CFB Sportsbook Consensus Grading Recap — Friday, October 23, 2026
47 experts graded on 5 games — Anthony Rome (TheSpread) leads at 10-2, +9.49u. Card 5-2 (+2.68u), every play graded at the posted line.
47 experts graded on 5 games — Anthony Rome (TheSpread) leads at 10-2, +9.49u. Card 5-2 (+2.68u), every play graded at the posted line.
39 experts graded on 2 games — Pete Fiutak and Connor O’Gara (College Football News) lead at 2-0, +1.82u each. Card 0-4 (-4.00u), every play graded at the posted line.
College Football News – Doug Millen led every graded source this week at 16-3-0 (84.2%) for +11.56 units, with VSiN – Steve Makinen at 9-1-0 (+7.19u) right behind. The consensus card went 11-10-0 for -0.71 units on the week — STRONG 7-6-0 (+0.31u), LEAN 4-4-0 (-1.02u).
153 experts graded on 52 games — Doug Millen (College Football News) leads at 13-3, +8.83u. Card 5-5 (-0.41u), every play graded at the posted line.
50 experts graded on 3 games — Doug Millen (College Football News) leads a four-way tie at 2-0, +1.82u. Card 2-3 (-1.16u), every play graded at the posted line.
50 experts graded on 3 games — Thom Cunningham (Lineups) leads at 3-0, +2.71u. Card 4-2 (+0.86u), every play graded at the posted line.
The DRatings model went 30-12 (+15.30u) and CBS Sports’ John Talty 16-3 (+11.56u) on last week’s CFB board, with College Football News’ Andre Cherry 14-4 (+8.74u) right behind. The consensus card went 12-11 (-0.54u) with STRONG plays 10-6 (+3.18u). 1,372 expert picks graded from 154 sources.
140 experts and models graded on 46 games — the DRatings model leads the day at 30-12 (+15.30u) and John Talty of CBS Sports went 14-3 (+9.74u). Card 6-5 (+0.52u), STRONG 5-3 (+1.61u), every play graded at the line we posted.
67 experts and models graded on five Friday games — FanSided’s Chris Landers leads the day at 5-0, +4.55u, and CBS Sports’ Tom Fornelli went 2-0 to take over the top of our CFB board at 27-15-3, +9.57u. The consensus card went 4-3 (+0.66u) with the STRONG plays 4-2 (+1.66u), every play graded at the line we posted.
53 experts graded across four games – the Odds Shark computer led the day at 4-0-1 (+3.64u) and FanDuel Research went a perfect 3-0 (+2.69u). Consensus card 2-3 (-1.72 units), every play graded at the line we posted.
Big Game Ben (College Football News) led the CFB board at 13-6, +5.83u, with SportsBettingDime’s Chris Amberley a perfect 6-0 (+5.42u) and three FOX Sports pickers at 6-2-1 (+3.46u each). The consensus card went 10-9 for +1.15 units; totals were the one losing market.
80 experts and models graded across 52 games — SportsBettingDime’s Chris Amberley leads the day at 6-0, +5.42u, with Covers’ Rob Paul 13-8 (+3.83u) on the widest card of anyone. Consensus card 5-4 (+1.08u), every play graded at the line we posted.