NFL Consensus Weekly Recap — Who’s Hot / Who’s Not — Week 6 (Oct 15–19, 2026)
Iain MacMillan (Sports Illustrated) was the hottest expert we track in NFL Week 6, going 20-11 for +6.61u across Thursday through Monday — season record with us 73-67-2, -6.44u. Liam Fox (Sportsbook Review) was right behind him at 13-5, +5.06u (season 17-12, +1.62u), and Manzano (Sports Illustrated) went 10-4, +3.62u (season 37-20-1, +4.54u).
The card this week
The consensus STRONG plays went 5-7 for -3.16u and the LEAN plays went 1-2 for -1.05u, so the card finished the week 6-9, -4.21u. There were no FADE-WATCH plays this week. Every play is graded at the posted line on the consensus record page.
Market check
Totals carried the card: STRONG totals went 3-1 (+1.69u) and LEAN totals split 1-1 (-0.05u). Spreads were where the week went wrong — STRONG spreads went 1-5 (-4.07u) and the lone LEAN spread lost by half a point (0-1, -1.00u). STRONG moneylines split 1-1 (-0.78u). Across the full field, the experts we grade went 323-372-5 this week, a 46.5% hit rate, against the card’s 40.0%.
Hot this week
| Expert | Outlet | W-L-P | Hit rate | Units |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Iain MacMillan | Sports Illustrated | 20-11 | 64.5% | +6.61u |
| Liam Fox | Sportsbook Review | 13-5 | 72.2% | +5.06u |
| Manzano | Sports Illustrated | 10-4 | 71.4% | +3.62u |
| Mike Spector | Sportsbook Review | 5-1 | 83.3% | +3.49u |
| Moton | Bleacher Report | 9-5 | 64.3% | +3.19u |
| The Gold Sheet | WagerTalk | 3-0 | 100.0% | +3.11u |
| Will Brinson | CBS Sports | 3-0 | 100.0% | +2.73u |
| Nikos Lagouretos | Sports Chat Place | 3-0 | 100.0% | +2.73u |
| Garrett Kerman | ClutchPoints | 3-0 | 100.0% | +2.73u |
Minimum 3 graded picks, Thursday Oct 15 through Monday Oct 19. Flat 1-unit grading at the stored line.
Season leaders
| Expert | Record | Units | Consensus weight |
|---|---|---|---|
| CBS Sports – Jordan Dajani | 20-11 | +7.20u | 1.14 |
| VSiN – Zachary Cohen | 13-6 | +7.20u | 1.13 |
| VSiN – Steve Makinen | 26-18-2 | +5.71u | 1.10 |
| SportsLine Model | 17-10-3 | +5.66u | 1.11 |
| VSiN – Matt Youmans | 22-14 | +5.65u | 1.11 |
| Pickswise – Andrew Wilsher | 8-3 | +5.17u | 1.00 |
| Sportsbook Review – Mike Spector | 10-4 | +4.97u | 1.00 |
| OddsShopper – Dave Loughran | 14-8 | +4.73u | 1.10 |
| SI – Manzano | 37-20-1 | +4.54u | 1.22 |
| VSiN – Wes Reynolds | 21-14 | +4.43u | 1.10 |
| Pickdawgz – David Racey | 10-5 | +4.27u | 1.10 |
| Sports Chat Place – David Racey | 9-4 | +4.11u | 1.00 |
| Athlon Sports – Bonini | 37-30-3 | +3.68u | 1.05 |
| TheSpread – Anthony Rome | 7-4 | +3.44u | 1.00 |
| CBS Sports – Jamey Eisenberg | 30-24-2 | +3.37u | 1.05 |
| Pickswise – Ricky Dimon | 12-8 | +3.35u | 1.06 |
| Sports Chat Place – Nikos Lagouretos | 8-4 | +3.28u | 1.00 |
| Sports Chat Place – Randy Chambers | 9-5 | +3.19u | 1.00 |
| Covers – Jason Logan | 24-19 | +2.86u | 1.05 |
| SportsBettingDime AI Model | 28-23-2 | +2.48u | 1.04 |
| Pickswise – Chris Farley | 12-9-1 | +2.43u | 1.04 |
| VSiN – Dave Tuley | 18-14-3 | +2.38u | 1.05 |
| SportsLine – Larry Hartstein | 7-4 | +2.37u | 1.00 |
| Covers – Joe Osborne | 9-6 | +2.14u | 1.05 |
| Covers – Trevor Knapp | 32-24 | +1.85u | 1.08 |
| Sportsbook Review – Liam Fox | 17-12 | +1.62u | 1.07 |
| Yahoo Sports Blended AI Model | 8-6-1 | +1.36u | 1.00 |
| FanSided – Zachary Rotman | 8-6 | +1.28u | 1.00 |
| Covers – Chris Vasile | 46-41 | +0.85u | 1.01 |
| SI – Breer | 35-19-1 | +0.59u | 1.21 |
| Pickdawgz – Andrew Jett | 7-6 | +0.37u | 1.00 |
Minimum 10 decided picks, units above zero. The full graded record for every source, good weeks and bad, is public on the grading pages.
What we’re watching
Spreads are the market we are watching hardest. STRONG spreads went 1-5 this week, with the Rams (-12.5) losing outright and the 49ers (-7.5) winning by six, and the tier is now 5-12 on spreads for the season while STRONG totals have been closer to even and LEAN totals sit at 5-2. Heading into Week 7 we are watching how STRONG spread plays grade when the expert agreement is lopsided, since four of this week’s five STRONG spread losses came on sides that lost the game outright, and we will report how the spread plays grade against the totals next Wednesday.
Please bet responsibly. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER.
Get the full graded consensus — every slate.
Free for 5 days, then $19.99/mo. Cancel anytime.
Season to date — the card
Live from the grading ledger, so it includes every game graded since this recap went up.
NFL consensus card
Graded Sep 13 – Nov 16 · 28 graded days| Tier | Spread | Moneyline | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| STRONG | 13-16 -4.23u | 8-6 -0.51u | 19-34-1 -16.80u |
| LEAN | 9-19 -10.91u | 3-3 -0.88u | 6-5 +0.57u |
FADE-WATCH (tracked, not staked, kept out of the card record): 4-4.
Every sport’s consensus record →
Flat 1-unit stakes at the line and price we posted before the game. STRONG and LEAN are tiered before the game starts and graded against the confirmed final the next morning. Updated automatically from the grading ledger.
