NHL Expert Grading – 2025-2026

NHL Expert Grading – 2025-26

The Daily Overlay team keeps track of top NHL expert predictions. We then grade this information each week and share it with our visitors and top performing experts. Our goal is to see who is great, who is really good, and who is not so hot, so you will know who to trust. Also, check out our Grading Process.


Every DO Score below is computed from that entry’s own A+ through F grade counts, and every row has been checked against those counts.

Rank Expert / Product Picks A+ A B C D F DO Score
1 RotoGrinders Lineup Builder 761 129 64 98 82 102 286 2.85
2 Industry Consensus – Cash 1199 195 117 136 133 146 472 2.80
3 RunPureSports 2604 364 231 269 279 308 1153 2.48
4 Rotowire – Optimizer 751 105 54 89 79 89 335 2.44
5 RotoGrinders Core 684 105 44 56 56 105 318 2.42
6 DailyFantasyNerd 719 97 62 74 66 97 323 2.41
7 Rotowire 920 113 89 94 107 113 404 2.37
8 DFSArmy – Cheatsheet 1123 147 93 105 133 128 517 2.35
9 FantasyGuru 2397 301 217 248 256 255 1120 2.34
10 DailyFantasyFuel – Optimizer 745 97 59 74 76 106 333 2.34
11 DFSArmy – Domination Station 749 100 54 76 71 96 352 2.32
12 Industry Consensus – GPP 1448 181 123 147 155 166 676 2.31
13 NHL.com 287 29 16 16 23 38 165 1.75