NHL Consensus Weekly Recap — Who’s Hot / Who’s Not — Week of Nov 9–Nov 15, 2026

Who was hot in NHL this week (Nov 9–15): Jay Cooper (Ultimate Capper) went 19-18-0 for +4.93u; season with us 63-68-0, +3.42u. Right behind: David Anicetti (Winners and Whiners) went 9-3-0 for +4.40u; season with us 15-9-0, +3.28u, and Guy Bruhn (Doc's Sports) went 6-4-0 for +3.89u; season with us 18-18-0, -1.76u. Every graded pick from all 96 sources we track is graded publicly on the site.

The card this week

The consensus STRONG plays went 26-19-0 for +2.17u. The LEAN tier went 7-9-0 for -2.64u. Together the card finished 33-28-0 for -0.47u across seven graded days; FADE-WATCH plays went 1-2-0 and carry 0 units. Full tier-by-tier history is on the consensus record page.

Market check

The moneyline carried the week at the top of the card: STRONG moneyline plays went 17-9-0 (+5.00u), the best market-and-tier spot on the board. Totals were close to even — STRONG 9-8-0 (-0.83u), LEAN 4-3-0 (+0.66u). The puck line was mixed: STRONG 0-2-0 (-2.00u), LEAN 2-1-0 (+0.70u). The weak spot was LEAN moneyline plays at 1-5-0 (-4.00u), which accounted for most of the LEAN tier’s loss. Across all 96 experts the field hit 52.6% (337-304-1, +0.32u); the card’s STRONG + LEAN plays hit 54.1%.

Hot this week

Expert Outlet W-L-P Hit rate Units
Jay Cooper Ultimate Capper 19-18-0 51.4% +4.93u
David Anicetti Winners and Whiners 9-3-0 75.0% +4.40u
Guy Bruhn Doc's Sports 6-4-0 60.0% +3.89u
Nick Martin Action Network 4-0-0 100.0% +3.60u
Braden Morrison Last Word on Sports 5-2-0 71.4% +3.24u
Kim Smith StatSalt 9-5-0 64.3% +2.67u
Josh Schonwald Doc's Sports 5-3-0 62.5% +2.63u
Robert Criscola Covers 3-1-0 75.0% +2.60u
Jon Yaremko Pickswise 5-3-0 62.5% +2.19u
Alex MacMillan Winners and Whiners 9-7-0 56.3% +2.16u

Minimum 3 graded picks this week.

Season leaders

Expert Record Units Consensus weight
iHeart Model 133-92-2 +12.56u 1.20
Doc's Sports – Josh Schonwald 22-14-0 +8.39u 1.11
Sportsgambler – Robert Carter 19-11-0 +5.73u 1.12
CBS Sports 100-72-2 +5.06u 1.16
Doc's Sports – Parlays Pundit 14-10-0 +4.51u 1.06
Pickswise – Mark Lammey 17-10-0 +3.89u 1.11
Ultimate Capper – Jay Cooper 63-68-0 +3.42u 0.89
Winners and Whiners – David Anicetti 15-9-0 +3.28u 1.10
Pick Dawgz – Nikos Lagouretos 21-15-0 +2.78u 1.08
Pickswise – Jon Yaremko 12-9-0 +2.22u 1.04
StatSalt – Kim Smith 19-14-0 +2.19u 1.06
TheSpread – Paul Elliot 13-10-0 +1.73u 1.04
Sports Chat Place – Chris Ruffolo 15-8-0 +1.44u 1.12
Pickswise – Connor Grootenhuis 9-7-0 +1.34u 1.03
Covers – Dustin Saracini 11-8-0 +1.33u 1.04
Doc's Sports – Tony Sink 18-14-0 +0.84u 1.05

Minimum 15 graded picks, in profit for the season. The full graded record for every source, good weeks and bad, is public on the grading pages.

What we’re watching

LEAN moneyline plays are the soft spot: 1-5-0 (-4.00u) this week and 9-15-0 (-6.93u) on the season, while STRONG moneyline plays sit at 41-27-0 (+4.67u). Next week we are watching whether that gap holds — when the experts are only loosely aligned on a side, the moneyline has not been paying, and we will keep reporting those LEAN sides separately from the STRONG tier.

Please bet responsibly. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER.

DailyOverlay Premium

Get the full graded consensus — every slate.

Free for 5 days, then $19.99/mo. Cancel anytime.

Start your free trial →

Season to date — the card

Live from the grading ledger, so it includes every game graded since this recap went up.

NHL consensus card

Graded Oct 24 – Nov 15 · 23 graded days
Card (STRONG + LEAN)
97-86
-6.21u · 53%
STRONG
72-53
+4.34u · 57.6%
LEAN
25-33
-10.55u · 43.1%
Last 7 graded days
33-28
-0.47u · 54.1%
TierPuck lineMoneylineTotal
STRONG10-5 +3.87u41-27 +4.67u21-21 -4.20u
LEAN5-4 +0.97u9-15 -6.93u11-14 -4.59u

FADE-WATCH (tracked, not staked, kept out of the card record): 1-5.

Every graded play, day by day →

Every sport’s consensus record →

Flat 1-unit stakes at the line and price we posted before the game. STRONG and LEAN are tiered before the game starts and graded against the confirmed final the next morning. Updated automatically from the grading ledger.