MLB Sportsbook Consensus Grading Recap — Monday, October 12, 2026

The grading found the room that got October right. The Dimers model was the best source we graded on Monday at 3-0, +2.51 units — it had the Guardians +1.5 run line, the Over 6.5 in the ALCS and the Over 6.5 in the NLCS, which is to say it had the only three things that happened. VSiN’s Dave Tuley went 1-0, +1.45u on Guardians moneyline at +145, one of only two sources in our log on Cleveland outright. Pickswise’s Jason Fragomeni went 1-0, +1.22u on Brewers moneyline at +122, and the SportsLine model (CBS Sports) went 1-0, +0.83u on the ALCS Over. TheSpread’s Anthony Rome — who carries the highest weight on our MLB board at 1.11 from a 12-6-1 graded record — split at 1-1, +0.39u, cashing Guardians moneyline at +139.

The consensus card went the other way. Monday’s three STRONG plays finished 0-3 (-3.00u) and the single LEAN finished 0-1 (-1.00u), so the card closed 0-4, -4.00 units, every play graded at the price we posted. The field as a whole hit 24.0% on 50 graded picks, so this was a day the market read two postseason games wrong and our log says so in full.

What actually happened

ALCS Game 1 — Guardians 7, Rays 3. One thing decided all three plays on this game, and it was not the thing the room was looking at. Drew Rasmussen pitched exactly the game the consensus handicapped: 6 innings, 8 hits, 2 earned runs, no walks, 7 strikeouts on 91 pitches, with Tampa in front 2-0 on first-inning RBI singles from Caminero and DeLuca. The read was that Tampa’s leverage arms had sat five days while Cleveland’s had all worked inside the last week. It inverted. Cleveland’s bullpen covered five innings behind a four-inning Foster Griffin start and gave up one run; Tampa’s gave up five across the eighth and ninth, with Wells charged 2 earned runs in a third of an inning and Sulser 3 earned in two thirds. DeLauter homered in the sixth, Bailey homered in the seventh to tie it, Lowe’s two-run single in the eighth put Cleveland ahead, and Adell’s two-run double in the ninth — a grounder Caminero was out of position for that rolled into left field — made it 7-3. That bullpen sequence is why the Rays run line lost, why the Rays moneyline lost, and why 10 combined runs beat the Under 6.5. One cause, three results.

NLCS Game 2 — Brewers 7, Dodgers 4. The case for the Dodgers was the starter, and the starter was gone in the third. Yoshinobu Yamamoto recorded eight outs and was pulled in the bottom of the third after a 36-pitch inning capped by Christian Yelich’s go-ahead hit, and Los Angeles used eight pitchers to finish the night. He was not scratched and nothing was voided — he started, he was beaten, and the consensus was beaten with him. Milwaukee’s rookie Logan Henderson was not sharp either and his own glove nearly cost him the game: two throwing errors to first handed Los Angeles two unearned runs and a 4-3 lead in the fourth. William Contreras then tied it with a solo home run off Kris Bubic in the fifth and singled in the go-ahead run in the sixth, and Milwaukee added two in the eighth. The Brewers’ bullpen finished with four shutout innings and did not allow a baserunner. Eleven combined runs, 4-4 through five.

Monday’s tiers

Tier Record Hit rate Units
STRONG 0-3-0 0.0% -3.00
LEAN 0-1-0 0.0% -1.00
Card total 0-4-0 0.0% -4.00

No FADE-WATCH plays ran Monday. Every play is graded at the line we posted at 09:15 CT.

Every play, graded

Result Game Market Consensus pick Tier Final Units
❌ ALCS G1 · Guardians @ Rays Run line Tampa Bay Rays -1.5 (+138) STRONG Guardians 7-3 Rays -1.00
❌ ALCS G1 · Guardians @ Rays Moneyline Tampa Bay Rays ML (-164) STRONG Guardians 7-3 Rays -1.00
❌ NLCS G2 · Dodgers @ Brewers Total Under 6.5 (-128) STRONG Brewers 7-4 Dodgers (11 runs) -1.00
❌ NLCS G2 · Dodgers @ Brewers Moneyline Los Angeles Dodgers ML (-135) LEAN Brewers 7-4 Dodgers -1.00

Best call: Dave Tuley on Guardians moneyline at +145. The whole board had Tampa as the rested side with the better starter, and Tampa got the start it wanted — Rasmussen left after six with a 2-0 lead. Tuley was paid because Cleveland’s supposedly overworked bullpen threw five innings and allowed one run while Tampa’s rested arms gave up five in two.

