NFL Sportsbook Consensus Grading Recap — Monday, September 21, 2026

The most-trusted capper in our NFL pool was on the right side of Monday night. SI – Peter Dewey, who carries the heaviest weight of any expert who posted on this game (1.15, and 19-10 on everything we have graded him on this season), took Rams -7 (-115) and collected for +0.87u as Los Angeles won 28-6. Picks and Parlays – Eddie Kline and VSiN – Zachary Cohen tied for the best number on the board at 1-0, +0.95u — Kline on Rams -6.5 at -105, Cohen on Under 47.5 at -105, both of them buying the better price on a side that never sweated. VSiN – Wes Reynolds followed Sunday’s 5-1 day by cashing Rams -7 for +0.91u, and Covers – Josh Inglis banked the widest margin of comfort on the board, winning Under 48.5 by 14.5 points.

Our own card split the two plays. The consensus posted no STRONG selections for this date — both plays graded as LEAN — and they finished 1-1-0 for -0.09 units: the Under 47.5 (-110) cashed for +0.91u, the Giants +6.5 (-105) lost for -1.00u. Card hit rate 50.0%, against a field that hit 46.7% on the same game.

What actually happened

One injury decided both sides of our card. Jaxson Dart went down early in the first quarter with a knee injury — reported as a sprained MCL, x-rays negative, an MRI to follow — and the game we handicapped stopped existing right there. Jameis Winston came in cold and finished 11 of 27 with an interception in the red zone, and the Giants never found a rhythm: 182 total yards, no touchdowns, down 14-3 at the half and run off the field from there.

The other end of it was Matthew Stafford picking apart a short-handed secondary for 327 yards and four touchdowns on 22 of 31, with Davante Adams catching 8 for 195 and two scores. New York also lost Brian Burns to an ankle injury and Andrew Thomas to a groin strain late, and Malik Nabers had a scare of his own. That is a team losing its quarterback and then losing the pieces it needed to survive without him.

It cut both ways for us. The Under 47.5 cashed because the Giants could not score with their backup quarterback — the same reason the Giants +6.5 never had a chance. Two plays, one cause.

Tier record — Monday, September 21

Tier Record Hit rate Units
STRONG — — 0.00u
LEAN 1-1-0 50.0% -0.09u
Card total (STRONG + LEAN) 1-1-0 50.0% -0.09u

No STRONG and no FADE-WATCH plays were posted for this date. Every play is graded at the line we posted, at a flat 1 unit.

Every play on the card

Result Tier Play Line Final Units
✅ WIN LEAN NYG @ LAR — Under 47.5 47.5 (-110) DraftKings Rams 28-6 Giants (34 total) +0.91u
❌ LOSS LEAN NYG @ LAR — Giants +6.5 +6.5 (-105) DraftKings Rams 28-6 Giants (LAR by 22) -1.00u

Best call and worst beat

Best call: Under 47.5. The total opened at 49 and was bid down to 47.5 before we posted it; the game came in at 34 combined points, 13.5 clear of the number. It was decided by halftime — neither side ever threatened the Over.

Worst beat: Giants +6.5. The Rams won by 22, so the number never came into play — but this was not a bad read of the matchup, it was a voided one. New York was a live underdog with Dart under centre and stopped being one about ten minutes into the game. We will take the loss, and we are not going to dress it up as a handicapping miss: you cannot price a quarterback leaving in the first quarter, and anyone who tells you they saw a 22-point game coming is selling something.

Expert scoreboard — Monday, September 21

53 experts, 60 graded selections, one game. The field went 28-32-0 for a net of -6.64 units and a 46.7% hit rate. The split was almost entirely about which side of the number you took: every Rams spread ticket (-6.5, -7 and -7.5) cashed and every Giants spread ticket lost, while the Under crowd went a perfect 6-0 and the Over 0-3.

