NFL – Handicapper Results and Recap – Week 4 (2021)

Top NFL Handicappers – Week 4

Week 4 was the first difficult week for the NFL handicappers which finished with about a 50% winning percentage. As you would expect from that our Consensus Best Bets when an even 4-4 for the week. Top handicappers this week included Aaron Schatz (ESPN) with a perfect 4-0 mark and Free picks from SportsBettingStats which when 3-0.

The Overall Leaderboard features RJ White (Sportsline) leading in Units won, followed by Aaron Schatz (ESPN), and Larry Hartstein (Sportsline). Our Consensus Best Bets still have a strong showing for the season in 4th place overall.

Consensus Picks Recap

The Consensus picks finished Week 4 with a 4-4 (50%) record with 4-3 ATS and 0-1 on Totals.

Week 4 Picks

Pick Spread/Total Net Consensus Result
Lions +3 8 L
Seahawks +2.5 6 W
Cowboys -4 5 W
Vikings +1 5 L
Titans/Jets U44.5 5 L
Jets +6 4 W
Chiefs -6.5 4 W
Buccaneers -7 4 L

YTD Results

Here are the Year-to-Date results for the Consensus picks:

  • Overall: 24-14 (63.2% / +8.6 units)
  • Sides 18-10 (64.3% / +7.0 units)
  • Totals: 6-4 (60.0% / +1.6 units)

Top Handicappers – Week 4

The collective picks from all handicappers finished just below 50% this week at 77-78 (49.7%). They were 67-67 (50.0%) ATS and 10-11 (47.6%) on Totals record.

Top Handicappers of the Week (multiple picks)

  • ESPN (Aaron Schatz): 4-0
  • SportsBettingStats (Free): 3-0
  • ActionNetwork (Big Money): 2-0
  • ActionNetwork (Matt Moore): 2-0
  • SportsIllustrated (Jennifer Piacenti): 4-1

Top Handicappers of the Week (single pick)

  • Covers (Marc Lawrence, American Sports Analysts, Forum Legends, Sean Murphy)
  • ESPN (Joe Fortenbaugh, Tyler Fulghum)
  • ActionNetwork (Collin Wilson)

Top Handicappers – Season

Check out the Overall Leaderboard to see how all of the handicappers we track are performing. Need at least 3 picks to qualify.

Top Handicappers – Win %

Site Handicapper Overall Pct
Covers American Sports Analysts 4-0-0 100.0%
ESPN Aaron Schatz 11-1-0 91.7%
Covers Jason Logan 10-2-0 83.3%
Sportsline Brett Anderson 4-1-0 80.0%
Sportsline Larry Hartstein 14-4-1 77.8%

Top Handicappers – Units

Site Handicapper Overall Units
Sportsline R.J. White 31-16-0 +13.4
ESPN Aaron Schatz 11-1-0 +9.9
Sportsline Larry Hartstein 14-4-1 +9.6
DailyOverlay Consensus 24-14-0 +8.6
SportsIllustrated Jennifer Piacenti 15-6-0 +8.4

Disclaimer: Picks are recorded as of the Saturday prior to the NFL games for the week so that we can provide our Consensus Picks. The handicapper records shown may not reflect all of the recommended wagers by that handicapper and does not take into account any variation of units recommended by the handicapper.

Follow me on Twitter @RotoPilot

DailyOverlay Premium

Get the full graded consensus — every slate.

Free for 5 days, then $19.99/mo. Cancel anytime.

Start your free trial →