NHL Expert Grading – 2023-2024

NHL Expert Grading – 2023-24

The Daily Overlay team keeps track of top NHL expert predictions. We then grade this information each week and share it with our visitors and top performing experts. Our goal is to see who is great, who is really good, and who is not so hot, so you will know who to trust. Also, check out our Grading Process.


Every DO Score below is computed from that entry’s own A+ through F grade counts, and every row has been checked against those counts.

Rank Expert / Product Picks A+ A B C D F DO Score
1 RotoGrinders Core 140 38 14 19 15 13 41 3.93
2 Rotogrinders NHL Slate Summary 221 49 22 32 24 21 73 3.46
3 DFSArmy – Cheatsheet 476 102 42 60 46 40 186 3.24
4 Industry Consensus – Cash 966 189 99 111 111 93 363 3.14
5 RotoGrinders Lineup Builder 576 107 50 68 52 62 237 2.93
6 RunPureSports 1539 257 155 197 205 149 576 2.92
7 RiseOrFall 318 50 38 44 26 35 125 2.86
8 Rotowire 912 135 78 90 104 95 410 2.54
9 DFSArmy – Domination Station 591 89 45 55 65 68 269 2.50
10 Stokastic – Cheatsheet 793 119 55 83 78 95 363 2.48
11 DailyFantasyFuel – Optimizer 588 85 47 47 59 65 285 2.40
12 Industry Consensus – GPP 1087 137 96 137 109 114 494 2.39
13 FantasyGuru 2175 293 180 209 243 249 1001 2.39
14 DailyFantasyNerd 577 75 52 60 65 58 267 2.39
15 Rotowire – Optimizer 566 74 51 64 49 67 261 2.39
16 NumberFire 600 81 50 59 59 61 290 2.36
17 Rotoballer 342 41 30 41 36 34 160 2.31
18 NHL.com 123 13 5 6 16 14 69 1.78