered in a 34-31 loss decided by a field goal at the gun, and Florida State -10.5 lost outright 28-10 to NC State.
The card, by tier
| Tier | Record | Hit rate | Units |
|---|---|---|---|
| STRONG | 3-4-1 | 43% | -1.28u |
| LEAN | 2-0-0 | 100% | +1.84u |
| Card (STRONG + LEAN) | 5-4-1 | 56% | +0.56u |
| FADE-WATCH (tracked, not staked) | 1-1-0 | 50% | +0.00u |
Every play is graded at the line we posted.
Every play
| Result | Tier | Play | Line | Final | Grading |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ❌ LOSS | STRONG | UCLA @ Michigan — UCLA -3.5 | -110 DraftKings | Michigan 18-16 UCLA (3OT) | UCLA 16, Michigan 18 (3OT) → UCLA lost by 2, does not cover -3.5 · -1.00u |
| ✅ WIN | STRONG | Georgia @ South Carolina — Georgia -14.5 | -115 DraftKings | Georgia 34-6 South Carolina | Georgia 34, South Carolina 6 → Georgia by 28, covers -14.5 · +0.87u |
| ✅ WIN | STRONG | LSU @ Tennessee — Tennessee +1.5 | -115 DraftKings | Tennessee 27-13 LSU | Tennessee 27, LSU 13 → Tennessee won by 14, covers +1.5 · +0.87u |
| ✅ WIN | STRONG | UCLA @ Michigan — Under 36.5 | -102 DraftKings | Michigan 18-16 UCLA (3OT) | UCLA 16 + Michigan 18 = 34 (OT included) → under 36.5 · +0.98u |
| ➖ PUSH | STRONG | Wake Forest @ Georgia Tech — Wake Forest -21 | -115 DraftKings | Wake Forest 50-29 Georgia Tech | Wake Forest 50, Georgia Tech 29 → Wake by 21, exactly -21 → push · +0.00u |
| ❌ LOSS | STRONG | Virginia Tech @ Miami — Over 60.5 | -115 DraftKings | Miami 28-20 Virginia Tech | Virginia Tech 20 + Miami 28 = 48 → under 60.5, Over loses · -1.00u |
| ❌ LOSS | STRONG | Memphis @ Navy — Memphis -2.5 | -115 DraftKings | Navy 38-34 Memphis | Navy 38, Memphis 34 → Memphis lost by 4, does not cover -2.5 · -1.00u |
| ❌ LOSS | STRONG | Arizona @ Kansas State — Arizona -7.5 | -105 DraftKings | Arizona 35-28 Kansas State (OT) | Arizona 35, Kansas State 28 (OT) → Arizona by 7, does not cover -7.5 · -1.00u |
| ✅ WIN | LEAN | Utah @ TCU — Utah -8.5 | -108 DraftKings | Utah 38-17 TCU | Utah 38, TCU 17 → Utah by 21, covers -8.5 · +0.93u |
| ✅ WIN | LEAN | Iowa @ Illinois — Iowa -8.5 | -110 DraftKings | Iowa 34-17 Illinois | Iowa 34, Illinois 17 → Iowa by 17, covers -8.5 · +0.91u |
| ✅ WIN | FADE-WATCH | Houston @ West Virginia — West Virginia +7 | -110 DraftKings | Houston 34-31 West Virginia | Houston 34, West Virginia 31 → West Virginia lost by 3, covers +7 · +0.00u |
| ❌ LOSS | FADE-WATCH | NC State @ Florida State — Florida State -10.5 | -108 DraftKings | NC State 28-10 Florida State | NC State 28, Florida State 10 → Florida State lost by 18, does not cover -10.5 · +0.00u |
Best call: Tennessee +1.5 (STRONG): 21 of 26 experts were on the Vols, and Tennessee won the fourth quarter 14-0 on Faizon Brandon’s two touchdown runs while the defense piled up eight sacks.
