NFL Sportsbook Consensus Grading Recap — Thursday, September 24, 2026

Three cappers walked out of Lambeau with the night in their pocket. The SportsGrid Model went a perfect 3-0 for +3.87 units — Falcons +4.5, Over 43.5 and Atlanta’s moneyline at +205, every one of them a winner. SI’s Iain MacMillan went 2-0 for +3.09 units and did it the hard way: he was the only writer in Sports Illustrated’s own straight-up column who took Atlanta, against six colleagues on Green Bay, and he had the Falcons at +5.5 as well. TheSpread’s Anthony Rome finished 2-1 for +1.97 units on the strength of Falcons +5.5 and Falcons ML +210. Behind them, fifteen more cappers cashed a single play: Vaughn Dalzell (NBC Sports) on Falcons +7, Tyler Sullivan (CBS Sports) and Zachary Cohen (VSiN) on +6.5, Wes O’Donnell and Moe Moton of Bleacher Report on +6.5, and Daniel Kohn (CBS Sports) and the SportsLine Model on the Over.

The card

The consensus card went 0-2 for -2.00 units: the STRONG Green Bay moneyline at -235 lost, and the LEAN Under 43.5 at -115 lost. The FADE-WATCH — Atlanta +5.5, on the card purely for reverse line movement and carried at zero units — was correct, and would have returned +0.85 had it been staked. That is the whole of it. Every number is in the tables below.

What actually happened

Michael Penix Jr. made his first start since tearing an ACL last November, and the opening drive went exactly the way the market had priced it: Xavier McKinney picked him off, Green Bay drove nearly five minutes and Christian Watson caught his fourth touchdown in three games for a 7-0 lead. Then Atlanta scored 27 straight points. Bijan Robinson broke a 55-yard run on the answering drive and finished with 29 carries for 194 yards and two touchdowns; Drake London caught nine balls for 194 yards including gains of 68 and 40. Atlanta held the ball for 37:05 to Green Bay’s 22:55 and Matt LaFleur called it “a butt-whoopin’.”

No injury voided the consensus premise, and we are not going to pretend one did. The Packers were already without right tackle Zach Bako-Bewele (patellar tendon, torn against the Jets the week before), left guard Aaron Banks and Josh Jacobs, and they lost right guard Jacob Monk to a quad and had Edgerrin Cooper evaluated for a concussion during the game — but Jordan Love played the whole way and threw the ball 53 times. The consensus backed the better roster at home against a quarterback making a short-week debut, and the quarterback making the short-week debut was the best player on the field outside of his own running back. The consensus misread the spot, and that is not bad luck.

One detail explains why the Under died. At 27-7 with eleven minutes left in the fourth, the game had produced 34 points and the Under 43.5 was comfortably alive. Then Green Bay scored, Atlanta answered with a Robinson touchdown and a two-point conversion, and 16 of the night’s 49 points arrived inside the last eleven minutes. The Under was not wrong about the pace of this game for three and a half quarters; it was wrong about a blowout’s ability to keep scoring.

Tier record — Thursday, September 24

Tier Record Hit rate Units
STRONG 0-1-0 0.0% -1.00
LEAN 0-1-0 0.0% -1.00
Card total (STRONG + LEAN) 0-2-0 0.0% -2.00
FADE-WATCH (watch only — 0 units staked) 1-0-0 100.0% 0.00

Every play is graded at the line we posted, not at a better number found later.

Every play on the card

Tier Play Line Book Final Units
❌ STRONG Green Bay Packers ML -235 BetMGM Falcons 35-14 Packers -1.00
❌ LEAN Under 43.5 (ATL @ GB) -115 Bet365 49 combined -1.00
✅ FADE-WATCH Atlanta Falcons +5.5 -118 FanDuel Falcons by 21 0.00

Arithmetic: Green Bay lost outright 14-35, so the moneyline is a loss. 35 + 14 = 49, and 49 > 43.5, so the Under loses and the Over cashes. Atlanta won by 21 and 21 > 5.5, so the Falcons cover.

Best call and worst beat

Best call — Iain MacMillan (@IainMacBets), Falcons ML +220 and Falcons +5.5. Six of his own colleagues at Sports Illustrated laid -270 on Green Bay in the same column he wrote in. He read the Penix return as a live-dog spot rather than a downgrade, and Penix went 18 of 25 for 256 yards at 10.2 a throw. Two plays, two winners, +3.09 units.

Worst beat — the Under 43.5. Not a beat in the unlucky sense, but the closest thing to one on the night: the number was winning by nine and a half points with eleven minutes to play. A Green Bay touchdown, an Atlanta touchdown and a two-point try later, it lost by five and a half. Nothing about the first three quarters of this game was wrong; the fourth quarter of a 20-point blowout simply kept producing points.

