NFL Sportsbook Consensus Grading Recap — Thursday, September 17, 2026

Thursday Night Football grading — Lions at Bills (Sept 17, 2026). The DailyOverlay NFL Sportsbook Consensus card went a perfect 2-0-0 for +1.38 units at flat 1-unit stakes. Buffalo opened its new stadium with a 41-31 win over Detroit, and both card plays cleared with room to spare. Totals went 1-0, moneyline 1-0, no spread plays on the card.

Card results

Result Pick Line / Odds Confidence Final Units
✅ WIN DET @ BUF — Over 54.5 Over 54.5 (-106) STRONG Bills 41-31 Lions (72 pts) +0.94
✅ WIN DET @ BUF — Bills ML -225 LEAN Bills 41-31 Lions +0.44

By confidence: STRONG 1-0-0 · LEAN 1-0-0 · FADE-WATCH 0-0-0

Best call: Over 54.5 (STRONG). Thirteen of fifteen logged experts were on the over and the game sailed past the number by 17.5 points — 72 combined, with 37 on the board by halftime.

Worst beat: None. Buffalo led 27-10 at the half and the -225 moneyline was never in doubt.

Expert scoreboard — Thursday

43 experts and models graded on 51 logged picks. The field went 33-18-0 (64.7%) for +9.62 units. Spread pickers split 15-15 before kickoff and the Bills side cashed at every number from -3 to -5.5; every game-total over cashed; both unders lost.

Top 5 W-L-P Units
Pickswise – Chris Farley 2-0-0 +1.86
Sportsbook Review – Gary Pearson 2-0-0 +1.80
TheSpread – Anthony Rome 2-0-0 +1.78
BetMGM Model 2-0-0 +1.18
CBS Sports – Pete Prisco (tied with 17 others at 1-0-0) 1-0-0 +0.91
Bottom 5 W-L-P Units
Covers Model 0-2-0 -2.00
OddsShopper – Dave Loughran 0-2-0 -2.00
SI – Iain MacMillan 0-1-0 -1.00
VSiN – Dave Tuley 0-1-0 -1.00
Doc’s Sports – Tony Sink (tied with 9 others at 0-1-0) 0-1-0 -1.00

Consensus vs. field: card 2-0 (100%) vs. all-expert 64.7% hit rate.

Week 1 Sunday expert ledger — backfilled

The Sunday, Sept 13 expert ledger (102 experts, 712 picks across 13 games) is now graded: the field went 372-339-1 (52.3%) for -34.09 units. Top of the day: Athlon Sports – Bonini and Bleacher Report – Davenport, both 10-3-0 (+6.10); Covers – Jason Logan 7-2-0 (+4.39); Covers – Chris Vasile and the SportsBettingDime AI Model, both 9-4-0 (+4.19). Bottom: SI – Iain MacMillan 11-18-0 (-10.11) and VSiN – Dave Tuley 1-5-0 (-4.09).

Season to date (NFL card)

7-5-1 overall · +0.91 units — Spread 2-2-0 · Moneyline 1-0-0 · Totals 4-3-1. (Sept 13: 5-5-1, -0.47u; Sept 17: 2-0-0, +1.38u.)

Grading notes: results are against the exact line stored on the card at post time; units at flat 1u from the stored odds; experts with no printed odds are graded at -110; Kalshi prices converted to units as (100 – price) / price. Final scores confirmed on ESPN, NBC Sports and footballdb.

Please gamble responsibly. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER.

DailyOverlay Premium

Get the full graded consensus — every slate.

Free for 5 days, then $19.99/mo. Cancel anytime.

Start your free trial →