Worst beat: Arizona -7.5 (STRONG): Arizona won 35-28 in overtime, one half-point short. Heavy rain held the Wildcats to 2.8 yards a carry, and they needed a late touchdown and two-point conversion just to reach overtime.
Expert scoreboard — Saturday, Nov 21
We graded 723 picks from 97 experts and models. The field went 378-340 (52.6%) against the consensus card’s 5-4 (56%).
| Top of the day | Pick | Record | Units |
|---|---|---|---|
| SI – Iain MacMillan | Nebraska ML +150 | 18-7-0 | +11.44u |
| Sports Chat Place – Chris Ruffolo | Iowa -8.5 | 9-2-0 | +6.19u |
| Athlon Sports – AI News Desk | Tennessee +1.5 | 10-3-0 | +6.10u |
| Sportsbook Review Model | Nebraska +3.5 | 14-8-0 | +4.74u |
| Sportsbook Review – Mike Spector | Nebraska ML +136 | 16-9-0 | +4.17u |
Also on the right side: CBS Sports’ David Cobb (4-0, Michigan +3.5 and Tennessee +1.5) and Picks and Parlays’ Kim Smith (4-0, Oklahoma -7.5 and two Unders), Covers’ Chris Vasile (6-2, +3.46u), Pickswise’s Sam Avellone (6-3, +2.67u), Saturday Down South’s Ethan Stone and RotoWire’s Jeff Edgerton (4-1, +2.64u each), and FanSided’s Cody Williams (26-21, +2.66u). At the bottom of the day: the Covers Computer Model went 43-51 (-11.87u) across 94 picks, Yahoo Sports’ Matt Russell went 0-4, Sports Chat Place’s Andrew went 4-7 (-3.36u), and RotoWire’s Greg Vara went 1-4 (-3.09u).
| Season leaders (CFB, graded with us) | Record | Units | Consensus weight |
|---|---|---|---|
| DRatings Model | 30-12 | +15.30u | 1.27 |
| Covers – Colby Marchio | 38-22 | +14.16u | 1.19 |
| SportsBettingDime – Chris Amberley | 35-18-2 | +13.74u | 1.23 |
| Pickswise – Napier Montgomery | 35-25-1 | +11.07u | 1.11 |
| College Football News – Doug Millen | 67-50 | +11.05u | 1.12 |
| SportsLine Model | 38-24-1 | +10.71u | 1.16 |
| VSiN – Steve Makinen | 94-76-4 | +9.54u | 1.08 |
How this changes the card
138 experts now have the 15 decided picks needed to carry weight, up from 133 before Saturday. Saturday Down South’s Ethan Stone rose to a 1.20 weight after a 4-1 day (18-7 on the season), and Covers’ Colby Marchio moved up to 1.19 (38-22) after a 2-0 day. Lineups’ Thom Cunningham slipped from 1.19 to 1.16 after a 5-5 day (24-13). DRatings Model still holds the top weight at 1.27 (30-12, +15.30u).
Season to date
| Tier | All | Spread | Moneyline | Total | Units |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| STRONG | 62-60-1 | 28-37-1 | 3-3 | 31-20 | -4.28u |
| LEAN | 42-44-1 | 26-29-1 | 6-4 | 10-11 | -5.53u |
| FADE-WATCH (not staked) | 6-5 | 5-3 | — | 1-2 | — |
| Card (STRONG + LEAN) | 104-104-2 | -9.81u |
Every card, every sport: the full consensus record.
UCLA-Michigan (3OT), BYU-Kansas (3OT), Indiana-Washington (2OT), Arizona-Kansas State (OT) and UL Monroe-App State (OT) were all graded with overtime included. Expert rows with no sportsbook price were graded at -110.
Please bet responsibly. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER.
Get the full graded consensus — every slate.
Free for 5 days, then $19.99/mo. Cancel anytime.