Expert scoreboard — Thursday, September 24

51 experts and models graded across 66 logged picks on the single Thursday game. The field went 28-38-0 — a 42.4% hit rate and -9.00 units at flat stakes. The consensus card went 0-for-2 on staked plays; the field beat the card on hit rate, and the divergence we flagged as a FADE-WATCH was the right side.

Top of the day Record Units
SportsGrid Model (@SportsGrid) 3-0-0 +3.87
SI – Iain MacMillan (@IainMacBets) 2-0-0 +3.09
TheSpread – Anthony Rome (@TheSpread) 2-1-0 +1.97
15 cappers tied on a single winner 1-0-0 +0.91 each
Pickswise – Chris Farley (@FarleyBets) 1-1-0 -0.07
Bottom of the day Record Units
SI – Peter Dewey 0-2-0 -2.00
ClutchPoints – Garrett Kerman 0-2-0 -2.00
SportsBettingDime – Chris Amberley 0-2-0 -2.00
Dimers Model 0-2-0 -2.00
24 cappers on a single loser 0-1-0 -1.00 each

Season leaders — the weights the consensus actually uses

Expert Graded record Hit rate Weight
SI – Albert Breer (@AlbertBreer) 19-8 70.4% 1.19
SI – Matt Verderame 18-10 64.3% 1.13
SI – Mike Kadlick 18-10 64.3% 1.13
SI – Peter Dewey 20-12 62.5% 1.12
SI – Geitheim 17-10 63.0% 1.11
Bleacher Report – Moe Moton (@MoeMoton) 10-5 66.7% 1.10
Bleacher Report – Davenport 10-5 66.7% 1.10
CBS Sports – Dave Richard 16-10 61.5% 1.09
SI – Gilberto Manzano 17-11 60.7% 1.09

39 of the 164 NFL cappers on our board now have the 15 decided picks needed to carry a weight other than 1.00.

How this changes the card

This night moved real weight, and most of it moved away from the room that built the losing play. The six Sports Illustrated writers who laid -270 on Green Bay all gave some back: Peter Dewey slipped from 1.16 to 1.12 (20-12), Verderame and Kadlick from 1.15 to 1.13 (18-10 each), Manzano from 1.11 to 1.09 (17-11), Goldich to 1.01 and Pluym below even at 0.99. That group is still the best-graded room we track and still carries more weight than a capper we have never seen hit, but a 70%-consensus moneyline drawn almost entirely from one staff column is exactly the concentration risk we flagged in the card itself, and it is what cost the card.

Moving the other way: Moe Moton crossed the 15-pick threshold with Thursday’s winner and enters the board at 1.10 on a 10-5 record — one of the nine highest weights we carry. And a caution against overreacting to one night: the day’s biggest winner, Iain MacMillan, is 23-27 (46.0%) across everything we have graded him on and sits at 0.90, below neutral. Thursday was his best night of the season, not evidence that he should be steering the consensus. SportsGrid (6 decided), Anthony Rome (5) and Chris Farley (5) all remain at a flat 1.00 — we are still building their samples, and none of them was weighted on anything Thursday. Joe Osborne (@JTFOz) and Tony Sink (@DocsSports), both at 9 decided picks, are the closest to qualifying.

Season to date — NFL

Tier Spread Moneyline Totals Overall Units
STRONG 1-3-0 0-1-0 8-6-1 9-10-1 -1.76
LEAN 1-2-0 1-0-0 2-1-0 4-3-0 +0.15
Card total 2-5-0 1-1-0 10-7-1 13-13-1 -1.61
FADE-WATCH (0 units staked) 2-1-0 — — 2-1-0 0.00

Five NFL grading days in the book. The totals book is carrying the season — STRONG totals are 8-6-1 for +1.24 units — while the sides have not yet returned a profit at 2-5 on spreads. Every line above comes from the results ledger, not from re-adding the sheets by hand.

Grading notes

Graded off the confirmed final: Atlanta 35, Green Bay 14 at Lambeau Field, no overtime, with ESPN, NFL.com and FOX Sports in agreement. Units are flat one-unit stakes priced at the line stored in the card; expert picks published without a price are graded at -110. Two logged expert picks sit outside the full-game tallies but are graded anyway — FanDuel Research’s Packers first half -2.5 (Atlanta led 17-7 at the break, loss) and BetMGM’s Packers team total Over 24.5 (Green Bay scored 14, loss). WalterFootball logged its Falcons +6.5 as a zero-unit lean; we grade it at the house flat stake for consistency and note the difference here.

Gamble responsibly. Bets are for entertainment, never money you need — if it stops being fun, call 1-800-GAMBLER.

DailyOverlay Premium

Get the full graded consensus — every slate.

Free for 5 days, then $19.99/mo. Cancel anytime.

Start your free trial →