MLB Sportsbook Consensus Picks — Wednesday, June 24, 2026

Sources — Moneyline board: 4 model sites, 19 Action Network expert picks, 1 free pick site (82 source picks). Totals board: 3 model sites, 16 Action Network over/under picks, 1 free pick site (67 source picks). All start times Eastern.

Across today’s 15-game MLB slate, 9 of 15 games reached a STRONG consensus on the moneyline board, and 9 of 15 reached STRONG on the totals (over/under) board. Each source — every model site, each Action Network expert, and each free-pick site — counts equally (flat weighting).

Strongest Overlay: White Sox +104 vs. Guardians (2:10 PM ET) — the lone plus-money consensus side on today’s board (Lean, 57% agreement). It is the only overlay play of the day. Overlay applies to the moneyline board only; the totals board is priced near −110 either way, so it shows the consensus line instead.

Moneyline Consensus Board

MatchupStart (ET)ConsensusAgreeSourcesOddsTierOverlay
Rangers @ Marlins12:10 PMRangers80%4/5-110STRONG 
Red Sox @ Rockies3:10 PMRed Sox80%4/5-156STRONG 
Orioles @ Angels4:07 PMAngels67%4/6-119STRONG 
Yankees @ Tigers6:40 PMTigers80%4/5-130STRONG 
Phillies @ Nationals6:45 PMPhillies80%4/5-126STRONG 
Astros @ Blue Jays7:07 PMBlue Jays100%5/5-134STRONG 
Brewers @ Reds7:10 PMBrewers100%5/5-129STRONG 
Braves @ Padres8:40 PMBraves78%7/9-120STRONG 
Athletics @ Giants9:45 PMAthletics67%4/6-110STRONG 
Guardians @ White Sox2:10 PMWhite Sox57%4/7+104Lean✓
Royals @ Rays6:40 PMRays60%3/5-140Lean 
Dodgers @ Twins7:40 PMDodgers60%3/5-163Lean 
Cubs @ Mets1:10 PMCubs50%3/6-113Split 
Mariners @ Pirates6:40 PMPirates50%2/4-109Split 
Diamondbacks @ Cardinals7:45 PMCardinals50%2/4-110Split 

Totals Consensus Board — Over/Under

MatchupStart (ET)ConsensusAgreeSourcesLineTier
Rangers @ Marlins12:10 PMUnder75%3/4U 7.5STRONG
Cubs @ Mets1:10 PMUnder80%4/5U 8.5STRONG
Guardians @ White Sox2:10 PMUnder80%4/5U 8.5STRONG
Red Sox @ Rockies3:10 PMUnder100%4/4U 11STRONG
Orioles @ Angels4:07 PMUnder100%4/4U 9.5STRONG
Yankees @ Tigers6:40 PMUnder67%4/6U 7.5STRONG
Mariners @ Pirates6:40 PMUnder75%3/4U 7.5STRONG
Phillies @ Nationals6:45 PMOver75%3/4O 9.5STRONG
Athletics @ Giants9:45 PMOver80%4/5O 8STRONG
Royals @ Rays6:40 PMOver67%2/3O 7.5Lean
Astros @ Blue Jays7:07 PMOver67%2/3O 8.5Lean
Brewers @ Reds7:10 PMUnder60%3/5U 9.5Lean
Diamondbacks @ Cardinals7:45 PMOver67%2/3O 9Lean
Dodgers @ Twins7:40 PMSplit50%3/6O/U 8Split
Braves @ Padres8:40 PMSplit50%3/6O/U 8Split

Graded Result

Moneyline consensus went 5–7 (41.7% right), −3.3u, −27.2% ROI. STRONG: 3–6. Overlays: 0–1.

Totals consensus went 5–8 (38.5% right), −3.5u, −26.5% ROI. STRONG: 3–6. Pushes: 0.

Moneyline

MatchupConsensusOddsResultUnits
Rangers @ MarlinsRangers-110✗-1.00
Red Sox @ RockiesRed Sox-156✗-1.00
Orioles @ AngelsAngels-119✓+0.84
Yankees @ TigersTigers-130✗-1.00
Phillies @ NationalsPhillies-126✓+0.79
Astros @ Blue JaysBlue Jays-134✗-1.00
Brewers @ RedsBrewers-129✓+0.78
Braves @ PadresBraves-120✗-1.00
Athletics @ GiantsAthletics-110✗-1.00
Guardians @ White SoxWhite Sox +104 (Overlay)+104✗-1.00
Royals @ RaysRays-140✓+0.71
Dodgers @ TwinsDodgers-163✓+0.61

Totals (Over/Under)

MatchupConsensusLineFinal TotalResultUnits
Rangers @ MarlinsUnder7.56✓+0.91
Cubs @ MetsUnder8.513 / 15 (DH)✗-1.00
Guardians @ White SoxUnder8.57✓+0.91
Red Sox @ RockiesUnder1114✗-1.00
Orioles @ AngelsUnder9.513✗-1.00
Yankees @ TigersUnder7.56✓+0.91
Mariners @ PiratesUnder7.512✗-1.00
Phillies @ NationalsOver9.59✗-1.00
Athletics @ GiantsOver83✗-1.00
Royals @ RaysOver7.58✓+0.91
Astros @ Blue JaysOver8.54✗-1.00
Brewers @ RedsUnder9.511✗-1.00
Diamondbacks @ CardinalsOver913✓+0.91

Moneyline graded at posted odds (1u stake). Totals graded at standard −110 (win +0.91u). Split/low-sample games are no-action and excluded from records. Cubs–Mets played a doubleheader; both games landed Over 8.5.

DailyOverlay Premium

Get the full graded consensus — every slate.

Free for 5 days, then $19.99/mo. Cancel anytime.

Start your free trial →