NFL Consensus Weekly Recap — Who’s Hot / Who’s Not — Week 2 (Sep 17–21, 2026)

Week 2 of the NFL Sportsbook Consensus experiment is in the books (Thu Sep 17 – Mon Sep 21, 2026). We logged 729 graded selections from 134 named experts and models across the three game days, graded every one against the number each source printed, and ran our own consensus card off the same ledger. Here is who was hot, how our card did, and what we are changing.

🔥 Who Was Hot — Week 2

Wes Reynolds (VSiN, @WesReynolds1) owned the week: 6-1 for +4.28u, and he is now 9-3 (+4.90u) on the season. Gilberto Manzano (Sports Illustrated, @gmanzano24) went 10-4 for +3.03u across a full Sunday slate of moneylines, with Matt Verderame (SI, @MattVerderame) right behind at 10-4 and +2.47u. David Racey (Sports Chat Place, @itsyerboi41) was a perfect 3-0 for +2.73u, Matt Youmans (VSiN, @mattyoumans247) went 5-2 for +2.55u, and CBS Sports’ Dave Richard and Jamey Eisenberg each posted 8-5 (+2.28u) on the straight-up spread grid. Sixty-eight experts had at least three graded picks this week; the top ten by net units are below.

# Expert Week 2 Hit Units Season
1 VSiN – Wes Reynolds 6-1-0 85.7% +4.28u 9-3-0 (+4.90u)
2 SI – Manzano 10-4-0 71.4% +3.03u 17-10-0 (+0.55u)
3 Sports Chat Place – David Racey 3-0-0 100.0% +2.73u 5-0-0 (+4.47u)
4 VSiN – Matt Youmans 5-2-0 71.4% +2.55u 9-5-0 (+3.15u)
5 SI – Verderame 10-4-0 71.4% +2.47u 18-9-0 (+1.22u)
6 CBS Sports – Dave Richard 8-5-0 61.5% +2.28u 16-10-0 (+4.56u)
7 CBS Sports – Jamey Eisenberg 8-5-0 61.5% +2.28u 15-11-0 (+2.65u)
8 SI – Orr 10-4-0 71.4% +1.87u 16-11-0 (-1.52u)
9 Pickdawgz – David Racey 3-1-0 75.0% +1.77u 5-2-0 (+2.63u)
10 CBS Sports – Jordan Dajani 3-1-0 75.0% +1.73u 5-1-0 (+3.55u)

Best outlet of the week, aggregating every one of its experts: VSiN went 23-13 (63.9%) for +7.75u across six contributors, ahead of SportsLine (11-5, +5.01u) and WagerTalk (7-2-1, +4.27u).

Our Card — Week 2

The DailyOverlay consensus card finished 8-6-0 for +0.86u on 14 staked plays: STRONG plays went 5-5-0 (-0.42u) and LEAN plays went 3-1-0 (+1.28u). Two FADE-WATCH spreads were tracked at zero stake and split 1-1. Season to date the card is 13-11-1 for +0.39u.

Market Check

Totals carried the week. Our totals went 7-3-0 for +3.42u and the one moneyline hit; our spread plays went 0-3-0. Across the whole field it was the same picture: experts hit 60.3% on totals (44-29-0, +10.86u) but only 45.3% against the spread (204-246-1), with Sunday’s slate the culprit (the field went 296-304-1 on Sep 20 after a 33-18 Thursday).

By confidence tier, LEAN outperformed STRONG (75% vs 50%), and by agreement level the 4–6 source plays went 6-2-0 (+3.05u) while the 7+ source plays — almost all big-field spread favorites — wentmdash; which included both heavy-consensus spread favorites — almost all big-field spread favorites — wentmdash; went 2-4-0 (-2.19u). The struggling side of the ledger this week was heavy-consensus spread favorites tagged STRONG; the hot side was mid-consensus totals, especially unders in low-total games.

The field as a whole hit 50.2% (357-354-1, -62.41u at flat 1u) against our card’s 57.1%.

Season Board (through Week 2)

Sources with at least three graded picks that are at or above water, ranked by net units (hit rate breaks ties). 36 of 97 qualifying sources are on the right side of zero.

