MLB Sportsbook Consensus Picks — Tuesday, June 23, 2026

Sources aggregated with equal (flat) weighting. Moneyline board: 4 computer-model sites (Dimers, OddsShark, DRatings, OddsTrader) plus 22 Action Network expert moneyline/side picks — 82 source-picks. Totals board: 3 model sites that publish an Over/Under pick (OddsShark, DRatings, OddsTrader) plus Action Network expert O/U picks — 59 source-picks. Free expert-pick sites were also checked. All start times Eastern.

Today’s slate is 15 MLB games. On the moneyline, 10 of 15 reached our STRONG tier (≥66% agreement with ≥4 sources). On totals, 5 of 15 reached STRONG — an Over-leaning model crowd against an Under-leaning Action Network expert pool produced more Splits.

Strongest Overlay (moneyline): Two plus-money consensus sides today. The strongest is the Athletics vs. the Giants (9:45 PM ET) — 4 of 7 sources at an average +112. The other is the Reds vs. the Brewers (7:10 PM ET), 3 of 5 at an average +32. Both Lean-tier value flags. (Overlay applies to moneyline only; totals are priced near even both ways.)

Moneyline Consensus Board

Matchup (Away @ Home)Start (ET)ConsensusAgreeSourcesOddsTierOverlay
Yankees @ Tigers6:40 PMYankees83%6-105STRONG 
Braves @ Padres9:40 PMBraves83%6-109STRONG 
Mariners @ Pirates6:40 PMMariners80%5-119STRONG 
Dodgers @ Twins7:40 PMDodgers80%5-160STRONG 
Guardians @ White Sox7:40 PMGuardians80%5-108STRONG 
Red Sox @ Rockies8:40 PMRed Sox80%5-150STRONG 
Orioles @ Angels9:38 PMOrioles80%5-135STRONG 
Royals @ Rays6:40 PMRays75%4-176STRONG 
Rangers @ Marlins6:40 PMMarlins75%4-148STRONG 
Phillies @ Nationals6:45 PMPhillies67%6-146STRONG 
Cubs @ Mets7:10 PMMets60%5-106Lean 
Brewers @ Reds7:10 PMReds60%5+32Lean✓
Athletics @ Giants9:45 PMAthletics57%7+112Lean✓
Astros @ Blue Jays4:07 PMBlue Jays50%6-121Split 
D-Backs @ Cardinals7:45 PMCardinals50%8-108Split 

Totals Consensus Board — Over/Under

Consensus is the Over/Under direction most sources back; Line is the median posted total on that side. Split = sources evenly divided.

Matchup (Away @ Home)Start (ET)ConsensusAgreeSourcesLineTier
Athletics @ Giants9:45 PMOver80%5O 8.5STRONG
Phillies @ Nationals6:45 PMOver75%4O 8.5STRONG
Cubs @ Mets7:10 PMOver75%4O 8STRONG
D-Backs @ Cardinals7:45 PMOver75%4O 8.5STRONG
Orioles @ Angels9:38 PMOver75%4O 9STRONG
Yankees @ Tigers6:40 PMUnder67%3U 8Lean
Rangers @ Marlins6:40 PMUnder67%3U 8.5Lean
Guardians @ White Sox7:40 PMUnder67%3U 7Lean
Red Sox @ Rockies8:40 PMUnder67%3U 10.5Lean
Mariners @ Pirates6:40 PMOver60%5O 8.5Lean
Brewers @ Reds7:10 PMOver60%5O 9.5Lean
Royals @ Rays6:40 PMSplit50%68Split
Dodgers @ Twins7:40 PMSplit50%49Split
Braves @ Padres9:40 PMSplit50%48¼Split
Astros @ Blue Jays4:07 PMSplit50%28.5Low sample

Graded Result

Moneyline consensus went 6–7 (46.2% right), −2.6u, −19.7% ROI. STRONG: 6–4. Overlays: 0–2.

MatchupConsensusOddsResultUnits
Yankees @ TigersYankees-105✓+0.95
Braves @ PadresBraves-109✗−1.00
Mariners @ PiratesMariners-119✓+0.84
Dodgers @ TwinsDodgers-160✓+0.63
Guardians @ White SoxGuardians-108✗−1.00
Red Sox @ RockiesRed Sox-150✓+0.67
Orioles @ AngelsOrioles-135✗−1.00
Royals @ RaysRays-176✗−1.00
Rangers @ MarlinsMarlins-148✓+0.68
Phillies @ NationalsPhillies-146✓+0.68
Cubs @ MetsMets-106✗−1.00
Brewers @ RedsReds+32✗−1.00
Athletics @ GiantsAthletics+112✗−1.00

Totals consensus went 5–6 (45.5% right), −1.5u, −13.2% ROI. STRONG: 2–3. Pushes: 0.

MatchupConsensusLineFinal TotalResultUnits
Athletics @ GiantsOver8.54✗−1.00
Phillies @ NationalsOver8.523✓+0.91
Cubs @ MetsOver815✓+0.91
D-Backs @ CardinalsOver8.57✗−1.00
Orioles @ AngelsOver96✗−1.00
Yankees @ TigersUnder87✓+0.91
Rangers @ MarlinsUnder8.510✗−1.00
Guardians @ White SoxUnder73✓+0.91
Red Sox @ RockiesUnder10.57✓+0.91
Mariners @ PiratesOver8.55✗−1.00
Brewers @ RedsOver9.52✗−1.00
DailyOverlay Premium

Get the full graded consensus — every slate.

Free for 5 days, then $19.99/mo. Cancel anytime.

Start your free trial →