Worst beat: Tampa Bay -1.5 at +138. Seven of eight sources took it and they got the exact game they drew up for six innings. It did not lose on a bad read of the matchup; it lost in the eighth and ninth innings, by four runs, after the starter was out of it.

Expert scoreboard — Monday, October 12

We graded 50 picks from 31 distinct sources across the two games. The field went 12-38 (24.0%) for a net of -25.15 units.

# Source Outlet Day Units
1 Dimers Model Dimers 3-0-0 +2.51
2 Dave Tuley VSiN 1-0-0 +1.45
3 Jason Fragomeni Pickswise 1-0-0 +1.22
4 SportsLine Model CBS Sports 1-0-0 +0.83
5 Anthony Rome TheSpread 1-1-0 +0.39
Bottom five of the day Outlet Day Units
Kyle Kargel WagerTalk 0-5-0 -5.00
Mike Spector Sportsbook Review 0-2-0 -2.00
Kim Smith Picks and Parlays 0-2-0 -2.00
Peter Dewey Sports Illustrated 0-2-0 -2.00
numberFire Model FanDuel Research 0-2-0 -2.00

Consensus vs. the field: the card hit 0.0% (0-4) against an all-expert hit rate of 24.0% (12-38). The card concentrated on the two heaviest-agreement sides in a two-game slate, and both heavy sides lost.

Season leaders and their weights

Source Graded record Hit rate Weight
Anthony Rome (TheSpread) 12-6-1 66.7% 1.11
Thom Cunningham (Lineups) 12-9-1 57.1% 1.04
Kim Smith (Picks and Parlays) 17-15-4 53.1% 1.01
Joe Jensen (Predictem) 8-8 50.0% 0.98
Kyle Kargel (WagerTalk) 8-11-1 42.1% 0.92
SportsGrid Model 6-18 25.0% 0.73

How this changes the card

Six sources on our MLB board have now cleared 15 decided picks and therefore carry a weight other than 1.00. Anthony Rome keeps the top weight at 1.11 on a 12-6-1 record and defended it Monday by cashing Guardians moneyline at +139 — he is now the single source the MLB consensus leans on hardest. Kyle Kargel moves the other way: a 0-5 Monday drops him to 8-11-1 and a weight of 0.92, meaning his side of a disagreement now counts for less than a source we have never graded. Thom Cunningham sits at 1.04 on 12-9-1 after a 1-3 day.

Monday’s best performers do not move the weights yet. Dimers Model, Dave Tuley, Jason Fragomeni and the SportsLine model all stay at 1.00 because none of them has reached 15 decided MLB picks in our log — we are still building their samples, and nothing on Monday’s card was weighted in their favour. That is the honest position, and it is why we publish the sample size next to the record.

Season to date — MLB

Tier Record Units Run line Moneyline Totals
STRONG 7-9-1 -2.23 2-1 (+0.86) 2-4 (-1.87) 3-4-1 (-1.22)
LEAN 16-7-0 +5.60 3-1 (+0.61) 5-3 (+0.87) 8-3 (+4.12)
Card (STRONG + LEAN) 23-16-1 +3.37 — — —
FADE-WATCH (watches, 0 units) 0-1-0 0.00 — 0-1 —

Grading notes

Both games were confirmed FINAL in regulation on independent box scores before anything was graded — no postponement, no suspension, no shortened game, no extra innings. Arithmetic: Cleveland by four runs, so Tampa Bay -1.5 cannot cover; 7 + 3 = 10 runs in the ALCS; 7 + 4 = 11 runs against the NLCS Under 6.5. One first-five-innings play appeared in the expert ledger (an F5 Under 3.5) and was graded on the five-inning score alone — Milwaukee and Los Angeles were tied 4-4 after five, so eight runs, a loss — and it is deliberately excluded from the full-game season record because F5 is a separate market. One Brewers team-total play was also graded and sits outside the card markets. Expert rows with no published price were graded at -110.

Betting involves risk. Only stake what you can afford to lose. If gambling stops being fun, call 1-800-GAMBLER.

DailyOverlay Premium

Get the full graded consensus — every slate.

Free for 5 days, then $19.99/mo. Cancel anytime.

Start your free trial →