# Expert Picks Record Hit Units Week 2
1 Athlon Sports – Bonini 14 11-3-0 78.6% +7.01u 1-0-0 (+0.91u)
2 Bleacher Report – Davenport 14 10-4-0 71.4% +5.10u 0-1-0 (-1.00u)
3 VSiN – Wes Reynolds 12 9-3-0 75.0% +4.90u 6-1-0 (+4.28u)
4 CBS Sports – Dave Richard 26 16-10-0 61.5% +4.56u 8-5-0 (+2.28u)
5 Sports Chat Place – David Racey 5 5-0-0 100.0% +4.47u 3-0-0 (+2.73u)
6 SportsBettingDime AI Model 13 9-4-0 69.2% +4.19u 0-0-0 (+0.00u)
7 CBS Sports – Jordan Dajani 6 5-1-0 83.3% +3.55u 3-1-0 (+1.73u)
8 Sports Chat Place – Randy Chambers 6 5-1-0 83.3% +3.55u 3-1-0 (+1.73u)
9 Covers – Chris Vasile 29 17-12-0 58.6% +3.47u 8-8-0 (-0.72u)
10 Bleacher Report – Moton 14 9-5-0 64.3% +3.19u 1-0-0 (+0.91u)
11 VSiN – Matt Youmans 14 9-5-0 64.3% +3.15u 5-2-0 (+2.55u)
12 Covers – Jason Logan 16 10-6-0 62.5% +3.12u 3-4-0 (-1.27u)
13 CBS Sports – Jamey Eisenberg 26 15-11-0 57.7% +2.65u 8-5-0 (+2.28u)
14 SportsLine – Larry Hartstein 5 4-1-0 80.0% +2.64u 3-1-0 (+1.73u)
15 Pickdawgz – David Racey 7 5-2-0 71.4% +2.63u 3-1-0 (+1.77u)
16 Covers – Joe Osborne 7 5-2-0 71.4% +2.50u 3-2-0 (+0.68u)
17 DraftKings Network – Julian Edlow 5 4-1-0 80.0% +2.47u 1-0-0 (+0.83u)
18 SI – Breer 27 19-8-0 70.4% +2.47u 10-4-0 (+1.31u)
19 SportsLine Model 9 6-3-0 66.7% +2.46u 4-2-0 (+1.64u)
20 VSiN – Zachary Cohen 6 3-1-0 75.0% +1.70u 2-0-0 (+1.82u)
21 CBS Sports – Ryan Wilson 27 15-12-0 55.6% +1.65u 7-7-0 (-0.63u)
22 Bleacher Report – Sobleski 14 8-6-0 57.1% +1.28u 1-0-0 (+0.91u)
23 SI – Verderame 27 18-9-0 66.7% +1.22u 10-4-0 (+2.47u)
24 Covers – Trevor Knapp 28 17-11-0 60.7% +1.21u 8-7-0 (-0.16u)
25 VSiN – Steve Makinen 16 9-7-0 56.2% +1.19u 4-4-0 (-0.36u)
26 Athlon Sports – Ellenport 16 9-7-0 56.2% +1.19u 1-2-0 (-1.09u)
27 Covers – Ed Scimia 3 2-1-0 66.7% +0.86u 1-0-0 (+0.91u)
28 Pickswise – Chris Farley 4 2-1-1 66.7% +0.86u 2-0-0 (+1.86u)
29 WagerTalk – The Prez 3 2-1-0 66.7% +0.84u 2-0-0 (+1.84u)
30 SI – Dewey 13 9-4-0 69.2% +0.77u 0-0-0 (+0.00u)
31 FanDuel Research 3 2-1-0 66.7% +0.77u 2-1-0 (+0.77u)
32 SI – Kadlick 27 18-9-0 66.7% +0.76u 9-5-0 (-0.37u)
33 Yahoo Sports – Matt Jacob 4 2-1-0 66.7% +0.74u 1-0-0 (+0.83u)
34 SI – Manzano 27 17-10-0 63.0% +0.55u 10-4-0 (+3.03u)
35 The Ringer – Anthony Dabbundo 11 6-5-0 54.5% +0.46u 5-3-0 (+1.55u)
36 SI – Peter Dewey 17 11-6-0 64.7% +0.37u 11-6-0 (+0.37u)

The complete graded record for every source we track — every pick, every line, good weeks and bad — is public on our grading pages: NFL Expert Grading (daily recaps) and NFL Consensus Picks (the cards). Nothing is hidden; the promotional board just leads with who hit.

One Change for Week 3

Big-field spread consensus is not a STRONG signal on its own. Every 7+ source spread play we tagged STRONG this week lost, while 4–6 source agreement, mostly on totals, went 6-2. Starting with the Week 3 card, a spread favorite backed by 15+ sources is capped at LEAN unless the number itself still has value at post time, and STRONG is reserved for plays where the agreeing sources are the ones actually hitting on the season board above. Same ledger, tighter weighting.

Please gamble responsibly. Bet only what you can afford to lose; if you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER.

DailyOverlay Premium

Get the full graded consensus — every slate.

Free for 5 days, then $19.99/mo. Cancel anytime.

Start your free trial →

Season to date — the card

Live from the grading ledger, so it includes every game graded since this recap went up.

NFL consensus card

Graded Sep 13 – Nov 16 · 28 graded days
Card (STRONG + LEAN)
58-83-1
-32.76u · 41.1%
STRONG
40-56-1
-21.54u · 41.7%
LEAN
18-27
-11.22u · 40%
Last 7 graded days
5-9
-4.61u · 35.7%
TierSpreadMoneylineTotal
STRONG13-16 -4.23u8-6 -0.51u19-34-1 -16.80u
LEAN9-19 -10.91u3-3 -0.88u6-5 +0.57u

FADE-WATCH (tracked, not staked, kept out of the card record): 4-4.

Every graded play, day by day →

Every sport’s consensus record →

Flat 1-unit stakes at the line and price we posted before the game. STRONG and LEAN are tiered before the game starts and graded against the confirmed final the next morning. Updated automatically from the grading ledger.