NFL Sportsbook Consensus Grading Recap — Thursday, November 19, 2026

Jordan Dajani (CBS Sports) was on the right side of a 26-3 Texans rout, and he is now 42-20 (+18.22u) in our NFL grading — the best record of any rated expert we track. Dajani took Texans -12.5 when 17 of 22 spread experts went the other way, and Houston covered by 10.5 points. His CBS Sports colleague Tyler Sullivan made the same call at -12.5 (1-0, +0.91u), and BetMGM’s Nick Hennion laid -10 (1-0, +0.91u).

Al MacMillan (Winners and Whiners) had the top return of the night at 1-0, +0.93u with Under 44. The Sports Geek Model went 2-1 (+0.11u) on Texans moneyline and Under 43.5, and Kim Smith (Picks and Parlays) split 1-1 with Under 44.5 — she is 51-44-1 (+2.46u) with us this season.

The consensus card went 0-2 for -2.00u. STRONG 0-2 (-2.00u): Colts +12.5 lost by 10.5 points and Over 43.5 finished 14.5 points short at 29 total. Every play is graded at the line we posted.

What actually happened

Houston led 17-3 at halftime on two C.J. Stroud touchdown passes, 42 yards to Nico Collins and 24 yards to Kayshon Boutte. Indianapolis scored on its opening drive with a 34-yard Spencer Shrader field goal and never scored again. Shrader missed from 56 and had a 62-yard try blocked by Logan Hall before the half.

The game turned for good early in the third quarter when Will Anderson Jr. sacked Daniel Jones in the end zone for a safety, his league-leading 11.5th sack. Stroud then hit rookie tight end Marlin Klein for 13 yards and a 26-3 lead. Stroud finished 21 of 27 for 194 yards and three touchdowns, David Montgomery returned from a groin injury to run 26 times for 107 yards, and Houston outgained Indianapolis 355-167. Jones went 12 of 27 for 144 yards with an interception by Kamari Lassiter, the game’s only turnover.

The Colts were without both starting tackles (Bernhard Raimann, Jalen Travis) and both starting outside corners (Sauce Gardner, Charvarius Ward Sr.), all ruled out before kickoff, so that was known when the lines were posted. Running back Seth McGowan left late in the second quarter with a hamstring injury. No quarterback was knocked out of the game. The consensus was beaten on the merits: Houston’s pass rush and passing game controlled both the margin and the pace.

The card, by tier

Tier Record Hit rate Units
STRONG 0-2-0 0% -2.00u
Card (STRONG + LEAN) 0-2-0 0% -2.00u

Every play is graded at the line we posted.

Every play

Result Tier Play Line Final Grading
❌ LOSS STRONG Colts @ Texans — Colts +12.5 +12.5 (-112) DraftKings Texans 26-3 Colts Colts 3, Texans 26 → Colts lost by 23; 23 − 12.5 = 10.5 short of covering ❌ · -1.00u
❌ LOSS STRONG Colts @ Texans — Over 43.5 43.5 (-118) DraftKings Texans 26-3 Colts 3 + 26 = 29 → 14.5 under 43.5 ❌ · -1.00u

Best call: Jordan Dajani (CBS Sports) on Texans -12.5: he cited Daniel Jones’ poor play and Houston’s response to a blown lead against Cleveland. Jones threw for 144 yards with an interception and was sacked for a safety, and Houston won by 23.

Worst beat: Over 43.5 (STRONG): the Colts gained 144 passing yards and scored only a first-drive field goal, missing from 56 and getting a 62-yarder blocked. With Indianapolis held to 3 points, 29 total points came nowhere near the number.

Expert scoreboard — Thursday, Nov 19

We graded 33 picks from 26 experts and models. The field went 9-24 (27.3%) against the consensus card’s 0-2 (0%).

Top of the day Pick Record Units
Winners and Whiners – Al MacMillan Under 44 (-108) 1-0-0 +0.93u
CBS Sports – Jordan Dajani Texans -12.5 1-0-0 +0.91u
CBS Sports – Tyler Sullivan Texans -12.5 1-0-0 +0.91u
BetMGM – Nick Hennion Texans -10 (-110) 1-0-0 +0.91u
The Sports Geek Model Texans ML (-750); Under 43.5 (-102) 2-1-0 +0.11u

Also on a winning side: Chris Farley (Pickswise) with Texans -12.5, Michael Harrison (SportsBettingDime) with Texans -10.5 and Kim Smith (Picks and Parlays) with Under 44.5, all 1-1 on the night. At the bottom, Joe Osborne (Covers) and Gary Pearson (Sportsbook Review) both went 0-2 (-2.00u) with Colts points and the Over. In total, 17 of the 22 experts with a spread pick took Indianapolis, and 7 of 10 total picks were on the Over.

Season leaders (NFL, graded with us) Record Units Consensus weight
CBS Sports – Jordan Dajani 42-20 +18.22u 1.28
Covers – Trevor Knapp 45-25 +12.68u 1.23
Athlon Sports – Bonini 63-46-4 +11.34u 1.13
SportsBettingDime AI Model 54-38-2 +10.46u 1.14
Sports Chat Place – David Racey 18-8 +8.81u 1.17
Pickdawgz – David Racey 18-8 +8.39u 1.17
SI – Manzano 49-25-1 +7.69u 1.27

How this changes the card

Jordan Dajani (CBS Sports) has the most weight in our NFL consensus at 1.28 after moving to 42-20. Sports Chat Place’s David Racey (18-8) dropped to 1.17, and Sportsbook Review’s Gary Pearson (48-47-2) is at 0.96 after his 0-2 night. 108 experts are now rated; R.J. White (SportsLine, 4-10) and SportsBettingDime’s Michael Harrison (6-7) are still provisional at 1.00 because they have fewer than 15 decided picks.

Season to date

Tier All Spread Moneyline Total Units
STRONG 40-58-1 13-17 8-6 19-35-1 -23.54u
LEAN 18-27 9-19 3-3 6-5 -11.22u
FADE-WATCH (not staked) 4-4 3-3 0-1 1-0 —
Card (STRONG + LEAN) 58-85-1 -34.76u

Every card, every sport: the full consensus record.

Expert rows with no listed odds are graded at -110. Each expert is graded at the line they published, which may differ from the card’s line.

Please bet responsibly. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER.

DailyOverlay Premium

Get the full graded consensus — every slate.

Free for 5 days, then $19.99/mo. Cancel anytime.

Start your free trial →