CFB Expert Grading – 2018

CFB Industry Expert Grading – 2018

The Daily Overlay team keeps track of top college football expert predictions. We then grade the experts this information each week and share it with our visitors and top performing experts. Our goal is to see who is great, who is really good, and who is not so hot, so you will know who to trust. Also, check out our Grading Process.


Every DO Score below is computed from that entry’s own A+ through F grade counts, and every row has been checked against those counts.

Rank Expert / Product Picks A+ A B C D F DO Score
1 DailyOverlay.com single pick 15 4 3 0 3 2 3 4.20
2 DFS Karma 53 17 0 9 8 3 16 4.08
3 RG CFB Marketplace Projections 186 45 29 20 28 17 47 3.91
4 RotoGrinders Consensus Plays 183 41 22 23 36 14 47 3.69
5 SportingNews 91 21 10 10 12 13 25 3.59
6 ScoutFantasySports 37 8 5 2 3 5 14 3.30
7 CFBDynasty.com 106 21 7 13 20 14 31 3.19
8 Rotoballer 72 13 9 6 13 6 25 3.13
9 TheDailyAudible 81 13 10 15 11 3 29 3.09
10 Fantasy Alarm 255 42 28 36 42 28 79 3.06
11 RotoGrinders – Lineup Builder 95 17 11 10 10 12 35 3.02
12 Industry Consensus 493 85 49 68 63 58 170 3.01
13 DailyFantasySportsRankings 108 19 8 16 16 9 40 2.95
14 FantasyCPR 248 43 22 30 35 27 91 2.93
15 DailyOverlay Power Five 233 35 28 28 35 32 75 2.90
16 ProFootballFocus 119 17 12 19 19 12 40 2.83
17 Sportsline 44 6 4 8 6 2 18 2.68
18 DFS Army 197 30 20 20 24 20 83 2.68
19 WiseTake Top Plays 135 20 7 18 18 15 57 2.52
20 DailyRoto 227 29 18 25 36 34 85 2.47
21 AthlonSports.com 147 18 9 20 23 23 54 2.41
22 Rotoworld 149 15 10 18 22 19 65 2.13