NFL Sportsbook Consensus Grading Recap — Sunday, September 20, 2026

Four cappers separated themselves on a 14-game Sunday. VSiN’s Wes Reynolds went 5-1 for +3.37 units, the best net of anyone we graded, hitting the Colts +6.5, the Vikings +5 and both of his totals. CBS Sports’ Dave Richard and Jamey Eisenberg both finished 8-4 for +3.28 units apiece, and both now carry more weight in our consensus than a capper we have never seen hit — Richard is 16-9 on everything we have graded him on this season, Eisenberg 15-10. SI’s Greg Manzano went 10-4 for +3.03 units, helped by a Raiders moneyline at +240. Sports Chat Place’s David Racey was a perfect 3-0 (+2.73u) and VSiN’s Matt Youmans 5-2 (+2.55u).

The card itself went 5-5 for -0.43 units. The STRONG tier was 4-5 (-1.36u) and the lone LEAN won (+0.93u). Totals carried the day at 5-3 (+1.57u) while both STRONG sides missed, 0-2 (-2.00u). Two FADE-WATCH monitors split 1-1 and are reported at 0 units, as always.

The day by tier

Tier Record Hit rate Units
STRONG 4-5-0 44.4% -1.36u
LEAN 1-0-0 100% +0.93u
Card total (STRONG + LEAN) 5-5-0 50.0% -0.43u
FADE-WATCH (monitors, unstaked) 1-1-0 50.0% 0.00u

Every play is graded at the exact line we posted. FADE-WATCH plays are monitors, not staked plays, and are kept out of the card record.

Every play, graded

Game Pick Line Tier Final Units
❌ PHI @ TEN Eagles -7.5 (-105) STRONG Eagles 24-20 — won by 4 -1.00
❌ MIN @ CHI Over 47.5 (-105) STRONG 9-3 — 12 points -1.00
✅ SEA @ ARI Under 41 (-110) STRONG 31-7 — 38 points +0.91
✅ LV @ LAC Under 43.5 (-108) STRONG 26-14 — 40 points +0.93
❌ MIA @ SF Under 45 (-110) STRONG 35-13 — 48 points -1.00
❌ CLE @ TB Buccaneers -8.5 (-108) STRONG Browns 23-19 — TB lost outright -1.00
❌ IND @ KC Under 46.5 (-110) STRONG 33-30 OT — 63 points -1.00
✅ WAS @ DAL Over 50.5 (-115) STRONG 37-20 — 57 points +0.87
✅ PIT @ NE Under 41.5 (-108) STRONG 20-3 — 23 points +0.93
✅ CIN @ HOU Under 45.5 (-108) LEAN 20-6 — 26 points +0.93
✅ MIN @ CHI Vikings +4.5 (-110) FADE-WATCH Vikings won 9-3 0.00
❌ MIA @ SF Dolphins +13.5 (-110) FADE-WATCH 49ers by 22 0.00

Best call: Under 41.5 in Pittsburgh-New England. The Patriots won 20-3 for 23 combined points — 18.5 clear of the number, and never in doubt after halftime.

Worst beat: Under 45 in Miami-San Francisco landed on 48. Three points the wrong way on a game that was a two-score 49ers win all afternoon.

Expert scoreboard — Sunday, September 20

We graded 618 expert picks from 100 distinct cappers and models across all 14 games. The field went 296-304-1 on decided picks, a 49.3% hit rate. Our card hit 50.0%.

Top five of the day

Expert Record Units
VSiN – Wes Reynolds 5-1-0 +3.37u
CBS Sports – Dave Richard 8-4-0 +3.28u
CBS Sports – Jamey Eisenberg 8-4-0 +3.28u
SI – Manzano 10-4-0 +3.03u
Sports Chat Place – David Racey 3-0-0 +2.73u

Bottom five of the day

Expert Record Units
Covers Model 8-14-0 -6.72u
CBS Sports – Pete Prisco 4-10-0 -6.36u
Sports Gambling Podcast – Ryan Kramer 4-10-0 -6.36u
SI – Pluym 6-8-0 -5.84u
Sports Gambling Podcast – Justin Mark 1-6-0 -5.17u

Season leaders and their consensus weight

An expert sits at a neutral 1.00 until we have graded 15 decided picks. Thirty NFL cappers have now cleared that bar.

Expert Season record with us Hit rate Weight
SI – Breer 19-8 70.4% 1.19
SI – Verderame 18-9 66.7% 1.15
SI – Kadlick 18-9 66.7% 1.15
SI – Peter Dewey 19-10 65.5% 1.15
CBS Sports – Dave Richard 16-9 64.0% 1.12
SI – Manzano 17-10 63.0% 1.11
SI – Geitheim 17-10 63.0% 1.11
Covers – Chris Vasile 17-11 60.7% 1.09
Covers – Trevor Knapp 17-11 60.7% 1.09
CBS Sports – Jamey Eisenberg 15-10 60.0% 1.08

How this changes the card

Sunday was the day the NFL ledger got real. Before these games only four cappers had reached the 15-pick threshold where our consensus starts weighting them; after grading 618 picks, thirty have. SI’s Albert Breer now leads the board at 19-8 (70.4%) and carries a 1.19 weight, meaning his side counts for roughly a fifth more than a capper we have never seen hit. Matt Verderame, Joe Kadlick and Peter Dewey all sit at 1.15, and Dave Richard’s 16-9 lifted him to 1.12 on the strength of Sunday’s 8-4.

Weight moved the other way too, and it matters just as much. Covers Model dropped to 0.76 after an 8-14 day left it 8-19 (29.6%) on the season, so its projections now carry about three-quarters of a normal vote. Athlon’s Easterling (10-17) sits at 0.84 and SI’s Iain MacMillan (20-27) at 0.85. The practical effect on tomorrow’s card: a 20-of-40 split like the Vikings spread no longer reads as a coin flip once the weights are applied — it reads as whichever side the cappers who have actually been right are standing on.

Season to date

Tier / market Record Units
STRONG — all 9-9-1 -0.76u
STRONG — Spread 1-3-0 -2.00u
STRONG — Totals 8-6-1 +1.24u
LEAN — all 3-1-0 +1.24u
LEAN — Spread 1-1-0 -0.13u
LEAN — Totals 1-0-0 +0.93u
LEAN — Moneyline 1-0-0 +0.44u
CARD TOTAL (STRONG + LEAN) 12-10-1 +0.48u
FADE-WATCH (monitors, unstaked) 1-1-0 0.00u

Grading notes

Final scores were confirmed on ESPN, FOX Sports and team/AP recaps, which agree on all 14 games. Green Bay–NY Jets and Indianapolis–Kansas City went to overtime and are graded on the overtime final. Units are flat 1u from the odds stored at posting time. Player props and first-half props cannot be settled from a final score and are marked NO ACTION at 0 units (17 of the 618 expert rows); team-total props are graded from the final score. Expert rows whose stored price is a prediction-market probability or a “line at capture” note carry no American odds, so those units use the standard -110 fallback. Results are graded against the exact line we posted and may differ from lines at other books or times.

Please gamble responsibly. If betting stops being fun, help is available 24/7 at 1-800-GAMBLER.

DailyOverlay Premium

Get the full graded consensus — every slate.

Free for 5 days, then $19.99/mo. Cancel anytime.

Start your free trial →