MLB Sportsbook Consensus Grading Recap — Tuesday, October 06, 2026
The grading found its winners at Petco and Truist on Tuesday night. Jason Martinak of Bettors Insider was the best capper on the board, 2-0 for +2.58 units, built on a Dodgers −1.5 run line at +162 and the Dodgers moneyline at −104; he is 2-1 (+1.58u) on everything we have graded him on this season. Kim Smith of Picks and Parlays went 3-0 with a push for +2.37 units and in doing so became the first MLB capper to clear our 15-pick rating bar, now 10-7-3 (+1.05u) across 17 decided picks. Kyle Kargel of WagerTalk logged the busiest night of anyone and came out 4-1 with a push for +2.10 units, and Ryan Gilbert of Sports Illustrated went 2-0 for +1.67 units with the Dodgers at Truist and the Padres at Petco. Joe Jensen of Predictem added a clean 1-0 (+0.96u) and now sits 6-3 (+3.31u) on the season.
The consensus card went 3-0 for +2.21 units on three plays across the two NLDS Game 3s. All three were LEAN; no STRONG play and no FADE-WATCH ran. One run-line play, one moneyline and one total, each graded at the line we posted at 09:40 CT.
What actually happened
At Petco, San Diego survived 4-3. The Padres took a 2-0 lead in the third on a Fernando Tatis Jr. groundout and a Manny Machado RBI single. Pat Murphy pulled Dustin May in the fourth after a leadoff walk — a quick hook off a rested bullpen, not an injury, so the pitching matchup the consensus handicapped did largely happen. William Contreras answered with a solo homer in the fourth and Jackson Chourio tied it at 2-2 on a fifth-inning sacrifice fly, but Jake Cronenworth took Antonio Senzatela out of the park in the bottom of the fifth to put San Diego back ahead, and Xander Bogaerts scored on a Pratt error in the sixth for the run that ended up deciding it. Milwaukee got one back in the eighth and left eleven men on base over the night. Michael King threw the last two innings for the save on one day of rest after starting Game 2, San Diego having lost closer Mason Miller to the paternity list forty-five minutes before first pitch and setup man Adrian Morejon to shoulder stiffness; Bogaerts fielded a 107 mph line drive on his knees for a game-ending double play.
Those eleven stranded runners are the whole story of the Petco total. The game landed on exactly seven runs, which pushed every Under 7 and Over 7 ticket in the ledger and left Over 7.5 a half-run short. The card carried no play on that number.
At Truist Park it was 3-1 Dodgers, and it was Yoshinobu Yamamoto: seven innings, one run, four hits, one walk, ten strikeouts, a postseason career high. Atlanta’s only run came in the fifth with the bases loaded and one out. Kike Hernandez hit a two-run homer in the fourth to score Andy Pages and Freddie Freeman added a solo shot, both off Chris Sale. Four combined runs with the two best starters of the round doing exactly what the six handicappers on the Under said they would; the four models on the Over were working off a 7.7-run projection that never came within three runs of the result.
Tier report — Tuesday, October 6
| Tier | Record | Hit rate | Units |
|---|---|---|---|
| STRONG | — none ran | — | 0.00u |
| LEAN | 3-0-0 | 100.0% | +2.21u |
| FADE-WATCH | — none ran | — | 0.00u |
| Card total (STRONG + LEAN) | 3-0-0 | 100.0% | +2.21u |
Every play is graded at the line we posted, at flat one-unit stakes. FADE-WATCH plays are watches, not staked plays, and are kept out of the card record.
Every play on the card
| Result | Tier | Game | Market | Consensus pick | Final | Units |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| WIN | LEAN | Brewers at Padres | Run line | Brewers +1.5 (−192) | Padres 4-3 Brewers | +0.52u |
| WIN | LEAN | Brewers at Padres | Moneyline | Padres ML (−137) | Padres 4-3 Brewers | +0.73u |
| WIN | LEAN | Dodgers at Braves | Total | Under 6.0 (−104) | Dodgers 3-1 Braves | +0.96u |
Arithmetic: Milwaukee lost by one, so +1.5 covers. San Diego won the game, so the moneyline cashes. 3 + 1 = 4 runs against a 6.0 total, so the Under cashes.
Best call
Jason Martinak of Bettors Insider, Dodgers −1.5 at +162. It was the only run-line ticket of the night that needed a two-run margin and got precisely that: Yamamoto’s ten strikeouts kept Atlanta to one run, and the two homers off Sale supplied the margin without ever threatening to blow the game open. Worth +1.62 units, the biggest single win on the board.
Worst beat
The SportsGrid model’s Over 7.5 at Petco. Milwaukee left eleven runners on base and the game stopped on exactly seven runs, a half-run short — and the same number pushed three Under 7 tickets and the SportsLine model’s Over 7. One more Brewers runner home in the eighth and four separate rows on the board read differently.
