MLB Sportsbook Consensus — Weekly Report Card (Jun 22 – Jun 28, 2026)

Our Week-in-Review report card grades every model, expert, and free site that posted MLB picks from Monday, June 22 through Sunday, June 28, 2026, across both the moneyline and totals (Over/Under) markets — each on a binary RIGHT/WRONG basis (totals can also push). The house Daily Overlay lines are our top-consensus plays (sources agreeing ≥75%).

This week the Daily Overlay Moneyline (≥75%) went 24–27 (47.1%), -7.80u (ROI -15.3%), while the Daily Overlay Totals (≥75%) went 17–15 (53.1%), +0.47u (ROI +1.5%). The week’s best moneyline source was AN: Jake (+3.57u, 4–1), and the best totals source was DRatings (+3.95u, 45–37).

Moneyline units priced at each source’s posted odds (missing prices defaulted to −110); totals graded at −110. Moneyline covers Mon–Sun; per-source totals data began Tue, June 23 (no totals feed on June 22). Postponed games (Cubs–Mets 6/22, D-backs–Cardinals 6/25) graded as void. This is the inaugural weekly report card, so no season-to-date line is shown yet.

Moneyline — Per-Source Leaderboard

SourcePicksRecordHit %Net UnitsROI
AN: Jake54–180.0%+3.57u+71.3%
AN: Picks Office138–561.5%+2.73u+21.0%
Pickswise2916–1355.2%+2.55u+8.8%
SCP: Nikos Lagouretos96–366.7%+2.45u+27.3%
AN: Sean Zerillo137–653.8%+1.84u+14.1%
AN: Sean Paul22–0100.0%+1.54u+77.0%
SCP: David Racey95–455.6%+0.55u+6.1%
AN: Brian Bitler189–950.0%+0.43u+2.4%
SCP: Chris Ruffolo74–357.1%+0.38u+5.4%
AN: Frank Ammirante137–653.8%+0.26u+2.0%
AN: OldSchool090963–350.0%+0.02u+0.3%
AN: Nick Martin42–250.0%-0.10u-2.4%
AN: Ryan Minion42–250.0%-0.22u-5.5%
Covers116–554.5%-0.23u-2.0%
AN: tonysartori9921–150.0%-0.25u-12.4%
AN: Kyle Murray73–442.9%-0.79u-11.3%
AN: Austin Pendergrass10–10.0%-1.00u-100.0%
Sportsbook Review10–10.0%-1.00u-100.0%
AN: Alex Hinton10–10.0%-1.00u-100.0%
AN: Sandy Plashkes147–750.0%-1.02u-7.3%
MyGameSim4523–2251.1%-1.45u-3.2%
DRatings9552–4354.7%-1.51u-1.6%
AN: Lock & Cash20–20.0%-2.00u-100.0%
SCP: Randy Chambers114–736.4%-3.44u-31.3%
AN: Matt Trollo82–625.0%-3.80u-47.5%
AN: Adam Kaufman3214–1843.8%-4.69u-14.7%
Dimers9248–4452.2%-4.99u-5.4%
OddsShark9348–4551.6%-5.48u-5.9%
OddsTrader9538–5740.0%-19.08u-20.1%

Totals — Per-Source Leaderboard

SourcePicksRecordHit %Net UnitsROI
DRatings8245–37–054.9%+3.95u+4.8%
AN: Brandon Kravitz149–5–064.3%+3.19u+22.8%
MyGameSim4424–20–054.5%+1.84u+4.2%
AN: Sean Paul22–0–0100.0%+1.82u+91.0%
AN: Anders43–1–075.0%+1.73u+43.3%
SCP: David Racey43–1–075.0%+1.73u+43.3%
AN: Matt Trollo85–3–062.5%+1.55u+19.4%
AN: Kyle Murray11–0–0100.0%+0.91u+91.0%
AN: The Pick Don11–0–0100.0%+0.91u+91.0%
SCP: Chris Ruffolo11–0–0100.0%+0.91u+91.0%
AN: Jake11–0–0100.0%+0.91u+91.0%
AN: Allan Lem42–2–050.0%-0.18u-4.5%
SCP: Nikos Lagouretos42–2–050.0%-0.18u-4.5%
AN: Ryan Minion10–1–00.0%-1.00u-100.0%
AN: Sandy Plashkes61–5–016.7%-4.09u-68.2%
AN: Picks Office145–9–035.7%-4.45u-31.8%
OddsTrader7939–40–049.4%-4.51u-5.7%
AN: Frank Ammirante208–12–040.0%-4.72u-23.6%
AN: Sean Zerillo208–12–040.0%-4.72u-23.6%
Covers92–7–022.2%-5.18u-57.6%
Pickswise60–6–00.0%-6.00u-100.0%
OddsShark8137–44–045.7%-10.33u-12.8%

Daily Overlay (≥75% consensus)

SegmentRecordHit %Net UnitsROI
Daily Overlay — Moneyline24–2747.1%-7.80u-15.3%
Daily Overlay — Totals17–1553.1%+0.47u+1.5%

Daily Overlay — Day by Day

DateMoneyline RecordML UnitsTotals RecordTotals Units
Mon Jun 223–5-2.85u——
Tue Jun 235–4-0.26u2–3-1.18u
Wed Jun 242–5-3.41u2–6-4.18u
Thu Jun 251–2-1.22u1–2-1.09u
Fri Jun 266–0+5.38u6–1+4.46u
Sat Jun 273–5-2.44u3–1+1.73u
Sun Jun 284–6-3.00u3–2+0.73u
DailyOverlay Premium

Get the full graded consensus — every slate.

Free for 5 days, then $19.99/mo. Cancel anytime.

Start your free trial →

Season to date — the card

Live from the grading ledger, so it includes every game graded since this recap went up.

MLB consensus card

Graded Sep 29 – Oct 28 · 21 graded days
Card (STRONG + LEAN)
38-26-1
+6.55u · 59.4%
STRONG
11-14-1
-4.23u · 44%
LEAN
27-12
+10.78u · 69.2%
Last 7 graded days
0-0
0.00u · —
TierRun lineMoneylineTotal
STRONG2-1 +0.86u4-5 -1.55u5-8-1 -3.54u
LEAN5-1 +2.88u10-6 +2.21u12-5 +5.69u

FADE-WATCH (tracked, not staked, kept out of the card record): 0-1.

Every graded play, day by day →

Every sport’s consensus record →

Flat 1-unit stakes at the line and price we posted before the game. STRONG and LEAN are tiered before the game starts and graded against the confirmed final the next morning. Updated automatically from the grading ledger.