Top 5 of the day

# Expert Record Units Play
1 Picks and Parlays – Eddie Kline 1-0-0 +0.95u Rams -6.5 (-105)
2 VSiN – Zachary Cohen 1-0-0 +0.95u Under 47.5 (-105)
3 VSiN – Wes Reynolds 1-0-0 +0.91u Rams -7
4 Covers – Josh Inglis 1-0-0 +0.91u Under 48.5
5 CBS Sports – Pete Prisco 1-0-0 +0.91u Rams -7

Twenty-eight experts finished the night in profit; nineteen more of them landed on +0.91u with a Rams spread or an Under at standard juice.

Bottom 5 of the day

# Expert Record Units
1 Elite Sports NY – Kevin Kinkead 0-2-0 -2.00u
2 SportsGrid Model 1-2-0 -1.09u
3 SportsBettingDime – Chris Amberley 0-1-0 spread leg -1.00u on the side
4 SportsLine Model 0-1-0 -1.00u
5 CBS Sports – Dave Richard 0-1-0 -1.00u

Twenty-five experts finished 0-1 at -1.00u; the two rows above them are the only cappers who lost more than a single unit.

Consensus vs. the field

Our card hit 50.0% (1 of 2 decided) against an all-expert hit rate of 46.7% (28 of 60 decided) on the same game. Narrow sample, but the consensus finished on the right side of the field for the third time in four graded NFL dates.

Season leaders in the ledger

Expert Graded with us Hit rate Consensus weight
SI – Breer 19-8 70.4% 1.19
SI – Verderame 18-9 66.7% 1.15
SI – Kadlick 18-9 66.7% 1.15
SI – Peter Dewey 19-10 65.5% 1.15
CBS Sports – Dave Richard 16-9 64.0% 1.12

How this changes the card

Thirty NFL experts now clear the 15-decided-pick bar and carry a real weight in the consensus, and Monday night moved several of them. SI – Peter Dewey is 19-10 on everything we have graded him on and sits at 1.15 — the heaviest weight of anyone who posted on this game — and he was on Rams -7. CBS Sports – Dave Richard (16-9, weight 1.12) and Covers – Chris Vasile (17-11, weight 1.09) were both on the Giants and both lost, which trims their weight slightly going forward.

The uncomfortable part is worth stating plainly, because it is what the weighting is for: the raw count had 28 of 50 spread selections on the Giants, and our weighted agreement came out at 56.8% against a raw 56.0% — not enough of a gap to flip the side. The heaviest single voice in the pool was on the Rams and the crowd outnumbered him. That is exactly the kind of date that, repeated, pushes Dewey’s multiplier up and pulls the Giants-side cappers’ down.

Thirty-five of the 53 experts who posted on this game are still under 15 decided picks and sit at a neutral 1.00 — including both of the day’s top scorers, VSiN – Zachary Cohen and Picks and Parlays – Eddie Kline. Their wins count toward qualifying but carried no extra weight into this card. We are still building those samples.

Season to date — NFL

Tier Record Spread ML Totals Units
STRONG 9-9-1 1-3-0 (-2.00u) 0-0-0 8-6-1 (+1.24u) -0.76u
LEAN 4-2-0 1-2-0 (-1.13u) 1-0-0 (+0.44u) 2-0-0 (+1.84u) +1.15u
Card total (STRONG + LEAN) 13-11-1 +0.39u
FADE-WATCH (watches, not staked) 1-1-0 1-1-0 0-0-0 0-0-0 0.00u

Four graded NFL dates so far this season. Totals are carrying the card: 10-6-1 (+3.08u) across both staked tiers, against 2-5-0 (-3.13u) on sides.

Grading notes

Graded from the final score confirmed on ESPN, CBS Sports, NBC Los Angeles and therams.com — all four agree on Rams 28-6 Giants, in regulation, no overtime. Combined total 34 points; Los Angeles by 22. Units are flat 1u from the odds stored at posting time; expert rows with no posted price are graded at -110. FADE-WATCH plays are monitors rather than staked plays, so they are graded and reported separately at 0 units and excluded from the card record. Every result is measured against the exact line we stored, which may differ from lines at other books or at other times.

Betting involves risk and no record guarantees future results. Bet only what you can afford to lose. If gambling stops being fun, call 1-800-GAMBLER.

DailyOverlay Premium

Get the full graded consensus — every slate.

Free for 5 days, then $19.99/mo. Cancel anytime.

Start your free trial →