Expert scoreboard — Tuesday, October 6
We graded 30 experts and models on 53 logged picks and 49 decided plays: the field went 29-20 with four pushes for +4.34 units, a 59.2% hit rate. A further seven logged rows were excluded before grading and carry NO ACTION at zero units — four series-winner calls, a series price dated October 2, a same-game parlay and one run-line row whose side could not be read with confidence.
| Top of the day | Outlet | Day | Units | Season with us |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jason Martinak | Bettors Insider | 2-0-0 | +2.58u | 2-1 (+1.58u) |
| Kim Smith | Picks and Parlays | 3-0-1 | +2.37u | 10-7-3 (+1.05u) |
| Kyle Kargel | WagerTalk | 4-1-1 | +2.10u | 6-5-1 (−0.02u) |
| Ryan Gilbert | Sports Illustrated | 2-0-0 | +1.67u | 3-3 (−0.38u) |
| Joe Jensen | Predictem | 1-0-0 | +0.96u | 6-3 (+3.31u) |
| Bottom of the day | Outlet | Day | Units |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dimers model | Dimers | 0-3-0 | −3.00u |
| SportsGrid model | SportsGrid | 1-3-0 | −2.48u |
| Alex MacMillan | Winners and Whiners | 0-2-0 | −2.00u |
| Ryan Minion | Action Network | 0-1-0 | −1.00u |
| Jon Metler | Covers | 0-1-0 | −1.00u |
Four more rows finished at −1.00u on a single losing pick: the SportsLine model, David Racey of Sports Chat Place, Randy Chambers of Sports Chat Place and the numberFire model.
Consensus versus the field: the card hit 100% on three decided plays against the all-expert hit rate of 59.2% on 49. The three plays the consensus concentrated on were the three it got right.
Season leaders in the MLB ledger
| Expert | Outlet | Season | Hit rate | Units | Weight |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Anthony Rome | TheSpread | 7-2 | 77.8% | +5.00u | 1.00 (building) |
| Shawn Krest | Covers | 5-0 | 100% | +4.88u | 1.00 (building) |
| Casey Whitmore | TheRX | 6-2 | 75.0% | +3.35u | 1.00 (building) |
| Joe Jensen | Predictem | 6-3 | 66.7% | +3.31u | 1.00 (building) |
| Mike Spector | Sportsbook Review | 4-1 | 80.0% | +3.11u | 1.00 (building) |
| Kim Smith | Picks and Parlays | 10-7-3 | 58.8% | +1.05u | 1.05 (rated) |
| SportsGrid model | SportsGrid | 5-15 | 25.0% | −10.88u | 0.77 (rated) |
How this changes the card
An expert holds a neutral weight of 1.00 in the consensus until we have graded 15 decided picks of theirs, and today the MLB board gained its second rated capper. Kim Smith of Picks and Parlays crossed the bar at 10-7-3 across 17 decided picks and a 58.8% hit rate, and now carries a weight of 1.05 — real pull, earned on a real sample, more than a capper we have never seen hit. The SportsGrid model moves the other way: 5-15 on 20 decided picks, a 25% hit rate and −10.88 units have taken it down to 0.77, and three of its four picks lost again on Tuesday. Everyone else is still at 1.00 while we build the sample, and two are close: Thom Cunningham of Lineups and Kyle Kargel of WagerTalk each sit at 11 decided picks, four short of qualifying. Nobody above was weighted differently on Tuesday’s card — the new weights apply to cards from here.
Season to date — MLB consensus card
| Tier | Market | Record | Units |
|---|---|---|---|
| STRONG | Run line | 2-0 | +1.86u |
| Moneyline | 1-2 | −0.70u | |
| Totals | 1-2 | −1.13u | |
| All STRONG | 4-4 | +0.03u | |
| LEAN | Run line | 3-1 | +0.61u |
| Moneyline | 3-2 | +0.25u | |
| Totals | 6-2 | +3.31u | |
| All LEAN | 12-5 | +4.17u | |
| Card total (STRONG + LEAN) | 16-9 | +4.20u | |
| FADE-WATCH | none staked | 0.00u | |
Five MLB game dates graded so far. STRONG and LEAN are reported separately because they are telling different stories: the LEAN tier carries the profit, and the STRONG tier is essentially flat at +0.03 units over eight plays.
Grading notes
Both games were FINAL in nine innings with no extra innings, no delays, no postponements and no suspended games; scores were confirmed against ESPN and the AP wire recap. Every play is graded against the exact line stored when the card was posted. One expert row, Jay Sanin of ATS.io, was published only at 55 cents on a prediction market with no sportsbook price, so it was graded at the standard −110 default. No first-five-innings plays appeared on either the card or the expert ledger. The full graded sheets for both files are archived for the date.
Betting involves risk and no record guarantees a future result. Bet only what you can afford to lose, and if gambling stops being fun, call 1-800-GAMBLER or visit ncpgambling.org.
Get the full graded consensus — every slate.
Free for 5 days, then $19.99/mo. Cancel anytime.
