MLB Sportsbook Consensus Picks — Wednesday, June 17, 2026

Sources aggregated (flat, equal weight): 4 model/prediction sites (Dimers, OddsShark, DRatings, OddsTrader) • 15 individual Action Network expert picks • 6 free expert sites (Covers, Pickswise, Sportsbook Review, Winners & Whiners, Predictem, WagerTalk). Total: 95 source-picks across 14 games.

Today’s moneyline consensus covers all 14 games on the MLB slate. Of those, 13 reached STRONG agreement (≥66% of sources aligned with at least 4 total sources), 1 graded as a Lean, and 0 as a Split. Every consensus side today is a market favorite, so plus-money value is scarce.

Strongest Overlay: No plus-money overlays today — the consensus landed on a favorite (negative moneyline) in every game on the board.

Full Consensus Board — Moneyline

MatchupConsensusAgreeSourcesOddsTierOverlay
Mets @ RedsMets100%6-128STRONG 
Royals @ NationalsNationals100%6-125STRONG 
Padres @ CardinalsCardinals100%4-122STRONG 
White Sox @ YankeesYankees100%7-176STRONG 
Giants @ BravesBraves100%7-137STRONG 
Rays @ DodgersDodgers86%7-149STRONG 
Rockies @ CubsCubs86%7-178STRONG 
Pirates @ AthleticsPirates78%9-119STRONG 
Angels @ DiamondbacksDiamondbacks71%7-159STRONG 
Orioles @ MarinersMariners71%7-130STRONG 
Marlins @ PhilliesPhillies67%6-112STRONG 
Tigers @ AstrosTigers67%6-105STRONG 
Guardians @ BrewersBrewers67%9-117STRONG 
Blue Jays @ Red SoxRed Sox57%7-121Lean 

Graded Result

Consensus went 7-7 (50.0% right), -2.1u, -15.0% ROI. STRONG plays: 7-6. Overlays: 0-0.

MATCHUPCONSENSUSODDSTIERRESULT
Mets @ RedsMets-128STRONG✓ +0.78u
Royals @ NationalsNationals-125STRONG✗ -1.00u
Padres @ CardinalsCardinals-122STRONG✗ -1.00u
White Sox @ YankeesYankees-176STRONG✓ +0.57u
Giants @ BravesBraves-137STRONG✗ -1.00u
Rays @ DodgersDodgers-149STRONG✓ +0.67u
Rockies @ CubsCubs-178STRONG✓ +0.56u
Pirates @ AthleticsPirates-119STRONG✓ +0.84u
Angels @ DiamondbacksDiamondbacks-159STRONG✓ +0.63u
Orioles @ MarinersMariners-130STRONG✗ -1.00u
Marlins @ PhilliesPhillies-112STRONG✗ -1.00u
Tigers @ AstrosTigers-105STRONG✗ -1.00u
Guardians @ BrewersBrewers-117STRONG✓ +0.85u
Blue Jays @ Red SoxRed Sox-121Lean✗ -1.00u
DailyOverlay Premium

Get the full graded consensus — every slate.

Free for 5 days, then $19.99/mo. Cancel anytime.

Start your free trial →