MLB Sportsbook Consensus Picks — Sunday, July 19, 2026

Sources: 5 predictive model sites (Dimers, OddsShark, DRatings, OddsTrader, MyGameSim), 16 Action Network experts, 4 named cappers at Sports Chat Place, and 8 named handicappers at Pickswise. Moneyline board: 136 total picks (78 model, 35 Action Network, 10 Sports Chat Place, 13 Pickswise) across 16 games. Totals board: 95 total picks (63 model, 24 Action Network, 4 Sports Chat Place, 4 Pickswise) across 16 games — only 4 of those sites publish a totals vote. All start times Eastern.

Across the 16-game slate, 8 of 16 games reached STRONG consensus on the Moneyline board and 6 of 16 reached STRONG on the Totals board.

Strongest Overlay: Pittsburgh Pirates over Cleveland Guardians — STRONG tier, 75% agreement (6/8 sources), average plus-money price of roughly +18. Two other plus-money overlays also cleared consensus today: Atlanta Braves over Texas Rangers (Lean, 55%, ~+60) and St. Louis Cardinals over Arizona Diamondbacks (Lean, 56%, ~+3). Overlay applies to the moneyline board only.

Moneyline Consensus Board

MatchupStart (ET)ConsensusAgreeSourcesOddsTierOverlay
Detroit Tigers @ Los Angeles Angels4:07 PMTigers89% (8/9)9-50STRONG 
Minnesota Twins @ Chicago Cubs2:20 PMCubs86% (6/7)7-98STRONG 
Cincinnati Reds @ Colorado Rockies3:10 PMReds86% (6/7)7-138STRONG 
New York Mets @ Philadelphia Phillies1:35 PMMets78% (7/9)9-122STRONG 
Pittsburgh Pirates @ Cleveland Guardians1:40 PMPirates75% (6/8)8+18STRONG✓
Los Angeles Dodgers @ New York Yankees12:35 PMDodgers75% (6/8)8-77STRONG 
Washington Nationals @ Athletics4:05 PMNationals73% (8/11)11-29STRONG 
Baltimore Orioles @ Houston Astros2:10 PMAstros71% (5/7)7-60STRONG 
Los Angeles Dodgers @ New York Yankees7:20 PMDodgers60% (3/5)5-117Lean 
San Diego Padres @ Kansas City Royals2:10 PMRoyals57% (4/7)7-115Lean 
Miami Marlins @ Milwaukee Brewers2:10 PMBrewers56% (5/9)9-123Lean 
St. Louis Cardinals @ Arizona Diamondbacks4:10 PMCardinals56% (5/9)9+3Lean✓
Tampa Bay Rays @ Boston Red Sox1:35 PMRed Sox55% (6/11)11-119Lean 
Texas Rangers @ Atlanta Braves1:35 PMBraves55% (6/11)11+60Lean✓
Chicago White Sox @ Toronto Blue Jays12:15 PMWhite Sox50% (6/12)12-76Split 
San Francisco Giants @ Seattle Mariners4:10 PMMariners50% (3/6)6-185Split 

Totals Consensus Board — Over/Under

MatchupStart (ET)ConsensusAgreeSourcesLineTier
Pittsburgh Pirates @ Cleveland Guardians1:40 PMOver100% (5/5)57STRONG
Detroit Tigers @ Los Angeles Angels4:07 PMUnder83% (5/6)69.5STRONG
Tampa Bay Rays @ Boston Red Sox1:35 PMUnder80% (4/5)58.5STRONG
Texas Rangers @ Atlanta Braves1:35 PMUnder75% (3/4)48.5STRONG
Baltimore Orioles @ Houston Astros2:10 PMOver75% (6/8)88.5STRONG
Washington Nationals @ Athletics4:05 PMUnder75% (3/4)410.5STRONG
San Francisco Giants @ Seattle Mariners4:10 PMUnder62% (5/8)87.5Lean
Chicago White Sox @ Toronto Blue Jays12:15 PMOver60% (3/5)58Lean
New York Mets @ Philadelphia Phillies1:35 PMUnder60% (3/5)59Lean
San Diego Padres @ Kansas City Royals2:10 PMUnder60% (3/5)59.5Lean
Los Angeles Dodgers @ New York Yankees12:35 PMUnder60% (6/10)108Lean
Los Angeles Dodgers @ New York Yankees7:20 PMOver60% (3/5)59Lean
St. Louis Cardinals @ Arizona Diamondbacks4:10 PMOver57% (4/7)79Lean
Miami Marlins @ Milwaukee Brewers2:10 PMSplit50% (0/6)6—Split
Minnesota Twins @ Chicago Cubs2:20 PMSplit50% (0/6)6—Split
Cincinnati Reds @ Colorado Rockies3:10 PMSplit50% (0/6)6—Split

