MLB Sportsbook Consensus Grading Recap — Monday, October 26, 2026

Sean Zerillo (Action Network) swept World Series Game 3, going 2-0 for +2.07u on Brewers ML (+105) and Over 7 (+102) as Milwaukee won 10-1 at Tropicana Field. That moves him to 3-0 (+2.70u) with us this season. Matt Trollo (Action Network) also cashed Brewers ML (+104) for +1.04u and is now 3-1 (+1.58u), and Mike Spector (Sportsbook Review) hit Brewers ML (+102) for +1.02u to go 12-4 (+6.99u) — a 75% hit rate, the best of any rated MLB expert we track.

Casey Whitmore (TheRX) found the biggest single payout of the night, Brewers -1.5 at +170 (+1.70u), and finished 1-1 (+0.70u) to sit at 14-8 (+5.84u). Jason Green (The Lines) went 1-0 (+1.02u) and is 7-2 (+3.99u) on the season.

The consensus card went 0-2 for -2.00u. STRONG 0-1 (-1.00u), LEAN 0-1 (-1.00u). Every play is graded at the line we posted.

What actually happened

The game turned on one inning. Milwaukee led 2-0 after a two-run third, then put up eight runs in the fifth, all with two outs, on a postseason-record seven straight hits. The rally survived a replay review: Junior Caminero appeared to force William Contreras at second, but the call was overturned and Contreras’ infield single loaded the bases. Brice Turang followed with a liner that glanced off shortstop Taylor Walls’ glove into shallow center for two runs, and Garrett Mitchell, Cooper Pratt (two-run double), Sal Frelick, David Hamilton and Jackson Chourio kept the line moving until it was 10-0.

Freddy Peralta, facing the club he spent most of his career with, was charged with five runs on seven hits over 4⅔ innings and left when the bases loaded in the fifth; Cam Booser and Cole Sulser could not stop it. On the other side, rookie lefty Robert Gasser allowed one hit, a first-inning single by Yandy Díaz, and retired 14 straight. The Rays’ only run came in the ninth. Chourio went 4-for-5 and the Brewers finished with 16 hits and a 3-0 series lead.

Neither card premise was voided — both starters took the ball and the dome kept weather out of it. The Under case rested on Peralta, and he was hit; the Rays case rested on Peralta out-pitching Gasser, and the opposite happened. The consensus was beaten on the merits, with one overturned call extending the inning that decided it.

The card, by tier

Tier Record Hit rate Units
STRONG 0-1-0 0% -1.00u
LEAN 0-1-0 0% -1.00u
Card (STRONG + LEAN) 0-2-0 0% -2.00u

Every play is graded at the line we posted.

Every play

Result Tier Play Line Final Grading
❌ LOSS STRONG Brewers @ Rays — Under 7 -108 DraftKings Brewers 10-1 Rays 10 + 1 = 11 runs, Under 7 loses ❌ · -1.00u
❌ LOSS LEAN Brewers @ Rays — Rays ML -120 DraftKings Brewers 10-1 Rays Brewers win by 9, Rays ML loses ❌ · -1.00u

Best call: Casey Whitmore (TheRX) on Brewers -1.5 at +170 (+1.70u). It needed Milwaukee to win by two; the eight-run, two-out fifth against Peralta and the Rays bullpen made it a nine-run cover, and Gasser’s one-hit start meant Tampa Bay never got back into it.

Worst beat: The STRONG Under 7 (-108). It was dead by the fifth: the seven straight two-out hits took the score from 2-0 to 10-0, and the inning only stayed alive because a force out at second was overturned on replay.

Expert scoreboard — Monday, Oct 26

We graded 28 picks from 23 experts and models. The field went 9-19 (32.1%) against the consensus card’s 0-2 (0%).

Top of the day Pick Record Units
Action Network – Sean Zerillo Brewers ML (+105) + Over 7 (+102) 2-0-0 +2.07u
TheRX – Casey Whitmore Brewers -1.5 (+170); Under 7 (-120) lost 1-1-0 +0.70u
Action Network – Matt Trollo Brewers ML (+104) 1-0-0 +1.04u
Sportsbook Review – Mike Spector Brewers ML (+102) 1-0-0 +1.02u
The Lines – Jason Green Brewers ML (+102) 1-0-0 +1.02u

Also on the Brewers moneyline: Sergey Demidov (RG.org, +102, +1.02u), Josh Schonwald (Doc’s Sports, +100, +1.00u) and Adam Burke (VSiN, -101, +0.99u). At the bottom of the day, Kyle Kargel (WagerTalk) and Kim Smith (Picks and Parlays) each went 0-2 on Rays ML and Under 7, and Anthony Rome (TheSpread) went 0-2 on the first five innings (Rays -0.5 and Under 4) with the Brewers up 10-0 after five.

Season leaders (MLB, graded with us) Record Units Consensus weight
TheSpread – Anthony Rome 17-10-1 +7.06u 1.11
Sportsbook Review – Mike Spector 12-4 +6.99u 1.16
TheRX – Casey Whitmore 14-8 +5.84u 1.10
Covers – Shawn Krest 6-0 +5.79u 1.00 (6 of 15 decided)
The Grueling Truth – Mike Goodpaster 13-7 +4.52u 1.11
The Lines – Jason Green 7-2 +3.99u 1.00 (9 of 15 decided)
Predictem – Joe Jensen 14-10 +3.85u 1.06

How this changes the card

Mike Spector (Sportsbook Review) gained the most weight in the MLB consensus, from 1.14 to 1.16 at 12-4, the top rated weight. Losses on the Under and the Rays trimmed The Grueling Truth’s Mike Goodpaster (1.13 to 1.11, 13-7), TheRX’s Casey Whitmore (1.11 to 1.10, 14-8), Predictem’s Joe Jensen (1.08 to 1.06, 14-10), Bettors Insider’s Earnest Horn (1.05 to 1.02, 10-8), WagerTalk’s Kyle Kargel (1.00 to 0.96, 12-13-1) and Picks and Parlays’ Kim Smith (0.99 to 0.96, 26-26-4). RG.org’s Sergey Demidov moved up from 0.96 to 0.98 at 8-8. Thirteen MLB experts are rated.

Season to date

Tier All Run line Moneyline Total Units
STRONG 10-14-1 2-1 3-5 5-8-1 -4.87u
LEAN 25-11 5-1 10-5 10-5 +10.08u
FADE-WATCH (not staked) 0-1 — 0-1 — —
Card (STRONG + LEAN) 35-25-1 +5.21u

Every card, every sport: the full consensus record.

Three first-five-innings picks (TheSpread – Anthony Rome x2, Winners and Whiners – Alex MacMillan) were graded on the 10-0 score after five and are shown in the scoreboard, but they are left out of the season ledger, which tracks full-game run line, moneyline and total. CBS Sports – Matt Severance’s Rays +1 alternate run line had no published price and is graded at -110. Final score from the Baseball-Reference box score; game details from ESPN’s recap.

Please bet responsibly. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER.

DailyOverlay Premium

Get the full graded consensus — every slate.

Free for 5 days, then $19.99/mo. Cancel anytime.

Start your free trial →