Fourteen games on this Tuesday. Plenty of aces to load up on and the Consensus provides some solid value bats to squeeze into those lineups tonight. The Consensus was spread out across the board team-wise as there are only two stack options tonight, the Red Sox and Tigers. Make sure to check the weather before posting those lineups…it’s that time of year.

If you are a fan of this Industry Expert Consensus article then you will love our newest feature only available to Email Subscribers, called the “Weighted Consensus”. In the Weighted Consensus, we provide a more in-depth version of the MLB Consensus that take into account each expert’s current DailyOverlay scored to generate weighted rankings. If you have ever wondered how to differentiate between two players that were selected by the same number of experts then this is the tool you need. We also list all players selected by at least two experts. Sign up now for a small fee and get emails for this feature as well as the rest of our free content.

Scroll to the bottom of the article for the “Top Stacks” section that lists out the teams with the most hitters being recommended by the experts today. Also, be sure to check each team’s lineup when it is released and watch the weather before finalizing your lineups tonight.


  • David Price (10x)
  • Chris Sale (8x)
  • Stephen Strasburg (8x)
  • Jeff Samardzija (8x)
  • Nathan Karns (4x)
  • Justin Verlander (4x)
  • Julio Teheran (3x)


  • Stephen Vogt (5x)
  • Welington Castillo (5x)
  • Buster Posey (4x)
  • Brian McCann (4x)


  • Chris Davis (8x)
  • Miguel Cabrera (6x)
  • Paul Goldschmidt (3x)
  • Hanley Ramirez (3x)
  • Jose Abreu (3x)


  • Robinson Cano (6x)
  • Rougned Odor (5x)
  • Jose Altuve (3x)
  • Jimmy Paredes (3x)
  • Daniel Murphy (3x)


  • Manny Machado (SS/3B) (8x)
  • Xander Bogaerts (6x)
  • Carlos Correa (5x)
  • Brandon Crawford (3x)


  • Todd Frazier (4x)
  • Yunel Escobar (4x)


  • Chris Young (7x)
  • Leonys Martin (5x)
  • Mike Trout (5x)
  • Michael Saunders (4x)
  • Gregory Polanco (4x)
  • JD Martinez (4x)
  • Mookie Betts (3x)
  • Cameron Maybin (3x)

Top Stacks of the Night

  • Red Sox (4) – Ramirez, Bogaerts, Young, Betts
  • Tigers (3) – Cabrera, Martinez, Maybin

Hope you find the right combination to cash! Follow me on Twitter @mbutlerok.