Graded Result

Moneyline consensus went 11–5 (68.8% right), +3.5u, +22.1% ROI. STRONG: 6–2. Leans: 3–3. Split: 2–0. Overlays: 2–1.

Totals consensus went 6–7 (46.2% right), -1.5u, -11.8% ROI. STRONG: 4–2. Pushes: 0.

Correction: nine moneyline board odds were replaced with ESPN’s verified Close ML (asterisked in the table below) because the board value was an invalid/implausible magnitude (under 100) or contradicted ESPN’s actual favorite — including both non-Pirates overlays: Pittsburgh Pirates (board +18 → ESPN -107, not an underdog) and Atlanta Braves (board +60 → ESPN -103, not an underdog). Other corrections: Tigers -50→-149, Cubs -98→-181, Dodgers (12:35) -77→-131, Nationals -29→-148, Astros -60→-127, Cardinals +3→+104, White Sox -76→-112. All units above use the corrected odds.

Moneyline

MatchupConsensusOddsResultUnits
Detroit Tigers @ Los Angeles AngelsTigers-149*✗-1.00u
Minnesota Twins @ Chicago CubsCubs-181*✓+0.55u
Cincinnati Reds @ Colorado RockiesReds-138✓+0.72u
New York Mets @ Philadelphia PhilliesMets-122✓+0.82u
Pittsburgh Pirates @ Cleveland GuardiansPirates-107*✓+0.93u
Los Angeles Dodgers @ New York Yankees (12:35 PM)Dodgers-131*✓+0.76u
Washington Nationals @ AthleticsNationals-148*✓+0.68u
Baltimore Orioles @ Houston AstrosAstros-127*✗-1.00u
Los Angeles Dodgers @ New York Yankees (7:20 PM)Dodgers-117✗-1.00u
San Diego Padres @ Kansas City RoyalsRoyals-115✗-1.00u
Miami Marlins @ Milwaukee BrewersBrewers-123✓+0.81u
St. Louis Cardinals @ Arizona DiamondbacksCardinals+104*✗-1.00u
Tampa Bay Rays @ Boston Red SoxRed Sox-119✓+0.84u
Texas Rangers @ Atlanta BravesBraves-103*✓+0.97u
Chicago White Sox @ Toronto Blue JaysWhite Sox-112*✓+0.89u
San Francisco Giants @ Seattle MarinersMariners-185✓+0.54u

Totals

MatchupConsensusLineFinal TotalResultUnits
Pittsburgh Pirates @ Cleveland GuardiansOver78✓+0.91u
Detroit Tigers @ Los Angeles AngelsUnder9.55✓+0.91u
Tampa Bay Rays @ Boston Red SoxUnder8.57✓+0.91u
Texas Rangers @ Atlanta BravesUnder8.513✗-1.00u
Baltimore Orioles @ Houston AstrosOver8.57✗-1.00u
Washington Nationals @ AthleticsUnder10.57✓+0.91u
San Francisco Giants @ Seattle MarinersUnder7.59✗-1.00u
Chicago White Sox @ Toronto Blue JaysOver83✗-1.00u
New York Mets @ Philadelphia PhilliesUnder97✓+0.91u
San Diego Padres @ Kansas City RoyalsUnder9.521✗-1.00u
Los Angeles Dodgers @ New York Yankees (12:35 PM)Under810✗-1.00u
Los Angeles Dodgers @ New York Yankees (7:20 PM)Over93✗-1.00u
St. Louis Cardinals @ Arizona DiamondbacksOver915✓+0.91u
Miami Marlins @ Milwaukee BrewersSplit—4—0u
Minnesota Twins @ Chicago CubsSplit—11—0u
Cincinnati Reds @ Colorado RockiesSplit—15—0u
DailyOverlay Premium

Get the full graded consensus — every slate.

Free for 5 days, then $19.99/mo. Cancel anytime.

Start your free trial →